| Year | Name | School | | 1947 | John Gillespie | Prep | | 1948 | None selected | | | 1949 | Ernie Beck | West | | 1950 | Tom Gola | La Salle | | 1951 | Tom Gola | La Salle | | 1952 | John "Misty" Fannon | ST More | | 1953 | Bill Lindsay | West | | 1954 | Bob Devine | West | | 1955 | Joe Ryan | Prep | | 1956 | Jim Kenny | North | | 1957 | Tom Samulewicz | North | | 1958 | Jim Gannon | Neumann | | 1959 | Billy Hoy | More | | 1960 | Frank Corace | Bonner | | 1961 | George Sutor | Judge | | 1962 | Matt Guokas Jr. | Prep | | 1963 | Chuck Storm | Roman | | 1964 | Rich Berberian | West | | 1965 | Frank Gillen | Neumann | | 1966 | Mike Hauer | Bonner | | 1967 | Bob Atene | Neumann | | 1968 | Hank Siemiontkowski | North | | 1969 | Tom Ingelsby | O'Hara | | 1970 | Jim O'Brien | Roman | | 1971 | Bill Magarity | Dougherty | | 1972 | Mo Howard | Prep | | 1973 | Jim "Chico" Singleton | Roman | | 1974 | Lloyd Ranson | Neumann | | 1975 | Zane Major | Roman | | 1976 | Michael Brooks | West | | 1977 | Fran McCaffery | La Salle | | 1978 | Reggie Jackson | Roman | | 1979 | Steve Senko | Ryan | | 1980 | Lonnie McFarlan | Roman | | 1981 | Randy Monroe | Roman | | 1982 | Chip Greenberg | La Salle | | 1983 | Dallas Comegys | Roman | | 1984 | Rodney Blake | Bonner | | 1985 | Mark Stevenson | Roman | | 1986 | Barry Bekkedam | Carroll | | 1987 | Vince Curran | Prep | | 1988 | Brian Daly | Bonner | | 1989 | Eddie Malloy | O'Hara | | 1990 | Chris Mooney | Ryan | | 1991 | Bernard Jones | Roman | | 1992 | Cuttino "Cat" Mobley | Dough | | 1993 | Marc Jackson | Roman | | 1994 | Rashid Bey | Neum | | 1995 | Lari Ketner | Roman | | 1996 | Donnie Carr | Roman | | 1997 | Martin Ingelsby | Carroll | | 1998 | Rasual Butler | Roman | | 1999 | Kasim Holloman | Prep | | Tim Whalen | Wood | | 2000 | Eddie Griffin | Roman | | 2001 | Tamal Forchion | Roman | | 2002 | Mike Spadafora | Wood | | 2003 | Mark Zoller | Prep | | 2004 | Charron Fisher | Roman | | 2005 | Matt Spadafora | Wood | | 2006 | Mike Ringgold | Roman | | 2007 | Jeff Jones | Bonner | | 2008 | Andrew Rogers | Ryan | | 2009 | Maalik Wayns | Roman | | 2010 | Tony Chennault | N-G | | 2011 | Lamin Fulton | N-G | | Juan'ya Green | Carroll | | 2012 | Gene Williams | Prep | | 2013 | Steve Vasturia | Prep | | 2014 | Ja'Quan Newton | N-G | | 2015 | Chris Clover | Prep | | 2016 | Ryan Daly | Carroll | | 2017 | Collin Gillespie | Wood | | 2018 | Andrew Funk | Wood | | 2019 | Hakim Hart | Roman | | 2020 | Jordan Hall | N-G | | 2021 | Not selected | | | 2022 | Daniel Skillings | Roman |
| | Most Honorees by School | | Year | Roman Catholic (21) | | 1963 | Chuck Storm | | 1970 | Jim O'Brien | | 1973 | Jim "Chico" Singleton | | 1975 | Zane Major | | 1978 | Reggie Jackson | | 1980 | Lonnie McFarlan | | 1981 | Randy Monroe | | 1983 | Dallas Comegys | | 1985 | Mark Stevenson | | 1991 | Bernard Jones | | 1993 | Marc Jackson | | 1995 | Lari Ketner | | 1996 | Donnie Carr | | 1998 | Rasual Butler | | 2000 | Eddie Griffin | | 2001 | Tamal Forchion | | 2004 | Charron Fisher | | 2006 | Mike Ringgold | | 2009 | Maalik Wayns | | 2019 | Hakim Hart | | 2022 | Daniel Skillings | | Year | St. Joseph's Prep (10) | | 1947 | John Gillespie | | 1955 | Joe Ryan | | 1962 | Matt Guokas Jr. | | 1972 | Mo Howard | | 1987 | Vince Curran | | 1999 | Kasim Holloman | | 2003 | Mark Zoller | | 2012 | Gene Williams | | 2013 | Steve Vasturia | | 2015 | Chris Clover | | Year | Neumann/N-G (9) | | 1958 | Jim Gannon | | 1965 | Frank Gillen | | 1967 | Bob Atene | | 1974 | Lloyd Ranson | | 1994 | Rashid Bey | | 2010 | Tony Chennault | | 2011 | Lamin Fulton | | 2014 | Ja'Quan Newton | | 2020 | Jordan Hall | | Year | Bonner (5) | | 1960 | Frank Corace | | 1966 | Mike Hauer | | 1984 | Rodney Blake | | 1988 | Brian Daly | | 2007 | Jeff Jones | | Year | West Catholic (5) | | 1949 | Ernie Beck | | 1953 | Bill Lindsay | | 1954 | Bob Devine | | 1964 | Rich Berberian | | 1976 | Michael Brooks | | Year | Wood (5) | | 1999 | Tim Whalen | | 2002 | Mike Spadafora | | 2005 | Matt Spadafora | | 2017 | Collin Gillespie | | 2018 | Andrew Funk | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |