Philadelphia High School Sports
All-City
Honorees, by School, A to L
(Sorted by First Name)
(First, Second or
Third Team in Football/Basketball/Baseball)
(Guys with nicknames appear at beginning of entries for their real name)
**All-City baseball/football teams not selected, 2019-forward.**
Return to TedSilary.com Home Page
| SCHOOL | SPORT | TEAM | YEAR |
| Audenried | |||
| Abdul Taylor | Bask | First | 1996 |
| Bartram | |||
| Abraham Holman | FB | Second | 1993 |
| Al-Hajj Shabazz | FB | Second | 2009 |
| Answered Gleplay | FB | Second | 2015 |
| Antonio Zachary | FB | First | 1972 |
| Bill Bailey | FB | Second | 1990 |
| Billy Dunfee | FB | First | 1986 |
| Billy Dunfee | Base | First | 1987 |
| Bobby Adams | Base | Second | 1982 |
| Bobby Leach | Bask | Second | 2001 |
| Bryan Anderson | FB | Second | 1995 |
| Bryan Anderson | FB | Second | 1996 |
| Bryan Anderson | FB | First | 1997 |
| Carlos Edwards | FB | Second | 1978 |
| Charles Evans | FB | Second | 1976 |
| Charles Jones | Bask | Third | 2003 |
| Chironn "Goober" Davis | FB | Second | 2001 |
| Chris Greene | FB | Third | 1987 |
| Clarence Norwood | FB | Second | 1977 |
| Clement Tuck | FB | Second | 1974 |
| Clyde Peterson | Base | Second | 1982 |
| Damond Warren | FB | Third | 1982 |
| Darrell Lane | FB | Second | 2009 |
| David Boone | FB | Second | 1981 |
| David Boone | FB | First | 1982 |
| David Martin | FB | First | 1976 |
| Davon Thompson | FB | First | 2017 |
| Don Massenburg | FB | Second | 1977 |
| Don Speller | FB | Third | 1978 |
| Elijah Clark | FB | Second | 2012 |
| Erik Williams | FB | First | 1985 |
| Gary Samuels | FB | Second | 1983 |
| George Williams | FB | First | 1990 |
| Greg Spence | FB | Third | 1983 |
| Greg Spence | FB | Second | 1984 |
| Hanson Teah | FB | Second | 2016 |
| Hector Scott | FB | Second | 1983 |
| Ibraheim Diouane | FB | First | 2017 |
| James Thompson | FB | Second | 1985 |
| Jason Cain | Bask | First | 2003 |
| Jeff Gold | FB | Third | 1979 |
| Jim Corsaro | FB | Third | 1986 |
| Jimmy Adams | Base | Third | 1981 |
| Joe Bryant | Bask | First | 1972 |
| Joseph Smith | FB | Third | 2001 |
| Julian Graham | FB | Second | 1993 |
| Julian Graham | FB | First | 1994 |
| Julius Carter | FB | Third | 2005 |
| Keith Gentry | Base | Third | 1979 |
| Kennis Jones | FB | First | 2003 |
| Kenny Glass | Bask | Third | 1982 |
| Kevin Deloatch | FB | Second | 1981 |
| Kevin DeWalt | FB | Third | 1982 |
| Larry Gainey | Bask | Third | 1977 |
| Leon "Duke" Linder | Bask | Third | 1980 |
| Mack Taylor | FB | Second | 1997 |
| Mack Taylor | FB | First | 1998 |
| Mahlmud Dioubate | FB | First | 2016 |
| Mahlmud Dioubate | FB | First | 2017 |
| Malcolm Brown | FB | Second | 1981 |
| Manny Carlis | FB | First | 1983 |
| Marquis Broxton | FB | Third | 2014 |
| Marquise Carrington | Bask | Third | 2005 |
| Marvin Snipes | FB | Third | 2002 |
| Matt Wilder | FB | Second | 1991 |
| Maurice Jessup | FB | First | 2006 |
| Maurice Stovall | FB | Second | 1978 |
| Maurice Suggs | FB | Second | 1997 |
| Michael Gold | FB | First | 1976 |
| Michael White | FB | Third | 1976 |
| Mike Morton | Base | Second | 1981 |
| Nasir Savage | FB | Second | 2018 |
| Novar Gadson | Bask | Second | 2008 |
| Paul Northern | FB | Third | 1996 |
| Paul Northern | FB | First | 1997 |
| Phil "Weasel" Melton | Bask | Third | 1991 |
| R.B. Williams | FB | Second | 1989 |
| Reggie Isaac | Bask | Second | 1986 |
| Rendell Bradley | Bask | Third | 1974 |
| Richard Francis | Bask | First | 2002 |
| Romar Drake | FB | Second | 2001 |
| Rufus Dorsey | FB | Second | 1988 |
| Russell Calloway | FB | Second | 2010 |
| Steve Guida | Base | Third | 2000 |
| Tarik Bey | FB | Third | 2018 |
| Tom Dunfee | FB | First | 1977 |
| Tom Dunfee | Base | First | 1978 |
| Tyron Cheeseboro | FB | Second | 2008 |
| Tyrone Garland | Bask | First | 2009 |
| Tyrone Garland | Bask | First | 2010 |
| Tyrone Mason | Bask | Third | 1990 |
| Tyrone Mason | Bask | Third | 1991 |
| Tyrone Myers | FB | First | 1971 |
| Tywain McKee | Bask | Third | 2004 |
| Vince Imparato | FB | Third | 1979 |
| Zack Turner | FB | First | 1977 |
| Bodine | |||
| Anwar Amin | Bask | Third | 1993 |
| Bok | |||
| Aaron Hayes | FB | Third | 2003 |
| Ackeem Clarke | FB | Second | 2007 |
| Akeem "Feathers" Green | FB | Third | 2002 |
| Alan Joynes | FB | Third | 1987 |
| Antoine Whitney | FB | First | 2012 |
| Brahkim Poole | FB | Third | 2008 |
| Cedric Green | FB | Second | 2003 |
| Charles Kennedy | FB | Third | 1988 |
| Charles Kennnedy | FB | First | 1999 |
| Cornelius Braxton | FB | Third | 1980 |
| Cornelius Braxton | FB | Third | 1981 |
| David Carolina | FB | Third | 1988 |
| Derrick Evans | FB | Second | 1988 |
| Ed Brumskill | FB | Third | 1999 |
| Ed Brumskill | FB | Second | 2000 |
| Eddie Turner | FB | First | 1998 |
| Eddie Williams | FB | Second | 1981 |
| Fred Warrick | Bask | Second | 1994 |
| James Holmes | FB | Third | 1990 |
| Jihard Ward | FB | Second | 2010 |
| Jihard Ward | FB | First | 2011 |
| Keith Williams | FB | Second | 2005 |
| Kevin Beaford | Bask | Second | 1979 |
| Kevin Thompson | FB | Second | 2009 |
| Khalil Neal | FB | Second | 2010 |
| Larry Pelzer | FB | Third | 2012 |
| Luke Lassiter | FB | Second | 2007 |
| Mark "Spider" Webb | FB | Third | 2012 |
| Mark Hobbs | FB | Third | 1980 |
| Mark Lowman | FB | Third | 1994 |
| Maurice Goodwin | FB | Second | 2006 |
| Michael Gales | FB | Third | 1994 |
| Michael Gales | FB | Third | 1995 |
| Michael Russell | FB | First | 1991 |
| Michael Russell | FB | First | 1992 |
| Naeem Nunnally | FB | Second | 2009 |
| Nick Perrone | FB | Second | 2005 |
| Phillip Ricks | FB | Second | 1987 |
| Ralph Sheridan | FB | Second | 1999 |
| Ramon Mills | FB | First | 1999 |
| Ramon Mills | FB | First | 2000 |
| Ray Tucker | FB | Second | 2008 |
| Raymond Felder | FB | Second | 1979 |
| Rodney McCarter | FB | Third | 2000 |
| Ron Kenney | Base | Third | 2000 |
| Ron Kenney | Base | Third | 2001 |
| Ryan Murray | FB | Second | 2006 |
| Ryan Murray | FB | Second | 2007 |
| Shaquil Sammons | FB | Second | 2011 |
| Shaquille Sammons | FB | Third | 2010 |
| Sharif Brown | Bask | Third | 1997 |
| Shawn Jeter | FB | Third | 2001 |
| Shawn White | FB | Third | 1988 |
| Shon Thompkins | FB | Third | 2005 |
| Tawan Miller | FB | Third | 1993 |
| Terry Glasgow | FB | Second | 1985 |
| Tony Dowe | FB | Second | 1971 |
| Troy Martin | FB | Third | 2008 |
| Vincent Thompson | FB | Second | 1986 |
| Vittorio "Vito" Goggins | FB | Second | 2012 |
| William Warfield | FB | Second | 1997 |
| Bonner / Bonner-Prendie | |||
| To Base '12 / FB '12 Forward | |||
| Alex Liberatore | Base | Second | 2010 |
| Anthony Becht | FB | Second | 1994 |
| Art Serano | FB | Third | 1986 |
| Art Serano | FB | First | 1987 |
| Ashley Howard | Bask | Second | 1999 |
| Bert Wenzel | FB | First | 1999 |
| Bill Collins | FB | Third | 1995 |
| Bill Tidmarsh | FB | Second | 1972 |
| Bill Whalen | FB | Second | 1990 |
| Bob Sadwick | Base | Second | 1990 |
| Brandon Fickenscher | FB | Second | 1990 |
| Brandon Fickenscher | Base | Second | 1991 |
| Brian "Sluggo" Fleming | FB | Third | 1994 |
| Brian Campbell | FB | Second | 1991 |
| Brian Daly | Bask | First | 1988 |
| Brian McCoach | Base | Third | 1997 |
| Brian Meagher | Base | Third | 2006 |
| Brian Morrow | FB | Third | 1994 |
| Brian Morrow | FB | First | 1995 |
| Chris Hemmert | FB | Second | 1993 |
| Chris Hemmert | FB | First | 1994 |
| Chris Schrader | FB | Second | 2001 |
| Chris Schrader | FB | Second | 2002 |
| Chuck Chupein | FB | Third | 1985 |
| Chuck Raech | Base | Second | 1978 |
| Chuck Raech | Base | Second | 1979 |
| Conor Kerins | Base | Second | 2007 |
| Conor Kerins | Base | First | 2008 |
| Dan Auld | Base | Third | 2000 |
| Dan Auld | Base | First | 2001 |
| Dan Brodeur | FB | First | 1981 |
| Dan DiRita | FB | First | 1989 |
| Dan Hastings | Bask | Third | 1977 |
| Dan Hirst | Base | First | 1982 |
| Dan Horan | FB | Third | 1980 |
| Dan Mulholland | Base | First | 1998 |
| Dan Summers | FB | First | 1987 |
| Dan Williams | Base | Third | 2009 |
| Dave Burns | FB | Third | 1976 |
| Dennis Moran | Base | Second | 1998 |
| Dom Armideo | FB | First | 2001 |
| Dom DiGalbo | FB | Third | 2011 |
| Drew Schiller | FB | Third | 2003 |
| Earl McNeil | FB | Third | 2003 |
| Ed Monaghan | FB | First | 1982 |
| Ed Monaghan | FB | First | 1983 |
| Ed Monaghan | FB | First | 1984 |
| Eric Petransky | FB | Second | 2009 |
| Fran Nelling | FB | Third | 1997 |
| Frank Nunan | Base | First | 2003 |
| Frank Saviski | Base | Third | 2012 |
| Frank Saviski | Base | Second | 2013 |
| Gene Stickley | FB | Second | 1990 |
| George Myers | FB | Second | 1993 |
| Greg Kirwan | FB | First | 1992 |
| Greg McEntee | FB | Second | 1991 |
| Greg Venuti | FB | Third | 1992 |
| Harry Binck | FB | Second | 1991 |
| Ivan "Pick" Brown | Bask | First | 1986 |
| Jack Concannon | Bask | Second | 1983 |
| Jack McCoy | Base | Second | 1988 |
| Jack McCoy | Base | First | 1989 |
| James Colivas | FB | Second | 2009 |
| Jeff Jones | Bask | Second | 2006 |
| Jeff Jones | Bask | First | 2007 |
| Jeff Morelli | FB | Second | 1991 |
| Jeff Tinari | Base | Third | 1989 |
| Jerry Coughlan | FB | Second | 1986 |
| Jerry Hunt | FB | First | 1984 |
| Jim Chupein | FB | Third | 1980 |
| Jim Chupein | FB | First | 1981 |
| Jim Corkery | FB | Third | 1991 |
| Jim Haley | FB | First | 2011 |
| Jim Haley | Base | Third | 2012 |
| Jim Tully | Base | First | 1998 |
| Joe Gallagher | FB | First | 1985 |
| Joe Haley | FB | Third | 2011 |
| Joe McGilligan | Base | Third | 2005 |
| Joe Nestor | Base | Third | 2010 |
| Joe Sopczynski | FB | First | 1972 |
| Joe Summers | FB | Second | 1998 |
| Joe Whinnery | FB | Third | 1978 |
| John Chupein | FB | First | 1982 |
| John DeFruscio | FB | Third | 1988 |
| John Schmitt | FB | First | 1980 |
| John Stauffer | FB | Third | 1998 |
| Jon Bystrek | FB | Third | 1994 |
| Jon Bystrek | Base | Second | 1995 |
| Jon Schaffer | Base | Third | 1987 |
| Jon Schaffer | Base | First | 1988 |
| Josh VanHorn | Base | Third | 2010 |
| Ken DeFeo | FB | Second | 1977 |
| Kevin Horning | Base | Third | 2003 |
| Kevin LeSage | FB | Third | 2000 |
| Kevin LeSage | FB | First | 2001 |
| Kevin O'Sullivan | FB | Second | 1979 |
| Kevin Ward | Base | First | 2004 |
| Kevin Ward | Base | First | 2005 |
| Kyle Kollmar | FB | First | 1989 |
| Larry DelViscio | FB | Third | 2008 |
| Lou Cristinziani | FB | Second | 1989 |
| Lou Tomasetti | FB | Second | 1975 |
| Marcus Collins | FB | First | 2010 |
| Mark Mulroy | Bask | Third | 1993 |
| Mark Turturici | FB | Third | 1997 |
| Matt Blong | FB | Third | 2002 |
| Matt Dolan | Base | Second | 2011 |
| Matt Giello | FB | First | 1995 |
| Matt Kern | Base | Second | 2006 |
| Matt Licci | FB | Second | 2004 |
| Matt Mullen | Base | Third | 2010 |
| Mike Dunn | Base | Third | 2006 |
| Mike Finnerty | FB | Second | 1971 |
| Mike Hemmert | FB | First | 1991 |
| Mike Hemmert | FB | First | 1992 |
| Mike Kollhoff | FB | Second | 1983 |
| Mike Kozak | FB | Third | 2001 |
| Mike Lombardi | FB | First | 1972 |
| Mike Mitros | FB | First | 1994 |
| Mike Mitros | Base | Third | 1995 |
| Mike Nestor | Bask | Third | 1995 |
| Mike Nolan | FB | Second | 2004 |
| Mike Pecko | FB | Third | 1989 |
| Mike Shalon | Base | Second | 2003 |
| Mike Sherlock | FB | First | 1976 |
| Mike Stack | Bask | Second | 1972 |
| Mike Staehle | Base | Second | 1991 |
| Mike Weber | Base | First | 1986 |
| Mike Whalen | FB | Third | 2001 |
| Neil Dabagian | FB | Second | 1982 |
| Nick Condo | Base | Second | 2002 |
| Pat McKenna | FB | Second | 1994 |
| Paul Brown | FB | Second | 1977 |
| Paul McNichol | FB | First | 2002 |
| Paul Shepherd | Base | Third | 2011 |
| Pete Klein | Base | Second | 1987 |
| Pete Ruggieri | FB | Second | 1984 |
| Pete Ruggieri | FB | First | 1985 |
| Ralph Tancredi | FB | Third | 1992 |
| Randy Milia | Base | First | 2002 |
| Rick Reigner | Base | First | 2010 |
| Rob Benedict | Base | Second | 2008 |
| Rob Cucinotta | Base | Third | 1997 |
| Rob Cucinotta | Base | First | 1998 |
| Rodney Blake | Bask | First | 1983 |
| Rodney Blake | Bask | First | 1984 |
| Ronnie Scull | Base | Second | 2012 |
| Ryan Benner | FB | Second | 1998 |
| Ryan Benner | FB | Second | 1999 |
| Ryan McMahon | Base | Third | 2001 |
| Scott Ely | Base | Second | 1989 |
| Scott Ely | Base | First | 1990 |
| Sean Fitzgerald | Base | Second | 2006 |
| Shawn Bell | FB | Second | 1992 |
| Steve Mancini | FB | Third | 1993 |
| Steve Minnick | FB | Second | 1978 |
| Steve Wheatley | FB | Second | 2005 |
| Steve Wright | FB | Second | 1990 |
| Steve Wright | FB | First | 1991 |
| Terry Hannan | Bask | Third | 1975 |
| Tim Dougherty | Base | Second | 2007 |
| Tom Abram | FB | First | 1981 |
| Tom Colvin | FB | Third | 1984 |
| Tom Galia | FB | Third | 1983 |
| Tom Gormley | Bask | Third | 1983 |
| Tom McHugh | FB | Second | 1999 |
| Tom McHugh | FB | First | 2000 |
| Tom Moran | Base | Second | 2005 |
| Tom Oropeza | FB | Third | 1994 |
| Tom Papa | Base | Second | 1998 |
| Tom Stauffer | Base | First | 1978 |
| Wally Rutecki | FB | First | 1978 |
| Wally Rutecki | Base | Second | 1979 |
| Walt Fuller | Bask | First | 1982 |
| Aaron McCastle | FB | Third | 2014 |
| Ajiri Johnson | Bask | Second | 2018 |
| Alex Coll | FB | Third | 2016 |
| Christian Summers | FB | First | 2012 |
| Collin DiGalbo | FB | Second | 2013 |
| Collin DiGalbo | FB | Third | 2014 |
| Dan Furman | Base | Second | 2013 |
| Gerald Smith | FB | Third | 2018 |
| Isaiah Wong | Bask | First | 2018 |
| Isaiah Wong | Bask | First | 2019 |
| Jim Haley | FB | Second | 2012 |
| Jim Haley | Base | First | 2013 |
| Joe Smith | FB | First | 2012 |
| John Durkin | FB | Second | 2013 |
| Kevin Zimmerman | FB | Third | 2016 |
| Kyrin Jackson | FB | Third | 2017 |
| Mike Ockimey | FB | Second | 2013 |
| Nasim Cooper | FB | Third | 2018 |
| Nate Furman | Base | Second | 2018 |
| Nick Bralczyk | Base | First | 2015 |
| Pat Vanderslice | Base | First | 2013 |
| Richie Tecco | Base | Third | 2014 |
| Steve Furman | Base | Second | 2015 |
| Steve Furman | Base | Second | 2016 |
| Tim Dougherty | Base | Second | 2016 |
| Tim Dougherty | Base | First | 2017 |
| Tyreese Watson | Bask | Third | 2020 |
| Boys' Latin | |||
| Cory Little | FB | Third | 2017 |
| Damir Smith Lockett | FB | Third | 2018 |
| Doug Osborne | FB | Third | 2011 |
| Malik Johnson | FB | Third | 2017 |
| Malik Johnson | FB | Third | 2018 |
| Maurice "Doo-Wop" Watson | Bask | Third | 2011 |
| Maurice "Doo-Wop" Watson | Bask | First | 2012 |
| Mohamed Diawara | FB | Third | 2018 |
| Yahmir Greenlee | Bask | Third | 2012 |
| Bracetti | |||
| Jordano Rodriguez | Base | Third | 2011 |
| Carroll | |||
| AJ Hoggard | Bask | First | 2018 |
| Andrew Garchinsky | FB | Second | 1993 |
| Andrew Garchinsky | FB | First | 1994 |
| Austin Tilghman | FB | Third | 2013 |
| Barry Bekkedam | Bask | Third | 1985 |
| Barry Bekkedam | Bask | First | 1986 |
| Bill Boegly | FB | Third | 1976 |
| Bill Ghaul | FB | Third | 2011 |
| Bill Phillips | Bask | Second | 1997 |
| Bill Zwaan | FB | First | 1971 |
| Brandon Moore | FB | First | 1987 |
| Brian Dunn | FB | Second | 1993 |
| Brian Mattaway | FB | First | 2000 |
| Brian Rorick | Base | First | 2004 |
| Brian Rorick | FB | First | 2004 |
| Brian Rorick | Base | Second | 2005 |
| Brian Serafin | FB | Second | 1991 |
| Brian Zwaan | FB | First | 1975 |
| Bryan Chesky | Base | Third | 2014 |
| Burt Grossman | FB | First | 1984 |
| Charlie Hurley | FB | Second | 2000 |
| Chaz Scott | FB | Third | 2001 |
| Chaz Scott | FB | First | 2002 |
| Chris Cashman | Base | First | 2004 |
| Chris Day | FB | Third | 1991 |
| Chris Dengler | Base | Second | 2007 |
| Chris Kennedy | FB | First | 2008 |
| Chris Lisowski | Base | Third | 2007 |
| Chris Olivieri | FB | Second | 1982 |
| Chris Stratts | FB | Second | 1991 |
| Chris Troutman | FB | Second | 1981 |
| Cole Chesnet | Base | Third | 2018 |
| Corey Hill | FB | Second | 1994 |
| Dahmir Ruffin | FB | Third | 2016 |
| Dahmir Ruffin | FB | Second | 2017 |
| Dan Graham | FB | Second | 1988 |
| Dan Mostardi | Base | Third | 1980 |
| Dan Mostardi | Base | First | 1981 |
| Dave Frascella | FB | Second | 1995 |
| Dave Lafferty | Base | First | 1982 |
| Derick Fox | FB | First | 1993 |
| Derrick Jones | Bask | Third | 2013 |
| Derrick Jones | Bask | First | 2014 |
| Derrick Jones | Bask | First | 2015 |
| Devin Brown | FB | Second | 1988 |
| DJ Irving | Bask | Second | 2009 |
| DJ Irving | Bask | Second | 2010 |
| Don O'Brien | FB | Second | 1984 |
| Doug Murphy | FB | Third | 1985 |
| Drew Shaw | FB | Third | 2000 |
| Ed Stefanski | FB | Second | 1997 |
| Ellis Rogers | FB | Third | 2007 |
| Eric McGough | Base | Second | 2012 |
| Evan Harvey | Base | Third | 2013 |
| Frank DiMaggio | Base | Third | 1994 |
| Frank DiMaggio | Base | First | 1995 |
| Frank Gailey | Base | First | 2002 |
| Frank Gailey | Base | First | 2003 |
| Frank Mellon | FB | Second | 1971 |
| Frank Rauscher | Base | Second | 1990 |
| George Ravalico | FB | Second | 1989 |
| George Stratts | FB | First | 1986 |
| Gerard Oakes | Base | Second | 1999 |
| Gerard Oakes | Base | First | 2000 |
| Gerard Phelan | FB | First | 1980 |
| Greg See | FB | Second | 1993 |
| Greg See | FB | First | 1994 |
| Harry Rohlfing | FB | Second | 1979 |
| J.T. Evangelist | Base | Third | 2014 |
| Jack Lowney | FB | Second | 2007 |
| Jack Lowney | FB | First | 2008 |
| Jake Kelchner | Base | First | 2018 |
| James "Big Rig" Roderick | FB | First | 2002 |
| James Kelly | Base | Second | 2016 |
| James Kelly | Base | First | 2017 |
| James Roderick | FB | Third | 2001 |
| Jamie Lockard | FB | Third | 1997 |
| Jay Aquilante | Base | First | 1996 |
| Jay Aquilante | Base | First | 1997 |
| Jeff Vanak | FB | First | 1999 |
| Jeff Vanak | FB | First | 2000 |
| Jim Costalas | FB | First | 1983 |
| Jim Fuchs | Base | Second | 1998 |
| Jim Fuchs | Base | First | 1999 |
| Jim Gillin | Base | Third | 2001 |
| Jim Gillin | Base | Second | 2002 |
| Jim Ronan | FB | Second | 1973 |
| Joe Bello | FB | First | 1982 |
| Joe Bergstrom | FB | First | 1988 |
| Joe Cocco | FB | Third | 2001 |
| Joe Corcoran | FB | Second | 1979 |
| Joe DiWilliams | Base | Third | 2014 |
| Joe Hallinan | FB | Second | 2000 |
| Joe Keefer | FB | Second | 1975 |
| Joe Rogers | Bask | Second | 1973 |
| Joe Utsch | FB | Third | 1987 |
| John Fair | FB | Second | 1973 |
| John Gardner | Base | Second | 2002 |
| John Lachman | FB | Second | 2003 |
| John Pindynski | Base | Third | 1999 |
| John Quigg | FB | Second | 1982 |
| John Vanak | FB | Second | 2001 |
| Jordan Ingram | Bask | Second | 2003 |
| Josh Halladay | FB | Third | 2005 |
| Josh Sharkey | Bask | Second | 2016 |
| Juan'ya Green | Bask | Second | 2010 |
| Juan'ya Green | Bask | First | 2011 |
| Juliano Mastrocola | FB | Third | 2018 |
| Justin Faust | FB | Second | 2002 |
| Kashif Payne | Bask | Third | 2001 |
| Kashif Payne | Bask | Second | 2002 |
| Keith Conway | Base | First | 1990 |
| Keith Conway | Base | First | 1991 |
| Kevin "Butch" Lynam | Bask | Third | 1977 |
| Kevin Mullen | FB | Third | 1976 |
| Kevin Mullen | FB | First | 1977 |
| Kevin Mullen | Base | Second | 1978 |
| Koran Butler | FB | Third | 2018 |
| Lamont Day | FB | Second | 1988 |
| Luke Wischnowski | FB | Second | 2008 |
| Marc Pellicciotta | Base | First | 1994 |
| Martin Ingelsby | Bask | Second | 1996 |
| Martin Ingelsby | Bask | First | 1997 |
| Marty Higgins | FB | First | 1999 |
| Marty Higgins | FB | First | 2000 |
| Marty McCabe | FB | Second | 1983 |
| Matt Donaldson | FB | Second | 2010 |
| Maurice Stovall | FB | Second | 2000 |
| Maurice Stovall | FB | First | 2001 |
| Max Hitman | Base | Second | 2017 |
| Mick Hannan | Base | Third | 2001 |
| Mike Adelizzi | FB | Second | 1971 |
| Mike Aquilante | Base | Third | 1995 |
| Mike Bailey | FB | First | 1974 |
| Mike Callan | FB | First | 1986 |
| Mike Costanzo | Base | Third | 2000 |
| Mike Costanzo | Base | First | 2001 |
| Mike Costanzo | Base | First | 2002 |
| Mike Daly | Base | Second | 1996 |
| Mike Fuchs | Base | First | 1996 |
| Mike Fuchs | Base | First | 1997 |
| Mike Hofer | FB | Second | 1984 |
| Mike Kempski | Bask | Third | 1987 |
| Mike Larkin | FB | Third | 2000 |
| Mike Roberts | FB | First | 1992 |
| Mike Roberts | Bask | Second | 1993 |
| Mike Saksa | FB | First | 1974 |
| Mike Sohmer | Base | Second | 1980 |
| Mike Wallo | FB | Third | 1984 |
| Moses Hipps | Bask | Third | 2022 |
| Nick Argentieri | Base | Third | 2016 |
| Pat Sillup | Base | First | 1998 |
| Paul Romanczuk | Bask | Third | 1995 |
| Pete Hinckle | FB | Second | 1994 |
| Pete McKenna | FB | First | 1976 |
| Pete Ravalico | FB | First | 1987 |
| Pete Sousa | FB | Second | 1994 |
| Rafal Bigus | Bask | Third | 1994 |
| Rafal Bigus | Bask | First | 1995 |
| Ray Kane | FB | First | 1989 |
| Ray Kane | FB | First | 1990 |
| Regan Fox | FB | Third | 1990 |
| Richie Kimmel | FB | Second | 2018 |
| Russ Kingsbury | FB | First | 1990 |
| Ryan Daly | Bask | First | 2016 |
| Ryan Harford | FB | Second | 2003 |
| Scott Gilinger | Base | Third | 1998 |
| Seamus Finnegan | Base | Third | 2010 |
| Sean Scott | FB | Third | 1995 |
| Sean Scott | FB | First | 1996 |
| Steve Adelizzi | FB | First | 1971 |
| Steve Jepson | FB | Second | 1974 |
| Steve Troutman | FB | First | 1986 |
| Ted Piotrowicz | Base | Second | 2001 |
| Teron Dobbs | FB | Third | 2011 |
| Terry Mullen | FB | First | 1982 |
| Terry Mullen | Base | Second | 1983 |
| Tom Dunn | Bask | Second | 1987 |
| Tom Dunn | Base | Third | 1987 |
| Tom Handzus | Base | Third | 1990 |
| Tom Handzus | Base | First | 1991 |
| Tom Hurley | Base | Third | 1984 |
| Tom Rohlfing | FB | Second | 1976 |
| Tom Siebert | FB | First | 1976 |
| Tyler Kehoe | Base | First | 2018 |
| Vince Sposato | FB | First | 1985 |
| Wiley Flowers | FB | Third | 2006 |
| Will Gruber | FB | Second | 1974 |
| Yosef Yacob | Bask | Second | 2013 |
| Zach Butler | FB | Second | 2018 |
| Cedar Grove | |||
| Anwar Scott | Bask | Third | 1997 |
| Central | |||
| Al Twyman | FB | Second | 1979 |
| Allen Taylor | Base | Second | 1979 |
| Andrew "Potter" Reynolds | Base | First | 2005 |
| Andrew Furtak | FB | Third | 2000 |
| Anthony DeVito | Base | Second | 2014 |
| Blake Mayberry | Base | First | 2018 |
| Blake Schwartz | FB | Third | 2015 |
| Blake Schwartz | FB | Third | 2016 |
| Bob Dintino | Base | Second | 1997 |
| Bob Keels | FB | Second | 1974 |
| Bob Keels | FB | First | 1975 |
| Brandon Watson | Base | Second | 2004 |
| Brian Schuster | Base | Second | 2000 |
| Brooks Ey | Base | Third | 2018 |
| Calvin Dixon | Bask | Third | 1978 |
| Calvin Dixon | Bask | Second | 1979 |
| Chris Bing | Bask | Third | 2014 |
| Chris Williams | FB | Third | 2002 |
| Chuck McCaffrey | Base | Third | 1992 |
| Collin Washington | FB | Third | 2015 |
| Collin Washington | FB | Second | 2016 |
| Cornelius Bunch | FB | First | 2004 |
| Craig Wise | Bask | First | 1991 |
| Damone Jones | FB | First | 1998 |
| Dan D'Imperio | Base | Third | 1983 |
| Darrell Ray | FB | First | 2005 |
| Darryl Williams | FB | Second | 1997 |
| Dennis Golden | FB | Third | 1980 |
| Derick Gallman | FB | First | 1973 |
| Devon Johnson | FB | Second | 2004 |
| DeVonne Boler | FB | Third | 2009 |
| Don Alecxih | FB | Second | 1974 |
| Everett Lee | FB | Second | 2000 |
| Frank Armstrong | FB | First | 1975 |
| Frank Santore | Base | Third | 1979 |
| Gary Bennett | Bask | First | 1982 |
| Greg Watson | FB | First | 1981 |
| Gregory Pittman | FB | First | 1971 |
| Hakeem Ellis | FB | Third | 2012 |
| Ian Lewis | Base | Third | 2009 |
| Ivan O'Connor | FB | Third | 1978 |
| Jared Farbman | Base | First | 2006 |
| Jared Farbman | Base | Second | 2007 |
| Jason Lavala | Base | First | 1988 |
| Jason Lewis | FB | Second | 1985 |
| Jerrod Washington | FB | First | 1988 |
| Jim Aversa | Base | Second | 1989 |
| Jim Benek | Base | Third | 2007 |
| Jim Krzywicki | Base | Third | 1988 |
| Jim Krzywicki | Base | First | 1989 |
| Jimmy Wilson | FB | Third | 1983 |
| Joe Coccia | Base | Second | 1984 |
| Joe Dugan | Base | Third | 1993 |
| Joe Dugan | Base | First | 1994 |
| Joe Magdovitz | Base | Second | 2006 |
| Joe Marshall | FB | Third | 2004 |
| Joe Starosta | Base | Third | 1978 |
| Joe Stellabotte | FB | First | 1975 |
| Joe Whalen | FB | Second | 1972 |
| John Kennedy | FB | First | 2006 |
| John Long | FB | Second | 1975 |
| John Marzano | Base | First | 1980 |
| John Marzano | Base | First | 1981 |
| Jon Ford | FB | First | 1986 |
| Jon Irvine | FB | Third | 1984 |
| Jonathan Jones | Bask | Third | 1985 |
| Jordan Anderson | FB | First | 2003 |
| Jordan Hesbacher | Base | Third | 1986 |
| Julien Blancon | Base | Second | 2012 |
| Kairi Cooper | FB | First | 1998 |
| Kaloma Cardwell | FB | First | 2001 |
| Kei-shon Graham | FB | Third | 2016 |
| Keith Buxton | FB | Second | 1971 |
| Ken Anderson | FB | First | 1971 |
| Kenyatta Rush | FB | First | 1985 |
| Kurtis West | FB | Third | 1999 |
| Lance Adams | FB | Second | 1985 |
| Leon Midgette | Base | Third | 1981 |
| Levord Burns | FB | Third | 1977 |
| Marc DeBeary | FB | Second | 1982 |
| Marc Priest | Base | Third | 1991 |
| Marc Priest | Base | Second | 1992 |
| Marcel Quarterman | FB | Second | 2003 |
| Mark Gervasi | Base | Third | 2010 |
| Mark Gervasi | Base | Second | 2011 |
| Mark Hrubar | FB | First | 1988 |
| Mark Ross | FB | Second | 1979 |
| Mark Surma | FB | Second | 2006 |
| Micah Winterstein | Base | Third | 2008 |
| Mike Braun | Base | Third | 2008 |
| Mike Cavallaro | Base | Third | 2011 |
| Mike Cavallaro | Base | First | 2012 |
| Mike Roche | FB | Third | 1985 |
| Mike Roche | FB | Third | 1986 |
| Mike Thompson | FB | Second | 2006 |
| Mike Vaughan | Base | Third | 1984 |
| Mike Wisher | FB | First | 1976 |
| Munir Nuriddin | FB | Second | 2001 |
| Nasir Womack | FB | Third | 2015 |
| Noah White | Base | Second | 2001 |
| Noah White | Base | Second | 2002 |
| Pete Gualtieri | FB | Second | 1977 |
| Pete Rowe | Base | Third | 2010 |
| Pete Stolzer | FB | Third | 1980 |
| Pete Whittle | Base | First | 1999 |
| Quentin Fuller | FB | First | 1993 |
| Quindel "Milky" Ladson | FB | Second | 2003 |
| Raheem Islam | FB | First | 1996 |
| Ray Harris | FB | Second | 2007 |
| Rich Danson | Base | First | 1983 |
| Rich Drayton | FB | First | 1985 |
| Rich Drayton | FB | First | 1986 |
| Rich Fernandez | Base | Second | 1986 |
| Rich Fernandez | Base | First | 1987 |
| Richard "Tre" Drayton | FB | First | 2011 |
| Robert Irlan | FB | Third | 1989 |
| Rodney Sykes | FB | Second | 2004 |
| Roman McDonald | FB | Third | 1990 |
| Roman McDonald | FB | First | 1991 |
| Ronald Porter | FB | Second | 1971 |
| Ryshan Manning | FB | Second | 2009 |
| Sam Campbell | FB | Second | 1997 |
| Sam Reid | FB | Third | 2013 |
| Scott Glenn | FB | Third | 1980 |
| Scott Rodgers | Bask | First | 2005 |
| Sean Ryan | FB | Third | 1996 |
| Sharif Bray | Bask | Second | 2002 |
| Siddiq Cornish | FB | Second | 2009 |
| Sondiata McKeithan | FB | Second | 1988 |
| SooSung Whang | FB | Second | 2017 |
| Steve Schall | Base | Third | 2009 |
| Sundiata Rush | FB | Second | 1988 |
| Tariq Sanders | FB | First | 2001 |
| Teddy Lipford | Base | Third | 2001 |
| Tim Greco | Base | First | 1996 |
| Tommy Capewell | Base | Third | 2009 |
| Tony Schimony | Base | Third | 1995 |
| Tyrone Tyson | Bask | Third | 1992 |
| Tyson Price | FB | Second | 1987 |
| Vic Bellamy | FB | First | 1980 |
| Vic Condora | Base | Third | 1980 |
| Vinny Santos | FB | Third | 2017 |
| Walt Campbell | Base | Third | 1993 |
| Walter Pegues | FB | Third | 2011 |
| Walter Pegues | FB | Second | 2012 |
| Walter Pegues | FB | First | 2013 |
| Warren McAllister | FB | First | 1971 |
| Wilbur Johnson | Bask | Third | 1992 |
| Zach Magdovitz | Base | Third | 2009 |
| Chestnut Hill / SCH Academy | |||
| To Base '11 / Foot '11 Forward | |||
| Andre Dixon | FB | Second | 1993 |
| Andrew Burke | FB | Second | 1987 |
| Andrew Burke | FB | First | 1988 |
| Anthony Cafagna | Base | Third | 2006 |
| Anthony Cafagna | Base | First | 2007 |
| Aquil Stinson | FB | First | 1994 |
| Brandon Sady | Base | Second | 2009 |
| Brendan Kilfeather | FB | First | 1989 |
| Brett DiFelice | Base | Third | 2005 |
| Brett DiFelice | Base | Second | 2006 |
| Brian Dones | FB | Second | 2010 |
| Brian Ewell | FB | Third | 1977 |
| Brian Jones | FB | Third | 1990 |
| Chris Brassell | FB | Second | 1988 |
| Chris McInerney | Base | Second | 2004 |
| Chris Simons | Base | First | 1989 |
| Chris Wright | FB | Third | 1982 |
| Chris Wright | FB | Third | 1983 |
| Christian Guinan | FB | First | 2010 |
| Chuck Lynch | FB | Third | 1986 |
| Colin Kelly | FB | Third | 2010 |
| Dan Rosenbaum | Base | Second | 2011 |
| Danny Hull | Base | Third | 2011 |
| Dave Miller | Base | First | 1992 |
| David Harrison | FB | Third | 1987 |
| David Miller | Base | Second | 1991 |
| David Whaley | FB | First | 1984 |
| Drew Glendinning | FB | Second | 1981 |
| George Bailey | FB | Second | 1978 |
| Glenn Barrie | Base | Third | 1981 |
| Ibraheim Campbell | FB | First | 2008 |
| Ibraheim Campbell | FB | First | 2009 |
| Jim Burke | FB | Third | 1982 |
| John Helverson | FB | First | 1994 |
| Jon McAllister | Base | Third | 2007 |
| Jon McAllister | Base | Second | 2008 |
| Jon McAllister | FB | Third | 2008 |
| Jon McAllister | Base | First | 2009 |
| Jon McAllister | FB | Third | 2009 |
| Jon McAllister | Base | First | 2010 |
| Josh Mechem | FB | Third | 1989 |
| Juan Gaskins | FB | Third | 2007 |
| Lloyd Yancey | FB | First | 1980 |
| Malcolm Dyson | FB | Third | 1990 |
| Mark Burke | FB | Third | 1985 |
| Matt Primavera | Base | Third | 2011 |
| Mike Brown | Base | Third | 1999 |
| Mike Brown | Base | First | 2000 |
| Mike Gizzi | FB | Third | 1993 |
| Mike Gizzi | Bask | Second | 1994 |
| Mike Koplove | Base | First | 1995 |
| Mike Long | FB | First | 2007 |
| Mike Mattei | Base | Third | 2007 |
| Mike Mattei | FB | Second | 2007 |
| Mike Mattei | Base | Second | 2008 |
| Pat Connaghan | FB | Second | 2009 |
| Paul Aguirre | FB | Second | 1988 |
| Paul Aguirre | FB | First | 1989 |
| Paul Burke | FB | First | 1990 |
| Paul Burke | Bask | Second | 1991 |
| Paul Burke | Base | Third | 1990 |
| Paul Burke | Base | Third | 1991 |
| Rashad Campbell | FB | First | 2006 |
| Rashad Campbell | FB | First | 2007 |
| Rich Greenwood | Base | Third | 1984 |
| Steel Russell | Base | Second | 2008 |
| Steel Russell | Base | Second | 2009 |
| Steve Lamberton | FB | Second | 1994 |
| Ted Haines | FB | Second | 1978 |
| Tim Gramlich | FB | First | 2007 |
| Tim Whitworth | Bask | Second | 1999 |
| Tito Nanni | FB | Third | 1976 |
| Tito Nanni | FB | First | 1977 |
| Tito Nanni | Base | First | 1978 |
| Tom Devlin | FB | First | 2009 |
| Tom Whitworth | Bask | Second | 1998 |
| Tyler Hightower | FB | Third | 2010 |
| Tyler Hightower | FB | Second | 2011 |
| Wayne Crawford | FB | Second | 2006 |
| Will Clark | Base | Third | 1998 |
| Will Emery | FB | Second | 2009 |
| Aaron Angelos | FB | Second | 2018 |
| Aidan "Curly" Frye | Base | Third | 2016 |
| Aidan "Curly" Frye | Base | Third | 2017 |
| Aidan "Curly" Frye | Base | Third | 2018 |
| AJ LaBella | Base | First | 2015 |
| Bobby Keyes | FB | Third | 2011 |
| Bobby Keyes | FB | Second | 2012 |
| Cedric Madden | FB | Second | 2011 |
| Chris "Bubba" Alleyne | Base | Third | 2016 |
| Chris "Bubba" Alleyne | Base | Second | 2017 |
| Chris Howard | FB | Third | 2011 |
| Danny Hull | Base | First | 2012 |
| Dylan Parsons | FB | Third | 2013 |
| Dylan Parsons | FB | First | 2014 |
| Gunnar Hayes | Base | First | 2016 |
| Ian Diaz | Base | Third | 2017 |
| Ke'Shawn Williams | FB | First | 2018 |
| Matt Kozemchak | Base | Second | 2013 |
| Nick Rowland | Base | Second | 2016 |
| Owen McAdoo | FB | Third | 2013 |
| Pat Elliott | FB | Third | 2017 |
| Pat Elliott | Base | Third | 2018 |
| Paul Dooley | FB | Third | 2013 |
| Paul Dooley | FB | First | 2014 |
| Riley Mihalik | Base | Second | 2015 |
| Sam Feirson | Base | Third | 2012 |
| Sameir Madden | FB | Second | 2014 |
| Shane Dooley | FB | Second | 2018 |
| Syaire Madden | FB | Third | 2014 |
| Tyson Hugee | FB | Third | 2016 |
| Communications Tech | |||
| Andrew "Scootie" Randall | Bask | First | 2008 |
| Diquan Gilbert | FB | First | 2012 |
| James Brunson | FB | Second | 2011 |
| Rolando "Ro-Ro" Ransom | FB | Second | 2010 |
| Rolando "Ro-Ro" Ransom | FB | Second | 2011 |
| Stacey Hill | FB | Third | 2008 |
| Terrick "Teddy" Carson | FB | Second | 2008 |
| Egan / Conwell-Egan | |||
| To Base '93 / FB '93 Forward | |||
| Bill Kramer | Base | Third | 1981 |
| Blaise Coleman | FB | Third | 1991 |
| Bob Molle | Base | Second | 1982 |
| Bob Zupcic | FB | First | 1983 |
| Bob Zupcic | Base | First | 1983 |
| Bob Zupcic | Base | First | 1984 |
| Brian Sottile | FB | First | 1974 |
| Chris Moore | FB | Third | 1989 |
| Chris Rooney | FB | Third | 1983 |
| Chuck Coleman | Base | Second | 1989 |
| Cliff Hagan | FB | Second | 1977 |
| Dom Cotugno | FB | Third | 1977 |
| Greg Youngblood | Base | First | 1984 |
| Hank Grezlak | FB | Third | 1986 |
| Jeff Palmer | FB | Second | 1989 |
| Jeff Perry | FB | Second | 1992 |
| Jerry Gallagher | FB | First | 1971 |
| Jerry Riley | FB | Second | 1975 |
| Jim Carr | Base | Third | 1988 |
| Jim Hvizda | FB | Second | 1983 |
| Jim Hvizda | Base | First | 1984 |
| Jim Schurr | FB | First | 1986 |
| Jim Siesser | FB | Second | 1972 |
| Joe Kobialka | FB | Second | 1982 |
| Joe Lynch | Base | First | 1978 |
| Joe McEwing | Bask | Second | 1990 |
| Joe McEwing | Base | Third | 1989 |
| Joe McEwing | Base | First | 1990 |
| John Fletcher | FB | First | 1988 |
| John Gerhardt | FB | Third | 1986 |
| John Rodak | FB | Second | 1980 |
| Keith Armstrong | FB | First | 1981 |
| Kevin Furphy | FB | Second | 1988 |
| Len Lynch | FB | Third | 1978 |
| Len Lynch | FB | First | 1979 |
| Lenny Rodak | FB | Second | 1977 |
| Mark Murphy | FB | First | 1983 |
| Mark Murphy | FB | Third | 1983 |
| Mark Pizzo | FB | First | 1983 |
| Mark Pizzo | FB | First | 1984 |
| Mike Blaszczak | Base | Third | 1990 |
| Mike Kramer | FB | First | 1981 |
| Mike Parrillo | FB | Third | 1981 |
| Mike Yeager | FB | Second | 1971 |
| Rich Gibney | FB | First | 1971 |
| Rick Burns | FB | First | 1981 |
| Rick Burns | FB | First | 1982 |
| Rick Burns | Base | First | 1982 |
| Rick Burns | Base | First | 1983 |
| Scott Haws | Base | First | 1990 |
| Scott Sheplock | Base | Third | 1988 |
| Sean Corrigan | FB | Third | 1989 |
| Shawn Passman | FB | First | 1976 |
| Steve Schurr | FB | First | 1988 |
| Tim Stough | FB | First | 1972 |
| Tom Seger | FB | First | 1979 |
| Tom Seger | FB | First | 1980 |
| Tony Petruccio | FB | First | 1974 |
| Alex Goldsby | FB | Third | 2018 |
| Andrew Garwo | FB | Third | 2018 |
| Anthony Singlar | FB | Second | 2009 |
| Beau Fleming | Base | Third | 2012 |
| Ben Keller | Base | Third | 2009 |
| Brian Herman | Base | First | 2006 |
| Brian Hrynczyszyn | FB | Second | 2003 |
| Chad Harvey | Base | Third | 2000 |
| Chris David | Base | Third | 2005 |
| Chris Majors | FB | Third | 2018 |
| Chuck Knowles | FB | Third | 1995 |
| Dajuan Harris | FB | Second | 2018 |
| Danny Bentley | FB | Third | 2016 |
| Dwayne Majors | FB | Third | 2017 |
| Dwayne Majors | FB | First | 2018 |
| Gary Stricker | Base | Second | 2002 |
| Gino Turchi | FB | Third | 2017 |
| Greg Treude | FB | Third | 1994 |
| Ike Robinson | Bask | Third | 2010 |
| Jack Barreras | FB | Third | 2017 |
| Jamal Nwaniemeka | Bask | Second | 2012 |
| Jeff McClenton | FB | Third | 2004 |
| Jeff Perry | FB | First | 1993 |
| Joe Lamina | FB | Second | 2001 |
| John Clark | FB | Third | 2010 |
| John Malloy | Base | First | 2006 |
| John McDonald | Base | Second | 2007 |
| John Paul Adamson | FB | Third | 1994 |
| Keanan Baines | FB | Second | 2016 |
| Kevin Knox | FB | Third | 1993 |
| Kevin Schafer | FB | First | 2006 |
| Kyree Bronson | FB | Third | 2016 |
| LaPri McCray-Pace | Bask | Third | 2016 |
| Matt Brazil | FB | First | 2002 |
| Matt Burns | Base | Second | 2005 |
| Matt Fischer | FB | Second | 2002 |
| Matt Fischer | Base | Third | 2004 |
| Matt Petrizzi | Base | Third | 2010 |
| Matt Wagner | Base | Third | 2011 |
| Nick Natriello | Base | Third | 2003 |
| Patrick Garwo | FB | First | 2017 |
| Patrick Garwo | FB | First | 2018 |
| Pete Iovino | FB | First | 1994 |
| Phil Brazil | Base | Third | 2001 |
| Phil Papirio | Base | Third | 1999 |
| Quameer Francis | FB | Third | 2017 |
| Rich Dupell | Base | Third | 2006 |
| Rob Biernat | FB | First | 2002 |
| Ryan Biernat | FB | Second | 2004 |
| Ryan Bond | FB | Second | 2009 |
| Ryan Geiss | Base | Second | 2005 |
| Ryan Golin | FB | Second | 2008 |
| Ryan Terry | Base | Second | 2006 |
| Sean Haines | Base | Third | 1996 |
| Shane Phillips | FB | Third | 2012 |
| Shawn Smith | Base | Third | 1995 |
| Steve Slaton | FB | Third | 2001 |
| Steve Slaton | FB | Second | 2002 |
| Steve Slaton | FB | First | 2003 |
| Steve Slaton | FB | First | 2004 |
| Stevie Jordan | Bask | Third | 2015 |
| Terome Mitchell | FB | First | 2018 |
| Tim Carroll | Base | Second | 2003 |
| Tim Carroll | Base | Second | 2004 |
| Tim Slater | Base | Third | 1996 |
| Tom Burns | FB | Second | 2018 |
| Constitution | |||
| Ahmad "J.R." Gilbert | Bask | First | 2014 |
| Ahmad "J.R." Gilbert | Bask | Second | 2015 |
| Daiquan Walker | Bask | Second | 2011 |
| Daiquan Walker | Bask | First | 2012 |
| Keshaun Hammonds | Bask | Third | 2019 |
| Kimar Williams | Bask | Second | 2014 |
| Kimar Williams | Bask | First | 2015 |
| Savon Goodman | Bask | First | 2012 |
| Del-Val | |||
| Ameer Selden | FB | Second | 2009 |
| Amir Walker | FB | Third | 2014 |
| Antwuan Butler | Bask | Third | 2016 |
| Antwuan Butler | Bask | Third | 2017 |
| Ari Long | FB | Third | 2016 |
| Asadiq Dejesus | FB | Third | 2016 |
| Brad Wilson | FB | Second | 2010 |
| Christian Davis-Stukes | FB | Third | 2016 |
| Davik Miller | FB | Third | 2014 |
| Dwine Walls | FB | Third | 2014 |
| Fred Ruff | FB | Second | 2009 |
| Heleaince Gates | FB | First | 2010 |
| Kyree Wade-McLeod | FB | Second | 2016 |
| Mahki Morris | Bask | Third | 2017 |
| Markeith Minnick | FB | Second | 2010 |
| Maurice McCray | FB | Second | 2016 |
| Mikal Cherry | FB | Second | 2015 |
| Semaj Motley | Bask | Second | 2016 |
| Shaheed Brown | FB | Second | 2015 |
| Shayne "Sugar" Smith | FB | Third | 2015 |
| Shei-Ron Whittaker | FB | Third | 2016 |
| Dobbins | |||
| Aaron Walker | FB | Third | 2010 |
| Andre Davis | FB | Third | 1997 |
| Andre Davis | FB | First | 1998 |
| Barren Grier | FB | Second | 2001 |
| Brett Singleton | FB | Second | 1998 |
| Charles Ellison | FB | First | 1973 |
| Cliff Carter | Base | Third | 1980 |
| Cordero Thompson | FB | Second | 2004 |
| Danny Johnson | FB | First | 1997 |
| Daquan "Day-Day" Brown | FB | Second | 2011 |
| Darnell White | FB | Second | 1996 |
| Darrell "Butta" Brown | FB | First | 2006 |
| Darren Harris | FB | First | 1984 |
| Darryl "Jeezy" Clark | FB | Second | 2008 |
| Darryle Simmons | FB | Second | 1988 |
| Derek Clark | FB | Third | 2007 |
| Derek Clark | FB | Second | 2008 |
| Charles Ellison | FB | First | 1973 |
| Derrik Millhouse | FB | Second | 1990 |
| Derrik Millhouse | FB | First | 1991 |
| Derrik Millhouse | FB | Third | 1991 |
| Derrik Millhouse | Base | Third | 1991 |
| Derrik Millhouse | Base | Second | 1992 |
| Dillon Hood | FB | Second | 2010 |
| Dion Jones | Bask | Second | 1995 |
| Doug Overton | Bask | First | 1987 |
| Eric "Hank" Gathers | Bask | Third | 1984 |
| Eric "Hank" Gathers | Bask | First | 1985 |
| Eric McLaughlin | FB | Third | 1977 |
| Ernest Brent | FB | First | 1998 |
| Ernest White | FB | Third | 2010 |
| Fred Way | FB | Second | 1973 |
| Fred Way | FB | First | 1974 |
| Germal Williams | FB | Third | 1992 |
| Greg "Bo" Kimble | Bask | Second | 1984 |
| Greg "Bo" Kimble | Bask | First | 1985 |
| Greg Myers | FB | First | 2003 |
| Horace Owens | Bask | Second | 1978 |
| Horace Owens | Bask | First | 1979 |
| Jamar Bennett | FB | Second | 1993 |
| Jerrell Wright | Bask | Second | 2010 |
| Jerrell Wright | Bask | First | 2011 |
| Kareem Jefferson | FB | Third | 2012 |
| Karon "Ron-Ron" James | FB | Third | 2009 |
| Kenny Pickron | FB | Third | 1992 |
| Kenya Mobley | Bask | Second | 1990 |
| Kevin Grigsby | FB | Second | 1979 |
| Kevin Ingram | FB | First | 1979 |
| Kevin Reed | FB | Third | 1981 |
| Kevin Washington | Base | Third | 1982 |
| Khalif Boldin | FB | Third | 2001 |
| Khalif Boldin | FB | Second | 2002 |
| Lamar Murray | FB | Second | 1993 |
| Lamont Robinson | FB | First | 1973 |
| Larry Stewart | Bask | Third | 1987 |
| Lateef Ferguson | FB | Second | 2002 |
| Lawrence Pitchford | FB | Second | 1992 |
| Marc Keller | FB | Third | 1987 |
| Marcus Allen | FB | Third | 1993 |
| Marvin Stinson | Bask | Third | 1991 |
| Matt Johnson | FB | First | 1994 |
| Michael Baldwin | FB | First | 2000 |
| Michael Harris | FB | Third | 2005 |
| Raheem Brock | FB | First | 1995 |
| Raheem Brock | FB | First | 1996 |
| Ray Haynes | FB | Second | 1984 |
| Ricky Wingfield | FB | Second | 1971 |
| Ricky Womack | FB | Third | 1978 |
| Robert Alford | FB | First | 1992 |
| Robert Weeks | FB | Third | 1993 |
| Roger Talley | FB | Second | 1987 |
| Ron Wooden | FB | First | 1971 |
| Steve Sydnor | FB | Second | 2004 |
| Terrance Sample | FB | Second | 2005 |
| Terrance Stafford | FB | First | 2010 |
| Terrell "Mouse" Barringer | FB | Third | 2008 |
| Tracy Allen | FB | Second | 1989 |
| Vincent McDuffy | FB | First | 1994 |
| Willie Robinson | FB | Third | 1990 |
| Yorel Prosser | FB | Second | 1996 |
| Dougherty | |||
| Andy Garczynski | FB | First | 1983 |
| Andy Garczynski | Base | Third | 1984 |
| Andy McMenamin | Base | Second | 1993 |
| Austin "Sonny" Nagle | FB | Second | 1995 |
| Bill Burke | Base | Second | 1997 |
| Bill Eddis | FB | Third | 1988 |
| Bill Wright | FB | Second | 1982 |
| Bill Wright | FB | First | 1983 |
| Bob Carr | Base | Second | 1991 |
| Bob Hudoka | FB | Second | 1980 |
| Bob LaMaina | FB | Third | 1981 |
| Bob LaMaina | FB | Second | 1982 |
| Bob Loscalzo | FB | Second | 1977 |
| Bob Loscalzo | Base | First | 1978 |
| Bob McGarrity | FB | Second | 1978 |
| Bob Wright | FB | Second | 1985 |
| Bobby Bell | FB | Third | 1991 |
| Brandon Phillips | FB | Second | 1987 |
| Brian Kersey | FB | First | 1996 |
| Brian O'Hare | Base | Third | 1997 |
| Bruce Perry | FB | Third | 1997 |
| Carlos Galarza | Base | Second | 1990 |
| Chalie McFadden | FB | Second | 1984 |
| Chris Dugan | Base | First | 1992 |
| Chris McNicholas | FB | Third | 2004 |
| Chris Williams | Bask | First | 1989 |
| Clyde Woodley | FB | Second | 1980 |
| Cory Sutton | FB | Third | 1998 |
| Cuttino "Cat" Mobley | Bask | First | 1992 |
| Dave Bognar | Base | Third | 1993 |
| David Gavin | FB | Third | 1999 |
| DeSean White | Bask | Second | 2004 |
| Dominic Rock | FB | Third | 2003 |
| Don Greenleaf | FB | Second | 1989 |
| Doug Flanagan | Base | Second | 1981 |
| Ed Kozlowski | Base | Second | 1983 |
| Ed Law | Base | First | 1981 |
| Fred Harrison | FB | Second | 1988 |
| Gale Hudgins | FB | First | 1993 |
| Gary Thompson | FB | First | 1985 |
| Greg Boyd | FB | First | 1975 |
| Greg Cowhey | FB | First | 1978 |
| Harry Swayne | FB | Third | 1982 |
| Imani Bell | FB | Second | 1994 |
| Imani Bell | FB | First | 1995 |
| Jack Fagan | Base | Third | 1982 |
| Jason Cartwright | FB | Third | 1988 |
| Jason Streeper | Base | Second | 1996 |
| Jason Streeper | Base | First | 1997 |
| Jerry "Jake" Sutton | Bask | Third | 1980 |
| Jim Berry | Base | Third | 1997 |
| Jim Corbett | FB | First | 1999 |
| Jim Daley | FB | Second | 1974 |
| Jimmy John McElvaney | FB | Third | 2002 |
| Joe Brown | Base | First | 1999 |
| Joe Lauch | FB | Second | 1986 |
| Joe Nolen | FB | Second | 1984 |
| Joe Ruch | Base | Third | 1981 |
| John Dimes | FB | Second | 1983 |
| John Incollingo | FB | Second | 1981 |
| John Incollingo | FB | First | 1982 |
| John James | FB | Second | 1992 |
| John James | FB | Second | 1993 |
| John O'Brien | FB | Third | 1982 |
| John O'Brien | Base | Third | 1982 |
| John O'Brien | Base | First | 1983 |
| John Waerig | FB | Third | 1993 |
| John Waerig | FB | First | 1994 |
| Keith Rieser | FB | First | 1982 |
| Kellen "Bubba" Kemp | FB | First | 2005 |
| Kevin Davis | Base | Second | 1992 |
| Kevin Korbal | Base | Second | 1990 |
| Kevin Pompey | FB | Third | 1985 |
| Khaliyq Duncan | FB | Third | 1998 |
| Kyle Lowry | Bask | Second | 2003 |
| Kyle Lowry | Bask | First | 2004 |
| Lawrence Reid | FB | First | 1975 |
| Lawrence Reid | Bask | Third | 1975 |
| Lawrence Reid | Bask | First | 1976 |
| Leonard Hodges | FB | Third | 2000 |
| Manny Gonzalez | FB | First | 1991 |
| Manny Gonzalez | FB | First | 1992 |
| Mark Micenec | FB | Second | 1992 |
| Mark Palmero | Base | Third | 1981 |
| Mark Rusas | FB | Second | 1985 |
| Marty Reidy | Base | Third | 1993 |
| Matt Andris | FB | Second | 1985 |
| Matt Greenleaf | FB | First | 1992 |
| Michael White | FB | Second | 1977 |
| Michael White | FB | First | 1978 |
| Mickey King | FB | Third | 1999 |
| Mickey King | FB | First | 2000 |
| Mike Conway | FB | Second | 1990 |
| Mike Griffin | FB | First | 1979 |
| Mike Kelly | FB | First | 1988 |
| Mike Reardon | Base | Third | 1986 |
| Pat McKinney | Base | Third | 1992 |
| Pete Mitchell | FB | First | 1980 |
| Rich Ashby | FB | Second | 1983 |
| Rick Lombardo | FB | Third | 1987 |
| Rodney Walker | FB | Second | 1982 |
| Ron Newman | FB | Second | 1971 |
| Sarina Oeub | FB | Second | 1999 |
| Sean McGovern | FB | Third | 2000 |
| Sean McGovern | FB | Second | 2001 |
| Sean McGovern | Base | Third | 2002 |
| Shane Clark | Bask | Third | 2004 |
| Shawn Newman | Bask | Third | 1991 |
| Stacey Davis | FB | Third | 1981 |
| Steve D'Ambra | FB | Third | 1983 |
| Terrence Mordecai | FB | Second | 1993 |
| Terry "Doc" Watson | Bask | Third | 1979 |
| Thomas Empson | FB | Third | 1980 |
| Thomas Empson | FB | First | 1981 |
| Tom Hilferty | Base | Second | 1980 |
| Tom Indio | FB | Third | 1992 |
| Tom Indio | FB | First | 1993 |
| Tom Kee | Base | Third | 2002 |
| Tom Tadley | FB | Second | 1977 |
| Tony Curcio | Base | Third | 1991 |
| Tony Curcio | Base | Second | 1992 |
| Tony Heffner | FB | Second | 1977 |
| Tony Heffner | FB | First | 1978 |
| Troy Kersey | FB | First | 1992 |
| Vernon Davis | FB | Second | 1995 |
| Vernon Smith | FB | Third | 1983 |
| Walt Bartle | FB | Second | 1993 |
| Engineering and Science | |||
| Chris Piccoli | Base | Third | 1987 |
| John Cox | Bask | First | 1999 |
| Lynn Greer | Bask | Second | 1995 |
| Lynn Greer | Bask | Second | 1996 |
| Lynn Greer | Bask | First | 1997 |
| Marcus Brown | Bask | Third | 2009 |
| Michael Anderson | Bask | First | 1984 |
| Will Chavis | Bask | Second | 1998 |
| Edison | |||
| Abel Rios | Base | Third | 1978 |
| Abel Rios | Base | First | 1979 |
| Albert Crockett | Bask | Third | 1996 |
| Angel Rivera | Base | Third | 1984 |
| Angel Rivera | Base | Second | 1985 |
| Anthony King | FB | Third | 1996 |
| Anthony Robinson | Bask | Second | 1983 |
| Carlos Gonzalez | Base | Third | 1991 |
| Chris Lopez | Base | Second | 2010 |
| David Eshun | FB | Second | 2002 |
| Dom Boseman | FB | Third | 2010 |
| George Bobe | Base | First | 1980 |
| German Sanchez | Base | Third | 2003 |
| Jaime Gonzalez | Base | Second | 1994 |
| James "Slurp" Gambrell | Bask | Second | 1980 |
| Javier Lafuente | Base | Third | 2007 |
| Joe Jefferson | Bask | First | 1987 |
| John Bellinger | Bask | Third | 1981 |
| Johnny Pagan | Base | Third | 2011 |
| Kory Marshall | FB | Second | 2006 |
| Louis Fountain | FB | Third | 1976 |
| Milton Anderson | FB | First | 1973 |
| Nate Coronado | Base | First | 2011 |
| Omar Logan | Bask | Second | 1996 |
| Omar Monserrate | Base | Third | 1996 |
| Omar Monserrate | Base | Second | 1997 |
| Omar Monserrate | Base | First | 1998 |
| Orman Brown | FB | Third | 1984 |
| Paul Delgado | Base | Third | 1982 |
| Paul Delgado | Base | Second | 1983 |
| Ramon Rodriguez | Base | Second | 1979 |
| Rodney Lee | Bask | First | 1975 |
| Ryan Moore | FB | Third | 1997 |
| Steve Martin | Bask | Second | 2005 |
| Tim Young | Bask | Third | 2003 |
| Timothy King | FB | Second | 1999 |
| Timothy King | FB | Third | 2000 |
| Warren Greer | FB | First | 1974 |
| Wigberto Rodriguez | Base | Second | 1980 |
| Episcopal Academy | |||
| Adam Klein | FB | Second | 2017 |
| Adam Murray | Base | First | 2002 |
| Adam Strouss | FB | First | 2012 |
| Andy Barks | Base | Second | 2003 |
| Andy Person | FB | Third | 1989 |
| Andy Person | FB | First | 1990 |
| Anthony Ciarlello | FB | Second | 1995 |
| Bobby FitzPatrick | FB | Third | 2006 |
| Bobby FitzPatrick | FB | Second | 2007 |
| Brett Carty | FB | Third | 1999 |
| Brian Dougherty | FB | Third | 1991 |
| Brian FitzPatrick | FB | First | 2004 |
| Brian Louderback | FB | Third | 1983 |
| Brian Person | FB | First | 1996 |
| Brian Ruditys | Base | Third | 2011 |
| Brian Snow | FB | Third | 2016 |
| Charles Hickman | Bask | Second | 1981 |
| Charlie Barks | Base | Third | 2006 |
| Chris Flynn | FB | Second | 1982 |
| Chris Flynn | FB | First | 1983 |
| Chris Person | FB | Second | 1992 |
| CJ McAnally | FB | Second | 2016 |
| Conner Delaney | Bask | Third | 2017 |
| Craig Renfrow | FB | Second | 1972 |
| D.J. Gregory | Base | First | 1999 |
| Dan Baker | FB | Third | 2015 |
| Dan Dougherty | FB | First | 1979 |
| Dan Dougherty | Base | First | 1980 |
| Dan Grazione | FB | Third | 1996 |
| Dan Person | FB | First | 1997 |
| Dan Williams | Base | Third | 2004 |
| Dave Casey | FB | Second | 1984 |
| Dave DeMoss | FB | Second | 1981 |
| Dave Donaghey | FB | Second | 1985 |
| Dave Donaghey | FB | First | 1986 |
| Dave Simmonds | FB | Second | 1992 |
| Dave White | FB | First | 1982 |
| Dee Barlee | FB | Third | 2015 |
| DeeWil Barlee | FB | Seond | 2017 |
| DeeWil Barlee | FB | First | 2018 |
| Dolph Tokarczyk | FB | First | 1983 |
| Doug Hitchner | Base | Second | 2000 |
| Doug Trimble | Base | First | 2013 |
| Dylan Brown | FB | Third | 2004 |
| Eric Moore | Bask | Third | 1991 |
| Erik Strid | FB | Second | 1986 |
| Ernie Rosato | FB | First | 1980 |
| Eugene Burroughs | Bask | Second | 1989 |
| Eugene Burroughs | Bask | First | 1990 |
| Evan Butts | FB | Third | 2012 |
| Evan Butts | FB | First | 2013 |
| Fran Person | FB | First | 2000 |
| Frank Antico | FB | Second | 1984 |
| Frank Rosato | FB | Third | 1988 |
| Gene Tinari | FB | Third | 1980 |
| Gerald Henderson | Bask | First | 2005 |
| Gerald Henderson | Bask | First | 2006 |
| Greg Isdaner | FB | Second | 2003 |
| Greg Isdaner | FB | First | 2004 |
| Greg Tokarczyk | FB | Second | 1998 |
| Ian Strain | FB | Second | 2012 |
| Ian Wallace | Base | Second | 2001 |
| Isaiah Payton | Base | First | 2018 |
| J.J. Durant | FB | Third | 1986 |
| J.J. Durant | FB | Second | 1987 |
| Jack Florio | FB | First | 2012 |
| Jack Meyers | Base | First | 2000 |
| Jack O'Reilly | Base | Third | 2017 |
| Jack O'Reilly | Base | First | 2018 |
| Jack Purcell | FB | Second | 2018 |
| Jackson Place | FB | Third | 2009 |
| James "Bruiser" Flint | Bask | First | 1983 |
| Jamie Auch | FB | Second | 1981 |
| Jamie Creed | FB | Third | 1999 |
| Jay Borkowski | FB | Third | 1978 |
| Jeb Broomell | Base | Third | 1999 |
| Jeff Hines | Bask | Third | 1987 |
| Jeff Steigerwalt | FB | Second | 1991 |
| Jeff Steigerwalt | FB | First | 1992 |
| Jerome Allen | FB | Second | 1990 |
| Jerome Allen | Bask | Second | 1991 |
| Joe Bellini | Base | First | 1984 |
| Joe Bellini | Base | Second | 1985 |
| Joe Person | FB | First | 2001 |
| Joe Rosati | FB | First | 2003 |
| Joe Rosati | FB | First | 2004 |
| Joe Rosati | Base | Second | 2005 |
| Joe Urbani | Base | Second | 1981 |
| Joel Lawson | FB | Third | 1998 |
| Joel Lawson | FB | Second | 1999 |
| John Meehan | FB | Third | 1985 |
| John Minicozzi | FB | Third | 2013 |
| John Minicozzi | FB | Second | 2014 |
| John Phillips | Bask | Second | 1997 |
| John Phillips | Bask | Second | 1998 |
| Justin DiLucchio | Base | Second | 2000 |
| Kurt Lunkenheimer | FB | Second | 1994 |
| Kurt Virbitsky | Base | Second | 2016 |
| Kyle Eckel | FB | First | 1999 |
| Kyle Eckel | FB | Second | 1998 |
| Kyle Virbitsky | FB | Second | 2016 |
| Kyle Virbitsky | Base | Second | 2017 |
| Luke Miller | FB | Second | 2006 |
| Malcolm Folk | FB | Third | 2018 |
| Mark Farrell | FB | Third | 1982 |
| Mark Farrell | Base | Third | 1983 |
| Matt Bailer | FB | First | 1996 |
| Matt Greim | FB | Third | 1992 |
| Matt Sheehan | FB | Third | 2006 |
| Mike Abate | Base | First | 1993 |
| Mike D'alicandro | FB | First | 1981 |
| Mike Dougherty | Base | Second | 1983 |
| Mike McGillian | FB | Second | 1999 |
| Mike McGillian | FB | Second | 2000 |
| Mike McGillian | Base | Second | 2001 |
| Mike Norrett | FB | Second | 2002 |
| Mike Yocum | Bask | Third | 2006 |
| Milton Mamula | FB | Second | 2017 |
| Nick Alikakos | Bask | Third | 2016 |
| Norm FitzPatrick | FB | Second | 1979 |
| Norm FitzPatrick | Base | Third | 1979 |
| Norm FitzPatrick | Base | Second | 1980 |
| Pat Jacobs | FB | Third | 1998 |
| Paul Chambers | FB | Second | 1987 |
| Paul Chambers | Bask | Third | 1988 |
| Paul Gilhool | FB | Second | 1986 |
| Pete Stanley | FB | Third | 1976 |
| Pete Stanley | FB | Third | 1977 |
| Pete Wichmann | FB | Third | 2004 |
| Quinn Hager | FB | Third | 2011 |
| Ralph Roam | FB | Third | 1994 |
| Rich Steigerwalt | Base | Third | 1997 |
| Roger Syracuse | FB | Second | 2002 |
| Ryan Klein | FB | Third | 2008 |
| Ryan Rockenbach | FB | Third | 2018 |
| Scott Turner | FB | Third | 1986 |
| Sean Cohen | FB | Second | 2007 |
| Shane Morrell | FB | Second | 2010 |
| Steve Faulkner | FB | Second | 2008 |
| Taylor Wright | Base | Third | 2011 |
| Teddy Ibarguen | FB | Third | 2012 |
| Terrence Mack | Bask | First | 2002 |
| Tim Gardner | FB | Third | 1988 |
| Toebe Hinckle | FB | Third | 1990 |
| Vince Russomagno | Base | Third | 2008 |
| Wayne Ellington | Bask | First | 2005 |
| Wayne Ellington | Bask | First | 2006 |
| Zach Morse | FB | Second | 2005 |
| Esperanza | |||
| Aderly Perez | Base | Third | 2012 |
| Carlos Roman | Base | Third | 2018 |
| Ralphy Ramos | Base | Third | 2012 |
| Fels | |||
| Christian DaSilva | FB | Third | 2015 |
| Dezhauntae White | FB | Second | 2012 |
| Dionte Christmas | Bask | Third | 2004 |
| Jamiel Hines | FB | Second | 2012 |
| Jylil Reeder | FB | First | 2013 |
| Malik Jackson | FB | Second | 2008 |
| Nijay Kelly | FB | First | 2011 |
| Shannon Givens | Bask | Second | 2009 |
| Terry "Dark" Brown | FB | Third | 2010 |
| Tyree "Bam" Rucker | FB | First | 2010 |
| FitzSimons | |||
| Richard Williams | FB | Third | 2009 |
| Richard Williams | FB | Second | 2010 |
| Frankford | |||
| Aaron Allison | FB | Third | 2011 |
| Adam Hartman | FB | First | 2002 |
| Akeem Smith | FB | First | 2008 |
| Alex Ljachin | FB | Third | 1985 |
| Alex Peev | FB | First | 1994 |
| Alonzo Williams | FB | Third | 2005 |
| Angel Gonzalez | FB | Second | 2005 |
| Anthony Chennault | Bask | First | 1981 |
| Anthony Turiano | FB | Second | 1973 |
| Arnold Mullins | FB | First | 2003 |
| Arthur "Yah" Davis | Bask | First | 1996 |
| Augusto "June" Ortega | Base | Second | 2011 |
| Augusto "June" Ortega | Base | First | 2012 |
| Bernie Laster | FB | First | 1975 |
| Blair Thomas | FB | Third | 1982 |
| Blair Thomas | FB | First | 1983 |
| Blair Thomas | FB | First | 1984 |
| Bob Brett | FB | First | 1980 |
| Bob Dittman | Base | Third | 1992 |
| Bobby Granata | Base | Second | 1996 |
| Bobby Higginson | Base | First | 1988 |
| Brandon Allen | FB | Third | 2006 |
| Brandon Gonzalez | Base | Third | 2012 |
| Brandon Norris | FB | Third | 2005 |
| Brandon Russell | FB | First | 2010 |
| Brian Fricker | FB | Second | 1989 |
| Brian Ramsey | FB | Second | 1980 |
| Brian Ramsey | FB | First | 1981 |
| Bruce Konick | Base | First | 1981 |
| Calvin Spires | FB | Second | 2006 |
| Carlin Warley | Bask | Second | 1988 |
| Carlin Warley | Bask | First | 1989 |
| Carlos Rivera | Base | First | 2003 |
| Carlos Rosado | Base | Third | 2005 |
| Charles Thomas | FB | Second | 1982 |
| Chris Covington | FB | Third | 1996 |
| Chris Spence | FB | First | 2007 |
| Chris Yurkow | FB | First | 1978 |
| Cliff Hubbard | FB | Third | 1983 |
| Cory Shaeffer | Base | Second | 2004 |
| Dajuan Franks | FB | Third | 2010 |
| Damien Adams | FB | Third | 1990 |
| Damien Adams | FB | First | 1991 |
| Damon Brockington | FB | First | 2005 |
| Dan Roberto | Base | Third | 1980 |
| Danny Owens | FB | First | 1997 |
| Darrell "D.J." Turner | FB | Second | 2002 |
| Darrell Miller | FB | First | 1976 |
| Daryl Wilson | Bask | Second | 1976 |
| Dave Dandalski | Base | Second | 1984 |
| Dave DeNofa | FB | Third | 1981 |
| Dave Firth | Base | First | 2002 |
| Dave Samuel | FB | Third | 1987 |
| Dave Samuel | Base | Third | 1988 |
| Dave Somerville | FB | First | 1983 |
| David Kenner | FB | First | 1998 |
| Dennis Boyles | Base | Third | 1998 |
| Derrick "Wiggles" Lanier | FB | First | 1993 |
| Dioanny Mejia | Base | Third | 2018 |
| Duane Johnson | Bask | Third | 1994 |
| Ed Durfor | Base | First | 2000 |
| Ed Noble | FB | Third | 1978 |
| Eddie Gaskins | FB | First | 1995 |
| Eddie Gaskins | FB | First | 1996 |
| Eddie Gaskins | FB | First | 1997 |
| Edgardo Bernard | Base | First | 2016 |
| Edwin "Tito" Rohena | Base | Second | 2007 |
| Edwin "Tito" Rohena | Base | First | 2008 |
| Edwin "Tito" Rohena | Base | First | 2009 |
| Eric Leaks | FB | First | 1980 |
| Ervin Goodson | FB | Third | 2007 |
| Ervin Hook | FB | Third | 2003 |
| Esteban "Shortie" Meletiche | Base | Third | 2006 |
| Esteban "Shortie" Meletiche | Base | First | 2007 |
| Esteban "Shortie" Meletiche | Base | First | 2008 |
| Ezequiel "Esky" Lopez | FB | Second | 2016 |
| Fred Ewing | Base | Third | 1996 |
| Gary Hegh | FB | Second | 1971 |
| Gary Hegh | FB | First | 1972 |
| Geoffrey Phillippe | FB | Second | 2011 |
| George Benson | FB | First | 1975 |
| George Gordienko | FB | Second | 1976 |
| George Heineman | FB | First | 1981 |
| Gerald "Moosha" Redding | Bask | Third | 1999 |
| Harry Cooke | FB | Second | 1976 |
| Harun Reed | FB | Third | 1987 |
| Herb "Pitter" Sample | FB | Second | 1997 |
| Isaiah "Zeke" Thompson | FB | First | 2003 |
| Israel Diaz | Base | Third | 2010 |
| Jameer Brooks | FB | Second | 2016 |
| James Allen | FB | First | 1999 |
| James Quiles | FB | Third | 2006 |
| James Quiles | FB | Second | 2007 |
| Jamie Ross | Bask | Second | 1988 |
| Jason Warley | Bask | Second | 1989 |
| Jay DiBello | FB | Third | 1995 |
| J.C. Montgomery | FB | Second | 2006 |
| Jeff Brooks | FB | Third | 1981 |
| Jeffery "Monk" Clark | Bask | First | 1977 |
| Jeffrey Mims | FB | First | 1995 |
| Jeremy Benson | FB | First | 2003 |
| Jerry Santa | FB | Second | 1989 |
| Joe Carretta | Base | Third | 1986 |
| Joe Farina | FB | Third | 2003 |
| Joe Farina | Base | First | 2003 |
| Joe Farina | Base | First | 2004 |
| Joe Garofalo | FB | Second | 1976 |
| Joe Smith | FB | Second | 1994 |
| John Stinsman | Base | Third | 1991 |
| John Stinsman | Base | First | 1992 |
| Jon Bracero | Base | Third | 2008 |
| Josh Pagan | Base | Third | 2017 |
| Juan Carlos Torres | Base | Third | 2006 |
| Kadar Jones | FB | First | 2012 |
| Kadar Jones | FB | First | 2013 |
| Kalif Walker | FB | Second | 2007 |
| Kalif Walker | FB | First | 2008 |
| Kashiem Poland | FB | Third | 2011 |
| Keith Washington | Bask | Second | 2011 |
| Kenny Spotwood | Bask | Third | 2007 |
| Kevin "Cat" Compton | Bask | Third | 1980 |
| Kevin McCoy | FB | Second | 1985 |
| Kevin McCoy | FB | First | 1986 |
| Kevin Montero | Base | Third | 2013 |
| Kevin Roche | Base | Third | 2007 |
| Kidanny Cumba | Base | Second | 2013 |
| Lamont Brown | FB | Third | 2004 |
| Lee Felice | FB | First | 1974 |
| Lewis Leonard | Bask | Second | 2006 |
| Lovato Bowman | FB | First | 1994 |
| Lovato Bowman | Base | Third | 1994 |
| Lovato Bowman | Base | Second | 1995 |
| Luis Alicea | Base | First | 2005 |
| Luis Ramos | Base | Third | 2017 |
| Luis Ramos | Base | Second | 2018 |
| Malik Tinsley | Bask | Second | 2008 |
| Marc Price | FB | Second | 2010 |
| Mark Dooling | FB | First | 1987 |
| Mark Dooling | Base | Third | 1988 |
| Marquise Poston | FB | Third | 2013 |
| Matt Colon | Base | Second | 2003 |
| Matt Evangelist | FB | First | 1985 |
| Matt Evangelist | Base | First | 1986 |
| Michael Dolbow | FB | Second | 2000 |
| Michael Robinson | FB | Second | 2001 |
| Michael Rothmaller | FB | Third | 1996 |
| Michael Washington | FB | First | 2003 |
| Mike Anhalt | FB | First | 1977 |
| Mike DiSipio | FB | Second | 1975 |
| Mike Hagen | FB | Second | 1974 |
| Mike McCann | FB | First | 1977 |
| Montik Goodwin | FB | Second | 1989 |
| Naim Franklin | FB | Second | 2015 |
| Nicholas King | Bask | Second | 2001 |
| Nick Herrera | Base | First | 2017 |
| Omar Cruz | Base | Third | 2011 |
| Paul Gebeline | FB | Third | 1991 |
| Paul Shipman | FB | Third | 1988 |
| Petrick Sanders | Bask | Second | 1995 |
| Petrick Sanders | Bask | First | 1996 |
| Phil Andrews | Bask | Third | 1974 |
| Phillip Alston | Bask | Second | 2000 |
| Ralph Hyland | FB | Third | 2015 |
| Ralph Marano | FB | Third | 1986 |
| Ralph Marano | Base | Third | 1987 |
| Ramon Reyes | Base | First | 2006 |
| Randy Whiteman | FB | First | 1974 |
| Rasheed Muhammed | FB | Third | 1997 |
| Ray Williams | FB | Third | 2003 |
| Ray Wolkiewicz | FB | Third | 1977 |
| Raymond Harris | FB | First | 1995 |
| Renz "Rodeo" Compton | FB | First | 2012 |
| Rich Geiger | FB | First | 1973 |
| Rich McKay | Base | First | 1982 |
| Ricky Rolon | FB | Third | 2002 |
| Rico Lugo | Base | First | 2018 |
| Rico Washington | Bask | First | 1982 |
| Robert Gallagher | FB | Second | 1989 |
| Robert Woolford | FB | Second | 1995 |
| Ronald James | FB | Second | 1996 |
| Ronnie Conway | Bask | Third | 1996 |
| Ryan Hardy | FB | Second | 2005 |
| Ryan McGovern | Base | Second | 1998 |
| Ryan McGovern | Base | Second | 1999 |
| Saleem Debnam | FB | Second | 1996 |
| Savoy Martin | FB | Second | 2011 |
| Scott Bonk | FB | Third | 1987 |
| Scott Croft | FB | Third | 1980 |
| Sean Parish | FB | First | 1987 |
| Shareef Miller | FB | First | 2013 |
| Shawn Persson | Base | Second | 1986 |
| Shawn Williams | FB | Second | 2000 |
| Steve Domico | FB | First | 2000 |
| Steve Ebbecke | FB | First | 1971 |
| Steve Szydlik | FB | Second | 1996 |
| Taron Mills | FB | Third | 2009 |
| Tauheed Smith | FB | First | 2009 |
| Terrance "Ted" Cook | FB | Second | 1997 |
| Terrance "Ted" Cook | FB | First | 1998 |
| Terrance Jones | FB | Third | 1996 |
| Theodore McNeil | FB | First | 1999 |
| Thurmon Robinson | FB | Second | 1971 |
| Tim DiGiorgio | FB | Second | 2011 |
| Tim DiGiorgio | FB | First | 2012 |
| Tim Hartman | FB | Second | 1986 |
| Tim Neal | Base | Third | 1998 |
| Tito Davis | FB | Third | 1984 |
| Tom Honeyman | FB | Third | 1987 |
| Tom Sullivan | Base | Second | 1993 |
| Toney Snipes | FB | Second | 1988 |
| Tony Butler | FB | First | 1979 |
| Tony Pace | FB | Third | 1994 |
| Tracy Williams | FB | Third | 2000 |
| Tracy Williams | FB | First | 2001 |
| Tyree Dudley | FB | First | 2006 |
| Tyrell Allen | FB | Third | 2009 |
| Tyrell Martin | FB | First | 2009 |
| Walter Parrish | FB | First | 1978 |
| Wander Nunez | Base | Second | 2009 |
| Wayne Rice | FB | Second | 1991 |
| William "Boo" Minor | FB | Third | 1992 |
| Willie Debnam | FB | First | 1972 |
| Franklin | |||
| Alex Wesby | Bask | First | 1998 |
| Andre Glover | Bask | Third | 2005 |
| Andre Taylor | FB | First | 1996 |
| Anthony Franklin | Base | First | 1984 |
| Anthony Smith | FB | First | 1981 |
| Archie Graham | FB | First | 1973 |
| Boe Davis | FB | Third | 2000 |
| Boe Davis | FB | First | 2001 |
| Brian "Sugar" Smith | Bask | Third | 1984 |
| Brian Harvey | FB | Third | 2014 |
| Bryant Jennings | FB | Third | 2002 |
| Calvin Johnson | Bask | First | 1999 |
| Charles Taylor | FB | First | 1997 |
| Chris Javier | Base | Third | 2018 |
| Chris Sturgis | FB | Third | 2007 |
| Clinton Young | FB | Second | 1975 |
| Dajuan Williams | FB | Third | 1989 |
| Darrell Fincher | FB | Third | 2003 |
| Darryl Gardner | FB | Second | 1983 |
| Darryl Gardner | FB | First | 1984 |
| David Carter | FB | First | 1995 |
| David Carter | FB | First | 1995 |
| Demetrius Town | FB | First | 2011 |
| Deron Miller | Base | First | 1983 |
| Deron Miller | Base | First | 1984 |
| Emmanuel Young | FB | Third | 2012 |
| Frank Anderson | FB | Third | 2005 |
| Gilbert Ford | FB | Third | 1976 |
| Jamal Nichols | Bask | First | 2001 |
| Jamel "Redz" Haggins | FB | First | 2008 |
| James "General" Moore | FB | Second | 1973 |
| James Parker | FB | Second | 1974 |
| James Parker | FB | Second | 1975 |
| Jamie Calloway | FB | Second | 1992 |
| Jamie Calloway | FB | First | 1993 |
| Jason Dunham | Bask | Third | 1999 |
| Javier Buffalo | FB | Second | 2014 |
| Javier Buffalo | FB | First | 2015 |
| Jermaine "Beanie" Smith | FB | Third | 1999 |
| Jermaine "Beanie" Smith | FB | First | 2000 |
| Jerome "Pooh" Richardson | Bask | First | 1984 |
| Jerome "Pooh" Richardson | Bask | First | 1985 |
| Jerry Fulton | FB | Third | 1991 |
| Jerry Fulton | FB | Second | 1992 |
| Karrington Ward | Bask | Second | 1974 |
| Keith Walker | Bask | Second | 1981 |
| Kevin Caldwell | FB | First | 2014 |
| Kevin Glover | FB | Third | 1985 |
| Kevin Glover | FB | First | 1986 |
| Keyon McCloud-Holman | FB | Third | 2015 |
| Lamont McGill | Base | First | 1980 |
| Lawrence Houston | FB | First | 1975 |
| Lydell "Loddy" Boanes | FB | Third | 2008 |
| Marquis White | FB | First | 2009 |
| Maurice Dantzler | FB | First | 2005 |
| Omar Johnson | FB | Second | 1997 |
| Ondria "Andre" Sanders | FB | Second | 1979 |
| Paul "Snoop" Graham | Bask | Second | 1985 |
| Paul Davis | FB | Third | 1978 |
| Phil "Sub" Crump | Bask | Second | 1989 |
| Phil Burton | Bask | Second | 1980 |
| Randy Woods | Bask | First | 1988 |
| Rapheal Rodriguez | FB | First | 2014 |
| Rapheal Rodriguez | FB | First | 2014 |
| Rasheem James | FB | Second | 2015 |
| Reggie Faison | Bask | Second | 1982 |
| Richard Warren | FB | Third | 1998 |
| Rico Washington | Bask | First | 1983 |
| Robert Fowler | FB | Third | 1986 |
| Rodney Hicks | FB | Third | 1998 |
| Steve Harvey | FB | First | 1977 |
| Steve Harvey | Base | First | 1978 |
| Taj Clea | FB | Second | 2014 |
| Tajidin McGough | FB | Third | 2007 |
| Terrell Berthau | Base | Third | 1988 |
| Terrell Berthau | Base | First | 1989 |
| Troy Burton | FB | Third | 1989 |
| Troy Conyers | FB | Second | 2014 |
| Ty "Smack" West | FB | Second | 1989 |
| Tyron Carlton | FB | Third | 2007 |
| Vaughn Coats | Bask | Third | 1979 |
| Vaughn Taylor | FB | Second | 1978 |
| Vic Alexander | Bask | First | 1981 |
| Franklin Learning Center | |||
| Antoine Jefferson | Bask | Second | 1989 |
| Denzel Yard | Bask | First | 2009 |
| Eric Coleman | Bask | Second | 1996 |
| Faron "Meatball" Hand | Bask | Third | 1990 |
| Faron "Meatball" Hand | Bask | First | 1991 |
| Faron "Meatball" Hand | Bask | First | 1992 |
| Joe Brown | Bask | Second | 1995 |
| Malcolm Eleby | Bask | Second | 2007 |
| Michael Green | Bask | Third | 2003 |
| Michael Robinson | Bask | First | 1994 |
| Rasiheed "Noot" Arnold | Bask | First | 1994 |
| Tyrone Weeks | Bask | First | 1991 |
| Tyrone Weeks | Bask | First | 1992 |
| Tyrone Weeks | Bask | First | 1993 |
| Zakee Smith | Bask | Second | 1998 |
| Franklin Towne | |||
| Keith Rycek | Base | Third | 2008 |
| Stephen Callahan | Base | Second | 2015 |
| Tim Hart | Base | Third | 2013 |
| Freire | |||
| Antione "Blue" Singleton | FB | Second | 2007 |
| Jarrod "G" Denard | Bask | First | 2008 |
| Furness | |||
| Kharee Ruley | FB | Third | 2013 |
| Maurice Harris | FB | Third | 2010 |
| Sharif Smith | FB | Second | 2009 |
| Sharif Smith | FB | Second | 2010 |
| Sharif Smith | FB | First | 2011 |
| Future | |||
| Jahreeson Caines | FB | Second | 2011 |
| Syree Groce | FB | Third | 2018 |
| Tysheem Anderson | FB | Second | 2017 |
| Germantown | |||
| Aaron "Snook" Boyd | FB | Third | 2011 |
| Akeem Johnson | FB | Second | 2005 |
| Akil Stokes | FB | First | 2002 |
| Angel Moultair | FB | First | 1999 |
| Antoine Kemp-Smith | FB | Third | 2006 |
| Atiba Kenyatta | FB | Third | 2000 |
| Brent Johnstone | FB | Third | 1992 |
| Brent Johnstone | FB | First | 1993 |
| Byron Smith | FB | Second | 1990 |
| Carlos Bradley | FB | First | 1975 |
| Carlos Bradley | FB | First | 1976 |
| Charles Murphy | Bask | Second | 1976 |
| Chris Wyche | Base | First | 1985 |
| Damon Barr | FB | Third | 1982 |
| Dana McCrewell | FB | First | 1978 |
| Darnell Muse | FB | Third | 1980 |
| Darnell Muse | FB | Third | 1981 |
| DeCarsta "Byrd" Webster | Bask | First | 1974 |
| Delane Hart | FB | Third | 2012 |
| Dennis Hill | FB | Second | 2003 |
| Ed Butler | FB | First | 1999 |
| Ernest "Pop" Lewis | Bask | Third | 1983 |
| *Erik Frazier | FB | Second | 2005 |
| Evan Davis | FB | Third | 1997 |
| Greg "E. Coast" Smith | FB | Second | 1976 |
| Greg "E. Coast" Smith | FB | Third | 1977 |
| James Johnson | FB | Third | 1982 |
| Javer Dillard | FB | First | 1994 |
| Jeffery "Skip" Coles | FB | Second | 1990 |
| Jeffrey "J.T." King | FB | First | 2001 |
| Jephrey Ritter | FB | Second | 1975 |
| Jephrey Ritter | FB | First | 1976 |
| Jerome Watts | FB | Third | 1983 |
| Jimmie Sykes | FB | Third | 1994 |
| Joe Empson | FB | Second | 1974 |
| John Sutton | FB | Third | 1978 |
| John Sutton | FB | Third | 1979 |
| Julius Grant | FB | Second | 1999 |
| Justin Alexander | FB | Second | 1999 |
| Keith Cross | FB | Second | 1974 |
| Ken Coffin | FB | First | 1979 |
| Kenny Greene | FB | Third | 1994 |
| Kermit Overton | FB | Second | 1974 |
| Kevin Fenning | FB | Third | 1978 |
| Kwame Miller | FB | Second | 2011 |
| Lance Johnstone | FB | First | 1990 |
| Lynnard Gross | FB | Second | 1977 |
| Mark Horton | FB | Second | 1998 |
| Marty Lee | Bask | Third | 1972 |
| Mike Sojourner | Bask | First | 1972 |
| Moses Brown | FB | Second | 1986 |
| Omar McDonnaugh | FB | Second | 2002 |
| Ordes Speaks | FB | Third | 1993 |
| Otis Young | FB | Third | 1985 |
| Parrish Reese | FB | Second | 1986 |
| Paul "P.J." Johnson | FB | Third | 2001 |
| Paul "P.J." Johnson | FB | Second | 2002 |
| Ramadan Abdullah | FB | Third | 2009 |
| Randall Richey | FB | Third | 1993 |
| Rasheed Dorn | FB | Third | 1999 |
| Richard Musgrove | FB | Second | 1972 |
| Richard Musgrove | FB | First | 1973 |
| Ricky Ford | Base | First | 1979 |
| Rob Lewis | FB | Second | 1981 |
| Spencer Whetts | FB | First | 1994 |
| Steve Duncan | FB | First | 1982 |
| Terry Bacon | FB | Third | 1996 |
| Terry Robertson | FB | Second | 1995 |
| Tim Claxton | Bask | Second | 1974 |
| Tony Scott | FB | Second | 1977 |
| Vidyapati Bey | FB | Third | 1996 |
| Wendell Thomas | FB | Second | 1979 |
| Wendell Williams | Base | Second | 1978 |
| Wesley Robinson | FB | Third | 1999 |
| Will Parks | FB | First | 2011 |
| *began season with W. Catholic | |||
| Germantown Academy | |||
| Alex Holcombe | FB | Second | 2005 |
| Alex Holcombe | FB | First | 2006 |
| Alex Kaplan | Base | Third | 2003 |
| Alvin Williams | Bask | Second | 1992 |
| Alvin Williams | Bask | First | 1993 |
| Andrew Hanson | Base | Third | 2004 |
| Andrew Hanson | Base | Third | 2005 |
| Andrew Ott | Bask | Third | 2005 |
| Austin Kevitch | FB | Third | 2009 |
| Ben Werkheiser | Base | Third | 2017 |
| Blair Hicks | FB | Second | 1992 |
| Blair Talmadge | FB | First | 1980 |
| Brad Tanner | FB | Second | 1971 |
| Brian Burke | Bask | Second | 1998 |
| Brian Grimes | Bask | Third | 2005 |
| Buddy Brennan | Base | First | 1996 |
| Cameron Ayers | Bask | Second | 2009 |
| Cameron Ayers | Bask | Second | 2010 |
| Charles Wise | FB | Second | 1994 |
| Chris Harvey | Base | First | 2011 |
| Chris Jordan | FB | First | 2000 |
| Chris Krug | Bask | Second | 1997 |
| Chris Krug | Bask | First | 1998 |
| Chris Rodgers | Bask | Second | 2000 |
| Chris Williams | FB | First | 1978 |
| Chuck Boddy | FB | Third | 2011 |
| Coley Murphy | FB | Second | 1993 |
| Colin Kish | Base | First | 2008 |
| Collten Smith | Base | Second | 2018 |
| Craig Shumock | FB | Second | 1976 |
| Craig Shumock | FB | First | 1977 |
| Craig Shumock | Base | First | 1978 |
| Craig White | Bask | Third | 1988 |
| Damon Myers | FB | First | 1993 |
| Dan Brooks | FB | First | 1973 |
| Dan Brooks | FB | First | 1974 |
| Dan Lipschutz | FB | Third | 2006 |
| Dan Lipschutz | FB | Second | 2007 |
| Danny Hoy | Base | First | 2012 |
| Danny Overcash | Base | Second | 2004 |
| Dave Ciambella | FB | Second | 1986 |
| Denis Kane | FB | Second | 1992 |
| Devon Goodman | Bask | Third | 2016 |
| Drew Hood | Base | Third | 1979 |
| Ed Logan | FB | First | 2007 |
| Elijah Wroten | FB | Third | 2016 |
| Elijah Wroten | FB | Second | 2017 |
| Elijah Wroten | FB | First | 2018 |
| Eric Dubas | FB | Third | 2000 |
| Erich Enns | Base | Third | 2006 |
| Evan-Eric Longino | Bask | Second | 2017 |
| Fran Cannon | FB | Second | 1973 |
| Frank Lynch | FB | First | 1989 |
| Frank Marolla | FB | First | 1972 |
| Gary Hufnagle | FB | Second | 1980 |
| Gene Leoni | FB | Second | 1976 |
| Gene Leoni | FB | First | 1977 |
| Greg Davis | FB | First | 1997 |
| Greg Davis | FB | First | 1998 |
| Greg Guers | Base | Second | 2011 |
| Hayes Nolte | FB | Third | 2013 |
| Jack Sullivan | Base | Third | 2018 |
| Jake Dianno | FB | Third | 2016 |
| James Washington | Base | Second | 1990 |
| Jarrod Niedosik | FB | Third | 1988 |
| Jarrod Niedosik | Base | Second | 1999 |
| Jason Novak | FB | Third | 1993 |
| Jay Jordan | FB | Third | 1995 |
| Jay Jordan | FB | Second | 1996 |
| Jim Kehan | FB | Second | 1990 |
| Jim McAfee | FB | Second | 1978 |
| Jim McAfee | FB | Third | 2015 |
| Jim McGeehan | FB | Third | 1988 |
| Jim Slattery | FB | First | 1999 |
| Jim Turner | FB | Third | 1980 |
| Jim Turner | FB | Third | 1981 |
| Jim Turner | FB | First | 1982 |
| Joe Bruderek | Base | First | 1996 |
| Joe Cawley | FB | Second | 2016 |
| Joe Conaway | FB | Third | 2007 |
| Joe Conaway | Base | Second | 2008 |
| Joe Malone | FB | Third | 1990 |
| Joe Matteo | Base | First | 2004 |
| John Aiello | Base | Third | 2014 |
| John Barr | Base | Third | 2005 |
| John Barr | Base | First | 2006 |
| John Barr | Base | First | 2007 |
| John Citrone | FB | Third | 2009 |
| John Lanzidelle | FB | Second | 1978 |
| John Spellman | FB | Third | 1990 |
| Jon Neve | FB | Third | 1998 |
| Jordan Longino | Bask | Second | 2020 |
| Julian Moore | Bask | Second | 2013 |
| Julius Williams | Bask | Second | 1996 |
| Julius Williams | Bask | Second | 1997 |
| Justin Holiday | FB | Third | 2002 |
| Keenan Kish | Base | Third | 2009 |
| Keenan Kish | Base | Second | 2010 |
| Keith Corliss | FB | Second | 2010 |
| Kevin Czaban | FB | Second | 1997 |
| Kevin Doty | FB | Second | 2007 |
| Kevin Doty | FB | Third | 2006 |
| Kevin Gordon | Base | Second | 2004 |
| Kyle Griffin | Bask | Second | 2007 |
| Kyle McCloskey | FB | Third | 2016 |
| Kyle McCloskey | Bask | Second | 2017 |
| Larry Leith | FB | Second | 1991 |
| Larry Leith | FB | First | 1993 |
| Lee Melchionnni | Bask | First | 2002 |
| Mark Nori | FB | Second | 1990 |
| Mark Nori | FB | First | 1991 |
| Mark Nori | Base | Second | 1991 |
| Mark Nori | Base | Third | 1992 |
| Mark Shimrock | Base | Third | 2005 |
| Mark Steffens | Base | Third | 1986 |
| Mark Steffens | Base | First | 1987 |
| Mark Steffens | Base | First | 1988 |
| Marvin Walters | Bask | Second | 1986 |
| Matt Blewitt | FB | First | 1997 |
| Matt Blewitt | FB | Second | 1996 |
| Matt Brown | Base | Third | 2004 |
| Matt Brown | FB | Second | 2004 |
| Matt Brown | Base | Third | 2005 |
| Matt Bruderek | Base | First | 2003 |
| Matt Bruderek | Base | Second | 2004 |
| Matt Gorman | FB | Third | 2016 |
| Matt Walsh | Bask | Third | 2001 |
| Matt Walsh | Bask | First | 2002 |
| Michael Turner | FB | First | 1990 |
| Mike Barnes | FB | Second | 1973 |
| Mike Ciambella | FB | First | 1984 |
| Mike Reilly | FB | Third | 2017 |
| Mike Salaman | FB | Third | 1979 |
| Mike Sharkey | Base | Second | 1991 |
| Mike Sharkey | Base | First | 1992 |
| Mike Slattery | Bask | First | 2001 |
| Mike Techtmann | FB | Third | 2002 |
| Mike Turner | FB | Second | 1989 |
| Nathan Wachter | FB | Third | 1998 |
| Otis Ellis | Bask | Third | 1985 |
| Pat Wade | Base | Second | 1997 |
| Patrick McGettigan | FB | Third | 2015 |
| Patrick McGettigan | FB | First | 2016 |
| Pete "Paco" Vernon | Base | Third | 2003 |
| Pete "Paco" Vernon | Base | Third | 2004 |
| Reed Marko | FB | First | 2007 |
| Rich Howden | Base | Second | 1980 |
| Rick Welsh | Base | First | 1994 |
| Rick Williams | Bask | Third | 1985 |
| Rob Heleniak | FB | Third | 1996 |
| Rob Heleniak | FB | Second | 1997 |
| Rodney Duncan | Bask | Second | 1975 |
| Rodney Duncan | Bask | First | 1976 |
| Ryan Ayers | Bask | First | 2005 |
| Ryan Dolan | FB | Third | 2011 |
| Ryan Dolan | Base | Second | 2012 |
| Scott Grieve | FB | Second | 1980 |
| Sean Coyle | Base | First | 2008 |
| Sean Coyle | Base | Second | 2009 |
| Sean Coyle | Base | First | 2010 |
| Sean Grieve | FB | Second | 2002 |
| Sean Grieve | FB | First | 2003 |
| Sean Grieve | Base | First | 2003 |
| Sean Grieve | Base | First | 2004 |
| Sean Hopkins | FB | Third | 2001 |
| Steve Holmes | FB | First | 1999 |
| Steve Holmes | FB | First | 2000 |
| Steve Sarnocinsi | FB | Third | 2000 |
| Steve Sarnocinski | FB | Third | 1999 |
| T.J. Wudarski | FB | Second | 1999 |
| Tanner Long | FB | First | 2017 |
| Ted Skuchas | Bask | Third | 2002 |
| Timmy Vernon | FB | Third | 2008 |
| Timmy Vernon | Base | First | 2009 |
| Tom Matteo | FB | Second | 2004 |
| Tom Platten | FB | Second | 1973 |
| Tommy Coyle | Base | Second | 2008 |
| Tommy Coyle | Base | Second | 2009 |
| Tyler Stampone | FB | Third | 2003 |
| Tyler Stampone | FB | First | 2004 |
| Tyler Stampone | Base | First | 2005 |
| Tyler Yerk | FB | Second | 2002 |
| Tyler Yerk | FB | Second | 2003 |
| Vince Capone | FB | Third | 2015 |
| Vince Capone | FB | First | 2016 |
| Zack Burwell | FB | Third | 1987 |
| Zack Burwell | FB | First | 1988 |
| Zeke Zabinski | Base | Third | 2013 |
| Germantown Friends | |||
| Chris Hamilton | Base | Second | 2000 |
| Joel Zuercher | Base | Third | 1992 |
| Jonathan Haynes | Bask | Second | 1989 |
| Jonathan Haynes | Bask | First | 1990 |
| Tom Frankel | FB | Third | 1979 |
| Germantown-Stevens | |||
| Tony Weldon | Bask | Second | 1974 |
| Girard Acad. Music Program | |||
| Anthony Venafro | Base | Second | 2007 |
| Danny Ferrazzano | Base | Third | 2000 |
| Desmond Drummond | Base | Second | 2012 |
| Dom Raia | Base | Second | 2010 |
| Dom Raia | Base | Second | 2011 |
| Eric Funaro | Base | Third | 2007 |
| Erik Lipson | Base | Third | 2018 |
| Mario Malatino | Base | Third | 2002 |
| Mario Malatino | Base | Second | 2003 |
| Tommy DeMarco | Base | Second | 1999 |
| Victor Rossi | Base | Second | 1989 |
| Girard College | |||
| Jai Hill | Bask | Third | 1990 |
| Gratz | |||
| Aaron McKie | Bask | Third | 1989 |
| Aaron McKie | Bask | First | 1990 |
| Afumiya McFadden | FB | Third | 1998 |
| Afumiya McFadden | FB | First | 1999 |
| Ameer Ali | Bask | Second | 2005 |
| Amir Baylock | FB | Third | 2015 |
| Amir Gillis | FB | Second | 2016 |
| Amir Gillis | FB | First | 2017 |
| Anthony Millhouse | FB | First | 1975 |
| Anthony Wallace | FB | First | 2004 |
| Antione "Ness" Bland | FB | First | 2009 |
| Antoine Lewis | FB | Third | 1986 |
| Aquil Younger | Bask | Second | 2011 |
| Barry Charles | FB | First | 1985 |
| Bernard Beamon | FB | Second | 1980 |
| Bradley Martin | FB | Second | 2006 |
| Brian Shorter | Bask | Third | 1985 |
| Brian Shorter | Bask | First | 1986 |
| Cameron Brown | FB | Third | 2014 |
| Cameron Brown | FB | Secon | 2015 |
| Charly Timite | FB | Third | 2015 |
| Chris Rhone | FB | Third | 1988 |
| Dennis "Dink" Whitaker | Bask | First | 1986 |
| Donald "Shug" King | FB | Second | 2005 |
| Earl Watford | FB | First | 2007 |
| Eddie Lane | FB | Third | 1997 |
| Eddie Savage | Bask | Second | 1987 |
| Ernest "Bo" Donaldson | Base | Third | 1991 |
| Eugene Wright | FB | Third | 2003 |
| Gary Devlin | Bask | First | 1975 |
| George Winns | Base | Third | 1990 |
| Harry Moore | Bask | Third | 1989 |
| Harry Moore | Bask | First | 1990 |
| James "Noot" Smith | FB | First | 1992 |
| Jarett Kearse | Bask | First | 1997 |
| Javon Whitfield | FB | Second | 2015 |
| Jermaine Robinson | Bask | First | 1999 |
| Jerrick Jenkins | FB | Second | 2006 |
| Jevon Edwards | FB | Second | 2017 |
| Joe Brown | Bask | Third | 1979 |
| Joe Gore | Bask | Second | 1973 |
| Joe Gore | Bask | First | 1974 |
| Jon "Country" Perry | FB | Second | 1993 |
| Jordan Mariney | FB | Second | 2018 |
| Keith Mitchell | FB | First | 1973 |
| Khalil Brown | FB | Third | 2010 |
| Lamont Lee-Edgefield | FB | Third | 2004 |
| Levan Alston | Bask | Second | 1991 |
| Luke White | FB | Second | 2015 |
| Lynard Stewart | Bask | First | 1994 |
| Malik Alvin | Bask | Second | 2006 |
| Mark Tyndale | Bask | First | 2004 |
| Marvin Brown | Bask | First | 1974 |
| Marvin O'Connor | Bask | Second | 1996 |
| Marvin O'Connor | Bask | First | 1997 |
| Maurice "Mardy" Collins | Bask | Second | 2002 |
| Maurice Mazzccua | FB | First | 2017 |
| Michael Cuffee | Bask | First | 2001 |
| Micheal Blackshear | Bask | Second | 2002 |
| Omar Johnson | Bask | Third | 2003 |
| Osiris Jackson | FB | Second | 1989 |
| Percell Coles | Bask | First | 2000 |
| Quasha Carter | FB | Second | 2016 |
| Rahmir Johnson | FB | Third | 2015 |
| Raquan Thomas | FB | First | 2014 |
| Raquan Thomas | FB | First | 2015 |
| Rasheed Wallace | Bask | First | 1991 |
| Rasheed Wallace | Bask | First | 1992 |
| Rasheed Wallace | Bask | First | 1993 |
| Robbie "Beano" Spivey | FB | First | 2002 |
| Robert Alston | FB | Third | 1989 |
| Robert Green | FB | Second | 1976 |
| Roderick Coleman | FB | First | 1994 |
| Rondell Turner | Bask | Second | 1993 |
| Saeed Sheard | FB | First | 2012 |
| Scott Ervin | FB | Third | 2012 |
| Shawn "Reds" Smith | Bask | Second | 1993 |
| Shawn "Reds" Smith | Bask | First | 1994 |
| Shawn "Woozy" Jenkins | FB | First | 2014 |
| Shawn "Woozy" Jenkins | FB | First | 2015 |
| Shawn Smalley | FB | Third | 1988 |
| Shawn Williams | FB | First | 2014 |
| Solly Hamilton | Base | Third | 1989 |
| Solly Hamilton | Base | Third | 1990 |
| Spencer Moses | FB | Third | 2010 |
| Steve Reynolds | FB | Third | 2016 |
| Steve Reynolds | FB | Third | 2017 |
| Terrell Stokes | Bask | Third | 1994 |
| Terrell Stokes | Bask | First | 1995 |
| Terrell Tate | FB | Third | 1979 |
| Terry Pittman | Bask | First | 1981 |
| Tito Cobb | FB | Third | 1993 |
| Todd Johnson | FB | Third | 1984 |
| Tyree Watson | FB | First | 2002 |
| Vincent Turner | FB | Third | 2001 |
| Yassir Stover | Bask | Second | 2020 |
| Haverford School | |||
| Aaron Hudson | FB | Third | 2016 |
| AJ Jones | FB | Second | 2009 |
| Andrew Hoffman | FB | Third | 2000 |
| Andrew Hoffman | Base | Second | 2000 |
| Andrew Landolfi | Base | Second | 2012 |
| Andy Losty | Base | Second | 1994 |
| Aron Morgan | FB | Second | 2011 |
| Aron Morgan | FB | Second | 2012 |
| Asim Richards | FB | Third | 2016 |
| Asim Richards | FB | First | 2018 |
| Bernard Bygott | FB | Third | 1996 |
| Bill Yoh | FB | Third | 1988 |
| Bob McCafferty | FB | First | 1971 |
| Brendan Burke | FB | Second | 2013 |
| Brian Denoncour | FB | Third | 2013 |
| Brian Denoncour | FB | Third | 2014 |
| Brian Denoncour | FB | First | 2015 |
| Bryan Hyland | Base | Second | 2015 |
| Bryan Hyland | Base | Second | 2017 |
| Bryan Savage | FB | First | 2003 |
| Carl Walrath | FB | Third | 2009 |
| Chris Dibello | FB | Second | 2010 |
| Chris Morgan | FB | Second | 2012 |
| Christian Ray | Bask | Second | 2018 |
| Christian Ray | Bask | First | 2019 |
| Colin Hurlbrink | FB | Second | 2016 |
| Colin Hurlbrink | FB | Second | 2017 |
| Craig Born | FB | Third | 1979 |
| Dan Burke | FB | Third | 1983 |
| Dan Coleman | FB | Second | 2003 |
| Dan Mayock | FB | First | 1981 |
| Dan Newhall | FB | Second | 1986 |
| Dave Levinson | Base | Third | 2002 |
| Dave Stilley | FB | First | 1991 |
| Dennis Connor | FB | Third | 1986 |
| Doug Fairfax | Bask | First | 1999 |
| Dox Aitken | FB | First | 2014 |
| Dox Aitken | FB | First | 2015 |
| Dy Cameron | Bask | Third | 1996 |
| E.J. Moyer | Base | First | 1991 |
| Ed McCrystal | Bask | Third | 1987 |
| Eric Hoffman | Base | Second | 2000 |
| Eric Pender | FB | Third | 2005 |
| Frank Cresta | FB | Second | 2015 |
| Frank McCann | FB | First | 1971 |
| George "Skeeter" Newby | FB | Second | 1978 |
| Isaiah Winikur | Base | Third | 2018 |
| Jack Soslow | FB | First | 2014 |
| James McConnon | Base | Third | 2016 |
| Jamie Robinson | Base | First | 1991 |
| Jared Cohen | Base | Third | 2007 |
| Jermaine Ballard | FB | Second | 1990 |
| Jim McConlogue | Base | Second | 2007 |
| Joe Masciantonio | FB | Second | 2001 |
| Joe Maselli | Base | Second | 1982 |
| Joe McCallion | FB | First | 2010 |
| Joe Ricchini | Base | Second | 1997 |
| Joe Ricchini | Base | First | 1998 |
| John Berringer | FB | Second | 1971 |
| John Decker | FB | Third | 2004 |
| John Edelman | Base | Third | 1984 |
| John Gillin | FB | Second | 1980 |
| John Haldeman | FB | First | 1971 |
| John Lieb | FB | Second | 1990 |
| John Lieb | Base | Second | 1991 |
| John Powers | FB | Second | 1985 |
| Jon Burling | FB | Second | 1997 |
| Jon Koffler | FB | Third | 1984 |
| Justin Meyer | Base | Second | 2015 |
| Justin Meyer | Base | Second | 2018 |
| Kevin Carter | FB | Third | 2014 |
| Kevin McGowan | Base | Second | 2013 |
| Kevin McGowan | Base | First | 2015 |
| Lamar Stevens | Bask | Second | 2015 |
| Levan "Shawn" Alston | Bask | Third | 2013 |
| Levan "Shawn" Alston | Bask | Third | 2014 |
| Levan "Shawn" Alston | Bask | Second | 2015 |
| Malik Twyman | FB | First | 2016 |
| Mark Gillin | FB | Third | 1981 |
| Mark Kulesa | FB | Third | 1991 |
| Mark Kulesa | FB | Second | 1992 |
| Mark Lewis | FB | Third | 1995 |
| Mark Mayock | FB | Second | 1979 |
| Mark Mayock | Base | Third | 1979 |
| Mark Mayock | Base | Second | 1980 |
| Matt Galambos | FB | First | 2011 |
| Matt Galambos | FB | First | 2012 |
| Matt Lengel | Base | First | 2010 |
| Matt Lipson | Base | Second | 2010 |
| Matt MacMullan | FB | Third | 1988 |
| Matt MacMullan | Base | Second | 1989 |
| Matt Mayock | FB | First | 1984 |
| Matt McAllister | Base | Second | 2010 |
| Matt Schuh | FB | Third | 1996 |
| Max Silver | FB | Second | 2009 |
| Micah Sims | FB | Second | 2015 |
| Michael Solomon | FB | Second | 2013 |
| Mickey Kober | FB | Third | 2014 |
| Mickey Kober | FB | First | 2015 |
| Mike Edelman | Bask | Third | 1976 |
| Mike Edelman | Bask | Second | 1977 |
| Mike Edelman | Bask | First | 1978 |
| Mike Galetta | Base | First | 2006 |
| Mike Galetta | Base | First | 2007 |
| Mike Mayock | FB | Second | 1973 |
| Mike Mayock | FB | First | 1974 |
| Mike Mayock | FB | First | 1975 |
| Mike Mullarkey | Base | Third | 1992 |
| Mike Vail | FB | Third | 2001 |
| Mike Vail | Base | Third | 2002 |
| Mike Viola | FB | Second | 1995 |
| Nick Craig | Base | Third | 2010 |
| Nick Craig | Base | Third | 2011 |
| Pat Fisher | FB | Second | 2003 |
| Pat Valentine | Base | Second | 2013 |
| Paul McKinney | FB | Second | 1999 |
| Paul McKinney | FB | First | 2000 |
| Paul Tornetta | Base | Third | 1980 |
| Peter Lindquist | FB | Second | 1971 |
| Peter Solomon | FB | Second | 2016 |
| Phil Poquie | FB | Second | 2014 |
| Rashad Smith | FB | Third | 1998 |
| Ray Powers | FB | Third | 1990 |
| Rob Casullo | FB | Third | 2003 |
| Rob Lesnevich | FB | Third | 1982 |
| Ryan Blake | Base | Second | 2011 |
| Sam Clement | FB | First | 1975 |
| Shomari Watts | FB | Second | 2008 |
| Spencer Custiss | Base | Third | 1995 |
| Steve Compton | Base | Third | 1999 |
| Steve Compton | Base | First | 2000 |
| Stuart Geisel | FB | Third | 1982 |
| Terance FitzSimmons | FB | Second | 2008 |
| Tim O'Mara | FB | Third | 1984 |
| Tom Close | Base | Third | 2004 |
| Tom Gallo | FB | First | 1976 |
| Tom Hipple | FB | Second | 1971 |
| Tommy Toal | FB | Second | 2015 |
| Tommy Toal | Base | Second | 2016 |
| Vince Rondolone | Base | First | 2011 |
| Will Barker | FB | First | 2004 |
| Will Katzka | Base | First | 2010 |
| Wyatt Benson | FB | First | 2009 |
| Imhotep | |||
| Aamir Brown | FB | Third | 2016 |
| Aaron Ruff | FB | First | 2013 |
| Ahmad Nowell | Bask | Second | 2022 |
| Ameen Tanksley | Bask | Third | 2010 |
| Ameen Tanksley | Bask | First | 2011 |
| Amin Black | FB | First | 2016 |
| Amir Lewis | FB | Second | 2016 |
| Andre Dreuitt-Parks | FB | Second | 2014 |
| Andre Mintze | FB | First | 2015 |
| Arick Lochetto | FB | Third | 2016 |
| Arick Lochetto | FB | Second | 2017 |
| Brandon Austin | Bask | Second | 2012 |
| Brandon Austin | Bask | First | 2013 |
| Brandon Chatmon | FB | Third | 2012 |
| Brashon Mcrae | FB | First | 2016 |
| Byron Cooper | FB | Second | 2011 |
| Carl Jones | FB | Third | 2017 |
| Chereef Knox | Bask | Third | 2018 |
| Chereef Knox | Bask | Third | 2019 |
| Dahmir Bishop | Bask | Second | 2019 |
| Daniel Jones | FB | Second | 2008 |
| Daron Russell | Bask | Second | 2015 |
| Daron Russell | Bask | Second | 2016 |
| Daron Russell | Bask | First | 2017 |
| Dave Beatty | Bask | Second | 2017 |
| David M. Williams | FB | First | 2012 |
| Deandre Scott | FB | First | 2012 |
| Deandre Scott | FB | First | 2013 |
| Denniston "DJ" Moore | FB | Second | 2013 |
| Denniston "DJ" Moore | FB | First | 2014 |
| Donta Scott | Bask | Second | 2017 |
| Donta Scott | Bask | First | 2018 |
| Donta Scott | Bask | First | 2019 |
| Eerin Young | FB | Third | 2011 |
| Eerin Young | FB | First | 2012 |
| Elijah Taylor | Bask | Second | 2020 |
| Erik Copes | Bask | Second | 2011 |
| Gerald Bowman | FB | Second | 2007 |
| Gordon Thomas | FB | Second | 2013 |
| Isheem Young | FB | First | 2016 |
| Jaekwon Carlyle | Bask | Second | 2016 |
| Jahmir Johnson | FB | Second | 2015 |
| Jalen Denby | FB | First | 2016 |
| Jalen Sutton-Christian | FB | Third | 2017 |
| JohnCarlo Valentin | FB | Third | 2013 |
| JohnCarlo Valentin | FB | First | 2014 |
| JohnCarlo Valentin | FB | First | 2015 |
| Jordan McCray | FB | Second | 2015 |
| Justin Edwards | Bask | First | 2022 |
| Justin Harris | FB | Second | 2016 |
| Justin Johnson | FB | Second | 2016 |
| Justin Johnson | FB | First | 2017 |
| Kamal Harrison | FB | First | 2017 |
| Kashief Edwards | Bask | Third | 2007 |
| Khaleel Evans | FB | Third | 2006 |
| Khalief Evans | FB | Second | 2006 |
| Khyree Wooten | Bask | Second | 2012 |
| Lamar Johnson | FB | Third | 2018 |
| Marlon Westcott | FB | First | 2018 |
| Maurice Palmer | FB | Third | 2010 |
| Mike Crawford | FB | First | 2016 |
| Mike Statham | FB | Third | 2017 |
| Mike Waters | FB | First | 2015 |
| Myles Nicholson | FB | Second | 2017 |
| Najee Goode | FB | Third | 2012 |
| Naseir "Pop" Upshur | FB | First | 2014 |
| Naseir "Pop" Upshur | FB | First | 2015 |
| Nasier Dean | FB | Third | 2018 |
| Nasir Boykin | FB | Third | 2015 |
| Nasir Boykin | FB | Second | 2016 |
| Nicholas Johnson | FB | Third | 2010 |
| Omar Speights | FB | First | 2016 |
| Omar Speights | FB | First | 2017 |
| Parrish Grant | Bask | Second | 2009 |
| Quadeem Starks | FB | Second | 2013 |
| Qwamere Wright-Downing | FB | Second | 2014 |
| Rahmir Barno | Bask | First | 2022 |
| Rashad Savage | Bask | Second | 2008 |
| Romeo Gunt | FB | Second | 2014 |
| Saint McLeod | FB | First | 2018 |
| Saledeem Major | FB | Second | 2008 |
| Saleem Lockett | FB | First | 2016 |
| Sam Prescott | Bask | First | 2009 |
| Sean Lloyd | Bask | Second | 2014 |
| Seifuddin Black | FB | Second | 2014 |
| Shafeek Smith | FB | Third | 2017 |
| Shafeek Smith | FB | First | 2018 |
| Shaka Toney | FB | Third | 2014 |
| Shaka Toney | FB | First | 2015 |
| Shaquille Jones | FB | Third | 2014 |
| Steve Denby | FB | Third | 2013 |
| Sy'mear Williams | FB | Second | 2017 |
| Sy'mear Williams | FB | Second | 2018 |
| Tykee Smith | FB | Second | 2016 |
| Tykee Smith | FB | First | 2017 |
| Tykee Smith | FB | First | 2018 |
| Tyliek Raynor | FB | Second | 2014 |
| Tyrone Barge | FB | Second | 2012 |
| Tyrone Barge | FB | Third | 2013 |
| Yasir Durant | FB | First | 2014 |
| Yasir Durant | FB | First | 2015 |
| Yusuf Terry | FB | First | 2017 |
| Yusuf Terry | FB | First | 2018 |
| Judge | |||
| Adam Nowak | FB | First | 2008 |
| Al Clancy | Bask | Second | 1975 |
| Al Hollawell | FB | Second | 1973 |
| Andrew McHale | FB | First | 2007 |
| Anthony Marascio | FB | First | 2007 |
| Anthony Walker | FB | Third | 2011 |
| Bill McNulty | FB | Third | 1989 |
| Bill Walsh | FB | Third | 1998 |
| Bob Convey | Bask | Second | 1977 |
| Bob File | Base | Third | 1993 |
| Bob File | Base | First | 1994 |
| Bob Greenfield | Base | Second | 2000 |
| Bob Verrelle | FB | Second | 1973 |
| Brandon Spatz | FB | Second | 2012 |
| Brendan Kwisz | FB | Third | 2006 |
| Brett Rickus | FB | Third | 2007 |
| Brian Dulin | FB | Third | 1984 |
| Brian Golderer | Base | Second | 1984 |
| Brian Kearney | Base | Second | 1998 |
| Brian Kearney | Base | First | 1999 |
| Brian Kennedy | FB | Third | 1992 |
| Brian Peacher | Base | Second | 1990 |
| Brian Reidy | FB | First | 1982 |
| Carl Peterson | FB | Third | 2002 |
| Carl Peterson | FB | First | 2003 |
| Casey Jones | FB | Third | 1991 |
| Charlie Schretzman | FB | First | 1983 |
| Charlie Warner | FB | Third | 1990 |
| Chris "Scooter" Ellis | FB | Second | 1987 |
| Chris Fagan | FB | Second | 1987 |
| Chris Gies | Base | Third | 1986 |
| Chris Gies | Base | First | 1987 |
| Chris Roantree | FB | Second | 1998 |
| Christian Lutz | Base | First | 2016 |
| Chuck Bushbeck | FB | Third | 1976 |
| Chuck Bushbeck | FB | Second | 1977 |
| Chuck Kelley | Base | Third | 2017 |
| Chuck Kelley | Base | First | 2018 |
| Colin Devlin | FB | Third | 1988 |
| Connor Foley | FB | Third | 2010 |
| Connor Foley | FB | Third | 2012 |
| Connor Foley | FB | First | 2013 |
| Connor Thompson | FB | Second | 2010 |
| Cosmo Losco | Base | First | 1980 |
| Curt Wortham | FB | Third | 2008 |
| Curt Wortham | FB | Second | 2009 |
| Dale Curry | FB | Third | 2003 |
| Dale Curry | Base | First | 2003 |
| Dale Curry | Base | First | 2004 |
| Dan Casey | FB | Third | 1999 |
| Dan Gallagher | FB | Third | 1987 |
| Dan Graf | FB | Third | 2001 |
| Dan Hammer | Base | Second | 2015 |
| Dan Hammer | Base | First | 2016 |
| Dave Faraldo | FB | First | 2011 |
| Dave Gallo | Base | First | 1979 |
| Dave Kniese | FB | Second | 1990 |
| Dave Waskiewicz | FB | Second | 1984 |
| David Read | FB | Second | 2004 |
| Dennis Klinger | Base | Second | 2000 |
| Dennis Minich | Base | Second | 1982 |
| Dom Carey | FB | First | 2016 |
| Doug Briggs | Base | Third | 1989 |
| Drew Dickson | FB | Third | 1993 |
| Ed McArdle | FB | Second | 1978 |
| Ed McGettigan | FB | Second | 1987 |
| Ed Tamasitis | FB | Third | 1984 |
| Eric Condron | FB | First | 2011 |
| Eric Ruhland | Base | First | 2000 |
| Frank Gubler | FB | Third | 1987 |
| George Beisel | Base | First | 1990 |
| Greg Gallagher | FB | Second | 1981 |
| Greg Hennigar | FB | Second | 2001 |
| Greg Viscusi | Base | Third | 1992 |
| Greg Yodis | FB | Second | 1994 |
| Harry Crane | Base | Third | 2002 |
| Harry Murray | Base | First | 1982 |
| Jacob Bonelli | FB | Second | 1991 |
| Jason Berghaier | FB | Third | 1992 |
| Jason Berghaier | Base | Third | 1993 |
| Jason D'Ambrosio | Base | Second | 2006 |
| Jason Shragher | FB | Second | 1989 |
| Jeff Brewer | FB | Third | 2008 |
| Jeff Jordan | Base | Third | 1989 |
| Jeff McMahon | FB | Second | 2005 |
| Jerry Clothier | FB | Third | 1980 |
| Jerry Gerth | FB | Third | 1994 |
| Jerry Langton | FB | Third | 1985 |
| Jerry Magallanes | FB | First | 1981 |
| Jim "Mo" Connolly | Bask | First | 1976 |
| Jim Benner | Base | Second | 1989 |
| Jim Casey | FB | First | 1997 |
| Jim DiLisio | FB | First | 2007 |
| Jim Edwards | Bask | Second | 1973 |
| Jim Galasso | FB | Second | 2013 |
| Jim Hasher | Base | Second | 2001 |
| Jim Hockel | Base | Second | 1978 |
| Jim Lannigan | FB | Third | 1996 |
| Jim Reeves | Bask | First | 1998 |
| Joe Gallagher | FB | Second | 2014 |
| Joe Garlick | FB | First | 1985 |
| Joe Healy | Base | Second | 1979 |
| Joe Lorenc | FB | First | 1980 |
| Joe Mahoney | FB | First | 1997 |
| Joe Morgan | Base | Second | 1988 |
| Joe Muffler | FB | Second | 1974 |
| Joe Shenko | FB | Second | 1992 |
| Joe Swallow | FB | Second | 2008 |
| John Higgins | Base | Third | 1982 |
| John Luciano | Bask | Third | 1981 |
| John Mohollen | FB | Second | 1985 |
| John O'Hanlon | FB | Second | 1980 |
| John Parsons | FB | Second | 1976 |
| John Shay | FB | First | 1991 |
| Josh Teson | Base | Third | 2013 |
| Jowell Agyedu | FB | Third | 2014 |
| Jude Cooke | FB | Third | 2005 |
| Justin Gies | FB | Second | 2015 |
| Justin Gies | FB | Second | 2016 |
| Justin O'Brien | FB | First | 2001 |
| Katob Joseph | FB | Third | 2017 |
| Katob Joseph | FB | Second | 2018 |
| Keith Chichearo | Base | Third | 2007 |
| Ken Vogt | Base | Third | 1990 |
| Kerry Cahill | Base | Second | 1985 |
| Kerry Cahill | Base | First | 1986 |
| Kevin Conroy | Base | Third | 2008 |
| Kevin Conroy | Base | Third | 2009 |
| Kevin Conroy | Base | First | 2010 |
| Kevin McGerry | FB | First | 1996 |
| Kevin McGerry | Base | Second | 1996 |
| Kevin McGerry | Base | First | 1997 |
| Kirk Bucholski | Base | First | 2000 |
| Kris Dufner | Base | Third | 1997 |
| Kris Dufner | Base | First | 1998 |
| Kurt Estes | FB | Third | 1986 |
| Kurt Sowa | Base | Third | 2011 |
| Larry Lowry | FB | Third | 1985 |
| Marc Fleming | Base | First | 1978 |
| Marc Rodriguez | Bask | Second | 2017 |
| Mark Arcidiacono | FB | First | 1982 |
| Mark Dickson | FB | Third | 2000 |
| Mark Dickson | Base | Third | 2001 |
| Mark Everitt | FB | Third | 1978 |
| Mark Iacovelli | Base | Second | 1984 |
| Mark Iacovelli | Base | First | 1985 |
| Mark Singer | Base | Third | 1980 |
| Marquis Seamon | FB | Second | 2013 |
| Matt Compton | Base | First | 2005 |
| Matt Compton | Base | First | 2006 |
| Matt Donnelly | FB | First | 1981 |
| Matt Kaupp | FB | First | 1975 |
| Matt Schmidt | FB | Third | 1986 |
| Matt Smalley | FB | Third | 2011 |
| Matt Spaeth | Base | Second | 2018 |
| Mike Bailey | FB | Second | 1998 |
| Mike Buchheit | FB | Second | 1986 |
| Mike Elentrio | FB | First | 1983 |
| Mike Fallon | FB | First | 1977 |
| Mike Gies | Base | Third | 1998 |
| Mike Gubler | FB | Third | 1992 |
| Mike Gwynn | FB | Third | 1981 |
| Mike McCloskey | FB | First | 1978 |
| Mike McIntyre | Bask | Second | 1979 |
| Mike McKay | FB | Second | 1975 |
| Mike McLaughlin | Base | First | 2011 |
| Mike Mulherrin | FB | First | 1984 |
| Mike O'Hanlon | FB | Second | 1983 |
| Mike O'Hanlon | Base | Second | 2013 |
| Mike Pidhirsky | Bask | Third | 1999 |
| Mike Stankiewicz | Base | Second | 1979 |
| Mike Stankiewicz | Base | First | 1980 |
| Mike Surina | FB | Second | 1991 |
| Pat Gallo | FB | Third | 1981 |
| Pat Gallo | FB | Second | 1982 |
| Pat Waninger | Base | First | 1982 |
| Paul Gimbel | FB | Second | 1995 |
| Paul Koenig | Base | Third | 2001 |
| Paul Mazurek | Base | Third | 1982 |
| Paul Roken | FB | Second | 2002 |
| Paul Smyth | FB | Second | 1982 |
| Prince Smith | FB | Second | 2014 |
| Raul Quinones | FB | Third | 2011 |
| Rich McCloskey | FB | Third | 1982 |
| Ricky Lannetti | FB | Second | 1999 |
| Rob King | FB | Third | 2016 |
| Robert Taggart | FB | Third | 2015 |
| Ron Filippo | Base | First | 1988 |
| Ryan Kreider | Base | First | 2007 |
| Ryan Langdon | FB | Third | 2008 |
| Savion Perez | FB | Second | 2015 |
| Sean Friel | FB | Third | 1996 |
| Sean Friel | FB | Second | 1997 |
| Stanley Brach | Base | Second | 1982 |
| Steve Arrington | FB | Third | 2017 |
| Steve Ramsey | FB | Second | 1971 |
| Steve Sellers | Base | Second | 2003 |
| Tim Ulrich | Base | Third | 2016 |
| Tom Bayer | FB | Third | 2013 |
| Tom Carboni | FB | First | 1979 |
| Tom DeGeorge | FB | Second | 1998 |
| Tom Hellwarth | Base | Third | 1994 |
| Tom Lynch | FB | Second | 2001 |
| Tom McHugh | FB | First | 1982 |
| Tom Penko | Base | Second | 2016 |
| Tom Robinson | FB | Second | 1984 |
| Tom Robinson | Base | Second | 1985 |
| Tom Ryan | FB | First | 2008 |
| Tom Walsh | FB | Second | 1996 |
| Tony Leneghan | FB | First | 1984 |
| Tony Luca | Base | Third | 1990 |
| Tony Luca | Base | Second | 1991 |
| Tony Marrone | FB | First | 1975 |
| Tony Volpe | FB | Second | 1991 |
| Vince Guckin | FB | First | 1979 |
| Vince Stutz | FB | Second | 1979 |
| Yeedee Thaenrat | FB | Second | 2013 |
| Yeedee Thaenrat | FB | First | 2014 |
| Yeedee Thaenrat | FB | First | 2015 |
| Kenrick / Kennedy-Kenrick | |||
| To Base '93 / FB '93 Forward | |||
| Billy Conners | FB | Third | 1976 |
| Brian Leahy | Bask | Second | 1983 |
| Brian Leahy | Bask | Second | 1984 |
| Chris Cameron | FB | Second | 1984 |
| Chris Mork | FB | Second | 1975 |
| Chris Mork | FB | First | 1976 |
| Dan Rizzo | FB | Third | 1983 |
| Dave Friday | FB | Second | 1984 |
| Dave Nolan | FB | Third | 1977 |
| Ed Denczi | Base | Third | 1978 |
| Eddie Hull | Base | Second | 1987 |
| Emil Boures | FB | Second | 1977 |
| Eric Toth | Base | Third | 1988 |
| Frank Mashett | FB | Third | 1976 |
| Harry Venezia | FB | First | 1978 |
| Jack Dunn | FB | First | 1971 |
| Jack Flore | FB | Second | 1972 |
| Jawood Carlin | FB | Second | 1973 |
| Jim Bolger | Bask | First | 1981 |
| Jim Carroll | FB | First | 1971 |
| Jim Genuardi | FB | Second | 1972 |
| Joe Lelli | FB | Second | 1975 |
| Joe Rowan | FB | Second | 1987 |
| John McGinley | FB | Second | 1986 |
| Jordy Hinkle | FB | Second | 1972 |
| Lou Lombardo | FB | Third | 1976 |
| Mike Boures | FB | Third | 1980 |
| Mike Hober | FB | Second | 1972 |
| Mike Migliarese | Base | First | 1985 |
| Mike Rebar | FB | Third | 1987 |
| Mike Sergio | Base | Second | 1989 |
| Moe Cabot | FB | Third | 1984 |
| Neil Abromavage | FB | First | 1988 |
| Paul Mulholland | Bask | Third | 1976 |
| Ray Ford | FB | Second | 1971 |
| Ray Ford | FB | First | 1972 |
| Rich Wesselt | FB | Second | 1984 |
| Rob Olszewski | Base | Third | 1992 |
| Scott Lawler | Base | First | 1992 |
| Sean Vandegrift | Base | First | 1991 |
| Steve Gambone | FB | First | 1972 |
| Steve Gambone | FB | First | 1973 |
| Steve Hoppel | Base | Second | 1990 |
| Steve Hoppel | Base | Second | 1991 |
| Tom Sergio | Base | Second | 1992 |
| Vinnie Romano | FB | Second | 1978 |
| Al Macchione | Base | Third | 1994 |
| Brian Gillin | FB | Second | 2004 |
| Chris Lubanski | Base | Third | 2001 |
| Chris Lubanski | Base | First | 2002 |
| Chris Lubanski | Base | First | 2003 |
| Chris Santoro | FB | Third | 2007 |
| Christian "Ya-Ya" Walker | Base | Second | 2007 |
| Christian "Ya-Ya" Walker | Base | First | 2008 |
| Christian "Ya-Ya" Walker | Base | First | 2009 |
| Cullen Rota | FB | Third | 2009 |
| Cullen Rota | Base | Second | 2010 |
| Don Zajick | FB | Second | 1993 |
| Greg Sadowski | FB | Third | 1995 |
| Greg Sadowski | FB | First | 1996 |
| Greg Sadowski | FB | Third | 1997 |
| Jermaine Pierce | FB | First | 2005 |
| Jim Boylan | FB | First | 1996 |
| Jim Boylan | Base | Second | 1996 |
| Jim Boylan | Base | First | 1997 |
| Joe Conte | FB | First | 1995 |
| Joe Harvey | Base | Third | 2009 |
| Joe Harvey | Base | Second | 2010 |
| John Couchara | FB | Third | 1994 |
| Jon Humay | Base | Second | 1996 |
| Josh Eidell | Base | Third | 2005 |
| Justin Fazzari | FB | First | 1993 |
| Justin Fazzari | FB | Second | 1994 |
| Kevin Lawrence | FB | Second | 2004 |
| Lenny DelGrippo | Base | First | 2005 |
| Marc DeStefano | FB | Second | 1993 |
| Marc Wagner | Base | First | 2001 |
| Matt Johnson | Base | Second | 2001 |
| Mike Fazio | Base | Third | 2006 |
| Mike Hendrzak | FB | Second | 1996 |
| Mike Hendrzak | FB | Second | 1997 |
| Mike Mann | FB | Third | 2000 |
| Mike Mastrocola | FB | Third | 2008 |
| Phil Mandato | FB | Third | 1993 |
| Rodrick McDowell | FB | Third | 1994 |
| Steve Lepak | FB | Third | 1993 |
| Tom Sergio | Base | First | 1993 |
| King | |||
| Alex Ringgold | FB | Second | 2005 |
| Al-Ma'hi Ali | FB | Third | 2018 |
| Andre Jones | FB | Third | 2004 |
| Barry Moore | FB | Third | 1979 |
| Billy Teel | FB | First | 1983 |
| Brian Beard | FB | Third | 1993 |
| Chris Dorman | FB | Third | 1998 |
| Darryl Kelly | FB | Third | 1982 |
| Dawan Robinson | Bask | First | 2000 |
| Dawayne Young | FB | Second | 2014 |
| Delane Hart | FB | First | 2013 |
| Dimetrius Dial | FB | Third | 2005 |
| Dion "Flea" Whittington | FB | Second | 2002 |
| Dominque McNeil | FB | Second | 2014 |
| Donald Jefferson | FB | Third | 2001 |
| Donnell Donaldson | FB | Third | 1994 |
| Dontae Angus | FB | Second | 2013 |
| Dwayne Cuff | FB | Second | 1992 |
| Dwight "D.J." Patterson | FB | First | 1992 |
| Dywaine Farley | FB | First | 1984 |
| Ed Blake | FB | First | 1976 |
| Fa'Teem Glenn | Bask | Second | 2013 |
| Gary Dunlap | FB | Third | 2001 |
| Gary Irvine | FB | Third | 1981 |
| Gary Irvine | Base | Second | 1982 |
| Greg Jacobs | Bask | Third | 1983 |
| Isiah Allen | FB | Second | 2018 |
| Ivan Felder | Bask | Second | 1981 |
| Jabri McCall | Bask | Third | 2016 |
| Jimmy Harris | FB | First | 1989 |
| John Adams | FB | First | 1982 |
| John Barnett | FB | Third | 1977 |
| Jordan Alexander | FB | Second | 2013 |
| Joseph Walker | FB | First | 2013 |
| Jo-Van Rogers | FB | Second | 1995 |
| Kendell Coleman | FB | First | 2006 |
| Kervin Charles | FB | First | 1994 |
| Kevin Keitt | FB | Third | 1991 |
| Kevin Pride | FB | Third | 1976 |
| Kevin Snyder | FB | Third | 2002 |
| Lormont Sharp | Bask | Third | 1994 |
| Malik Moore | Bask | First | 1996 |
| Marc Daniels | FB | Second | 1996 |
| Marc Wilson | FB | First | 1986 |
| Mark Bristol | FB | Second | 1994 |
| Paul Sanchez | FB | Third | 2015 |
| Qaadir Dixon | FB | Second | 2017 |
| Raheem Scott | Bask | Third | 2002 |
| Ralph McCoy | FB | First | 1997 |
| Rasheim "Feet" Wright | FB | First | 1998 |
| Roland Houston | Bask | Third | 1978 |
| Ron Bryant | FB | Third | 1985 |
| Salim Dixon | FB | Third | 2017 |
| Sammy Foreman | Bask | Second | 2014 |
| Terrence Miles | FB | Second | 1994 |
| Victor Moore | FB | First | 1979 |
| Vince Hardaway | Base | Third | 1981 |
| Wally Mitchell | FB | First | 1989 |
| Wayne Blassingame | FB | First | 1981 |
| Wayne Marshall | Bask | First | 2003 |
| Wilbert "Wrecking" Crew | FB | Second | 1987 |
| La Salle | |||
| Allen Powell | Bask | Third | 2019 |
| Amar Stukes | Bask | First | 2013 |
| Andrew Cossetti | Base | Second | 2016 |
| Andrew Cossetti | Base | First | 2017 |
| Andrew Cossetti | Base | First | 2018 |
| Andrew Wallace | Base | Third | 1992 |
| Anthony Cossetti | Base | Second | 2018 |
| Bernie Fitzgerald | FB | Second | 1976 |
| Bill Frusco | FB | Third | 2013 |
| Bill Tatar | FB | Second | 1992 |
| Bill Warrender | Base | Third | 2006 |
| Bob Ball | Base | Second | 1993 |
| Bob Cooper | Base | Third | 1980 |
| Bob Nix | FB | First | 1972 |
| Brad Schneider | Base | Second | 2014 |
| Brendan ``Bird'' Coyle | FB | Second | 1996 |
| Brett Gordon | FB | Second | 1995 |
| Brett Gordon | FB | First | 1996 |
| Brett Gordon | FB | Third | 1996 |
| Brett Gordon | FB | First | 1997 |
| Brian Buckley | Base | Third | 2014 |
| Brian Curci | FB | Third | 1995 |
| Brian Daly | FB | First | 1989 |
| Brian Donohoe | FB | First | 2001 |
| Brian Hogan | FB | Third | 2003 |
| Brian Schaub | Base | Third | 2018 |
| Bruce Pohlot | FB | First | 2002 |
| Bryan Harvey | Base | First | 2000 |
| Cameron Cappo | FB | Second | 2010 |
| Chikwere "Obi" Amachi | FB | First | 1998 |
| Chip Greenberg | Bask | Third | 1981 |
| Chip Greenberg | Bask | First | 1982 |
| Chip Lloyd | Base | Second | 1983 |
| Chris Ashley | FB | Third | 2006 |
| Chris Brady | FB | Second | 1993 |
| Chris Cabrey | FB | Third | 2006 |
| Chris Curran | FB | First | 1982 |
| Chris Dougherty | FB | First | 1999 |
| Chris Galbally | FB | First | 2002 |
| Chris Gary | FB | Third | 2013 |
| Chris Jeffers | Base | Third | 2002 |
| Chris Kane | FB | Third | 2012 |
| Chris Lazorcheck | Bask | Third | 1990 |
| Chris Maloney | FB | Third | 2015 |
| Chris Maloney | FB | Second | 2016 |
| Chris Maloney | FB | Second | 2017 |
| Chris Massella | Base | First | 1990 |
| Chris Melillo | Base | Second | 2012 |
| Chris Melillo | Base | First | 2013 |
| Chris O'Brien | Bask | Third | 1981 |
| Chris Pennington | FB | First | 1998 |
| Chuck Malloy | Base | Third | 1990 |
| Colin Buckley | FB | Third | 2011 |
| Colin Pyne | Base | First | 2011 |
| Colin Pyne | Base | Second | 2012 |
| Connor Daly | FB | First | 2010 |
| Connor Hoffman | FB | Second | 2009 |
| Connor Kerrigan | FB | Second | 2011 |
| Corey Baiada | Base | Second | 2011 |
| Corey Baiada | Base | First | 2012 |
| Craig Conlin | Bask | Third | 1984 |
| Craig Conlin | Bask | Second | 1985 |
| Dan Fritz | Base | Second | 1993 |
| Dan Karrash | FB | First | 2017 |
| Dan Kuznetsov | FB | Second | 2017 |
| Dan McNichol | FB | Third | 1994 |
| Dan Waters | Base | First | 2002 |
| Dan Waters | Base | First | 2003 |
| Danny Solecki | FB | Second | 2017 |
| Dave DeMara | FB | Second | 1989 |
| Dave Gathman | FB | Second | 1990 |
| Dave Gathman | FB | First | 1991 |
| Dave Kratz | FB | Third | 1988 |
| Dave Wolpert | Base | Third | 1987 |
| David Krmpotich | Bask | Third | 2015 |
| Dillon Trainer | FB | First | 2018 |
| Dominic Cuoci | Base | Third | 2012 |
| Dominic Cuoci | Base | First | 2013 |
| Dominic Cuoci | Base | First | 2014 |
| Donny Quinn | Base | Third | 1994 |
| Doug Atkinson | FB | Third | 1985 |
| Drew Loughery | FB | First | 2008 |
| Drew Loughery | FB | First | 2009 |
| Drew Middlemiss | FB | Second | 1996 |
| Drew Middlemiss | Base | Third | 1996 |
| Drew Middlemiss | Base | First | 1997 |
| Drew Santillo | Base | Third | 1999 |
| Drew Shire | Base | Second | 1989 |
| Duke Wolpert | Base | Third | 1987 |
| Ed Bongard | FB | First | 1997 |
| Ed Bongard | Base | Third | 1997 |
| Ed Bongard | Base | First | 1998 |
| Ed Boron | FB | First | 1996 |
| Ed Sabia | FB | Second | 2000 |
| Ed Sabia | FB | First | 2001 |
| Eddie Meehan | FB | First | 1979 |
| Eddie Mitchell | Bask | First | 2011 |
| Eric Marasheski | Base | Third | 2017 |
| Eric Marasheski | Base | First | 2018 |
| Ernie Barile | FB | Third | 1999 |
| Fran McCaffery | Bask | First | 1977 |
| Frank Natale | FB | Second | 1983 |
| Gabe Marabella | FB | Second | 2000 |
| Garrett Zobel | FB | Second | 2016 |
| Garrett Zobel | FB | First | 2017 |
| Gene Schall | Base | Second | 1987 |
| Gene Schall | Base | First | 1988 |
| George Hudson | FB | First | 2005 |
| George Winslow | FB | First | 1980 |
| George Winslow | FB | First | 1981 |
| Greg Frantz | FB | First | 2006 |
| Gregg Sywulak | Base | Third | 2017 |
| Ian McIntosh | Base | Second | 2015 |
| Jack Forster | FB | Second | 2005 |
| Jack Forster | FB | First | 2006 |
| Jack Pogyor | Base | Second | 2017 |
| Jack Stanczak | FB | First | 1988 |
| Jack Stanczak | Base | Second | 1988 |
| Jack Stanczak | Base | First | 1989 |
| Jake Gandolfo | FB | Third | 2018 |
| Jamal Abdur-Rahman | FB | Third | 2008 |
| Jamal Abdur-Rahman | FB | Second | 2009 |
| Jamal Abdur-Rahman | FB | Third | 2010 |
| Jeff Pietrak | FB | First | 1997 |
| Jeff Pietrak | Base | Third | 1996 |
| Jeff Pietrak | Base | First | 1998 |
| Jim Blount | FB | Second | 1985 |
| Jim Gillies | FB | Third | 1976 |
| Jimmy Herron | FB | Third | 2012 |
| Jimmy Herron | Base | Second | 2013 |
| Jimmy Herron | FB | First | 2013 |
| Jimmy Herron | Base | First | 2014 |
| Jimmy Herron | FB | First | 2014 |
| Jimmy Herron | Base | First | 2015 |
| Jimmy Morrissey | FB | Second | 2015 |
| Joe Aloia | Base | Second | 2009 |
| Joe Forcellini | Base | First | 2011 |
| Joe Migliarese | FB | Third | 2006 |
| Joe Miller | Base | First | 2018 |
| Joe Naji | FB | Second | 2010 |
| Joe Picard | Base | Third | 2013 |
| Joey Burnham | FB | Third | 2017 |
| John Brady | FB | Second | 1981 |
| John Gannon | FB | Second | 1976 |
| John Harrison | FB | Third | 2005 |
| John Harrison | FB | First | 2006 |
| John Harrison | FB | Second | 2007 |
| John Malara | Base | Third | 1999 |
| John Mastronardo | FB | First | 1972 |
| John McBurnie | FB | Third | 2005 |
| John McBurnie | FB | First | 2006 |
| John Poley | FB | Second | 1999 |
| John Reifsnyder | Base | First | 2001 |
| John Reifsnyder | Base | Second | 2002 |
| John Scheffey | Base | Third | 2014 |
| Jon Naji | FB | Second | 2012 |
| Jordan Meachum | FB | Second | 2013 |
| Jordan Meachum | FB | Second | 2014 |
| Keith Conlin | FB | First | 1990 |
| Keith Lachawiec | FB | First | 1995 |
| Kevin Conlin | FB | First | 1992 |
| Kevin Forster | FB | Third | 2009 |
| Kevin Forster | FB | First | 2010 |
| Kevin Kline | Base | First | 1994 |
| Kevin Long | Base | First | 2012 |
| Kevin Noone | FB | Second | 1998 |
| Kevin Olender | Base | Second | 1993 |
| Kevin Olender | Base | Second | 1999 |
| Kornrad Kiszka | Bask | Second | 2019 |
| Kyle Hemcher | Base | Third | 2016 |
| Kyle Shurmur | FB | Second | 2013 |
| Kyle Shurmur | FB | Second | 2014 |
| Liam Trainer | FB | Third | 2017 |
| Luke Persichetti | FB | Second | 2012 |
| Manny Quiles | FB | Third | 2018 |
| Marc Borrelli | FB | First | 1988 |
| Mark Houck | FB | Second | 1991 |
| Matt DiGiacomo | FB | Third | 2009 |
| Matt Howard | Base | Second | 2007 |
| Matt Magarity | FB | Third | 2011 |
| Matt McDermott | FB | Third | 2014 |
| Matt McDermott | FB | First | 2015 |
| Matt McGurkin | FB | Third | 2002 |
| Matt Michel | Base | Third | 2000 |
| Matt Mihalich | Bask | Third | 1976 |
| Matt Raczak | FB | Third | 2013 |
| Matt Raczak | FB | First | 2014 |
| Matt Savage | FB | First | 2015 |
| Matt Zielinski | Base | First | 2005 |
| Matt Zielinski | Base | First | 2006 |
| Max Guevara | FB | Third | 1991 |
| Michael Raczak | FB | Second | 2015 |
| Mike Adamow | FB | Third | 1992 |
| Mike Bennett | FB | Third | 2008 |
| Mike Bennett | FB | First | 2009 |
| Mike Donohoe | FB | Second | 2008 |
| Mike Eife | FB | Third | 2012 |
| Mike Lynch | FB | Third | 2003 |
| Mike Mattern | Base | Third | 1998 |
| Mike Matthews | Bask | Third | 1986 |
| Mike Mattia | FB | First | 1995 |
| Mike Mattia | FB | First | 1996 |
| Mike Pennington | Base | Second | 2005 |
| Mike Piscopo | FB | Third | 2011 |
| Mike Piscopo | FB | Third | 2012 |
| Mike Savage | FB | First | 1998 |
| Mike Villari | Base | Third | 2005 |
| Mike Villari | Base | Second | 2006 |
| Mike Wells | FB | First | 2016 |
| Najee Walls | Bask | Third | 2015 |
| Nate Moss | FB | Second | 2000 |
| Neil O'Brien | Base | Second | 1978 |
| Nick Burns | Base | Third | 2011 |
| Nick Dermo | Base | First | 2014 |
| Nick Rinella | FB | First | 2015 |
| Nick Shattuck | Bask | Third | 2004 |
| Pat Gibson | FB | First | 1987 |
| Pat Gorman | Base | Second | 1996 |
| Pat Riley | Base | Third | 2003 |
| Pat Riley | Base | Third | 2004 |
| Pat Salvitti | Base | Second | 1999 |
| Patrick Hoffman | FB | Second | 2012 |
| Paul Grevy | Base | Second | 1997 |
| Paul Weinacht | FB | First | 1997 |
| Pete Uzelac | FB | Second | 1973 |
| Rob Forster | FB | Second | 2003 |
| Roger Harrington | Base | Third | 1990 |
| Roger Harrington | Base | Second | 1991 |
| Roger Harrington | Base | First | 1992 |
| Ron Puggi | FB | Second | 1994 |
| Ryan Brady | FB | Second | 2014 |
| Ryan Cain | FB | Second | 2006 |
| Ryan Coonahan | FB | First | 2013 |
| Ryan Coonahan | Base | Third | 2014 |
| Ryan Eidenshink | FB | Second | 2008 |
| Ryan Geiger | FB | First | 2010 |
| Ryan Harrington | Base | Second | 1995 |
| Ryan Marsh | FB | Third | 1989 |
| Ryan Parfitt | FB | Second | 2000 |
| Ryan Parfitt | Base | Third | 2000 |
| Ryan Parfitt | Base | First | 2001 |
| Ryan Savage | FB | Second | 2018 |
| Ryan Willis | FB | Third | 2018 |
| Ryan Winslow | FB | Second | 2010 |
| Ryan Winslow | FB | Second | 2011 |
| Ryan Winslow | FB | First | 2012 |
| Sam Feleccia | FB | Second | 2008 |
| Sam Feleccia | FB | First | 2009 |
| Sean Abbott | FB | Third | 2008 |
| Sean Burke | FB | First | 2011 |
| Sean Coleman | FB | Second | 2011 |
| Sean Coleman | FB | First | 2012 |
| Sean Daly | FB | Third | 2018 |
| Sean Hunsicker | FB | First | 1995 |
| Sean McDermott | FB | First | 1992 |
| Sean Miller | FB | Third | 2001 |
| Sean Saverio | Base | Third | 2006 |
| Sean Saverio | FB | Second | 2006 |
| Sean Saverio | Base | First | 2007 |
| Shane Brady | FB | First | 2009 |
| Shawn O'Brien | Base | Second | 1991 |
| Shawn O'Neill | Base | Third | 2008 |
| Shawn O'Neill | Base | First | 2009 |
| Steve Sinnott | FB | First | 2009 |
| Steve Szostak | FB | First | 2009 |
| Syaire Madden | FB | Third | 2015 |
| Syaire Madden | FB | First | 2016 |
| T.J. Garvin | FB | Third | 2015 |
| Tim Black | FB | Third | 1999 |
| Tim McDonald | FB | Second | 1998 |
| Tim Wade | FB | First | 2011 |
| Tom Craig | FB | Third | 1991 |
| Tom Gizzi | FB | First | 1984 |
| Tom Spiteri | FB | First | 2012 |
| Tony Cossetti | Base | Third | 1989 |
| Tre McNeill | FB | First | 2016 |
| Troy Hockaday | Bask | Second | 2010 |
| Troy Holland | FB | Second | 2017 |
| Tyler Freeman | Base | Second | 2009 |
| Tyler Kozeniewski | Base | Second | 2012 |
| Zac Hess | Base | Second | 2004 |
| Zaire Franklin | FB | First | 2012 |
| Zaire Franklin | FB | First | 2013 |
| Zaire McLaurin | FB | Third | 2018 |
| Lamberton | |||
| Andre Daniel | Bask | Second | 1989 |
| Brandon "Pooh" Gary | Bask | Second | 2000 |
| Gerald McGonigle | Base | Second | 1985 |
| Kareem Pilgrim | Bask | Second | 1999 |
| Troy Daniel | Bask | Second | 1984 |
| Lansdale Catholic | |||
| Bill Piotrowicz | FB | Third | 2017 |
| Danny Dutkiewicz | FB | Third | 2017 |
| Danny Dutkiewicz | FB | Second | 2018 |
| Devon Barrett | FB | Second | 2010 |
| Ifeanyi Okorji | FB | Third | 2016 |
| Jake Doheny | FB | Third | 2017 |
| John Howell | FB | Second | 2008 |
| Jon Motts | Base | Third | 2012 |
| Matt Brudenski | FB | Third | 2018 |
| Matt Casee | FB | Third | 2017 |
| Matt McGouldrick | FB | Third | 2009 |
| Matt Pinzka | FB | Third | 2010 |
| Nick Manai | Base | Third | 2009 |
| Rory Clemens | Base | First | 2011 |
| Ryan Quigley | FB | Second | 2014 |
| Ryan Quigley | FB | Second | 2015 |
| Stefan Swaintek | Base | Third | 2010 |
| Zach Talley | FB | Third | 2013 |
| Lincoln | |||
| Allston Augustin | FB | Third | 2016 |
| Avery Jones | FB | Third | 1988 |
| Bernard Franklin | FB | Second | 2003 |
| Bill Cook | FB | First | 1977 |
| Bill Cook | Base | Third | 1978 |
| Bobby Miller | FB | First | 1983 |
| Bruce Carthon | FB | First | 1978 |
| Carlin Edwards | FB | Second | 2005 |
| Charlie Peoples | FB | Second | 1987 |
| Charlie Peoples | FB | First | 1988 |
| Chuck Casper | FB | First | 1982 |
| Corey McElveen | FB | Third | 1979 |
| Courey Burrell | FB | Second | 2006 |
| Craig Kuptsow | FB | First | 1972 |
| Craig Pfeifer | FB | Second | 1975 |
| Darren Miller | FB | Third | 1977 |
| Darrien Peoples | FB | Third | 1992 |
| Dennis Moore | FB | Second | 1988 |
| Dennis Tygh | FB | Second | 1996 |
| Dennis Tygh | Base | Third | 1997 |
| Drew DeMarco | FB | Third | 1978 |
| Ed Kaisinger | FB | Second | 1979 |
| Eric Cintron | Base | Second | 2014 |
| Erich Houser | Base | Third | 1999 |
| Gary Neugebauer | FB | Third | 1976 |
| Gary Schneider | FB | Second | 1982 |
| Greg Heard | FB | Second | 1972 |
| Horace Jackson | FB | Second | 1988 |
| Jack MacIlvain | FB | Second | 1977 |
| Jim McCusker | Base | Third | 1985 |
| Joe DiGrazio | FB | Second | 2004 |
| Joe McCausland | FB | Third | 2009 |
| Joe Nedley | FB | First | 1974 |
| John Whitley | FB | Second | 1973 |
| Keita Crespina | FB | First | 1988 |
| Keith Michalak | FB | Second | 1991 |
| Keith Michalak | Base | Third | 1991 |
| Keith Michalak | Base | Third | 1992 |
| Ken Dysart | Base | Second | 1986 |
| Kevin Chilton | FB | Third | 2007 |
| Khalif Meares | Bask | First | 2018 |
| Louis Purr | FB | Third | 2004 |
| Louis Purr | FB | Third | 2005 |
| Mahlon Crampton | FB | Second | 1991 |
| Mannie Adens | FB | First | 1989 |
| Marc Foster | FB | First | 1984 |
| Mark Ryan | FB | First | 1976 |
| Mark Slade | FB | Third | 1979 |
| Marq. "Marty" McFarland | FB | Third | 2011 |
| Martin Campbell | FB | Second | 1973 |
| Mike Little | FB | Third | 1982 |
| Mike McDonald | Base | First | 1995 |
| Mike Slade | FB | First | 1979 |
| Nate London | FB | First | 1987 |
| Omar Black | FB | First | 2009 |
| Otis Young | FB | First | 2003 |
| Perry Linton | FB | Third | 1976 |
| Pete DiDonato | Base | Third | 1991 |
| Phil Atwell | FB | Third | 1980 |
| Phil Atwell | FB | Third | 1981 |
| Reggie Johnson | FB | Second | 1983 |
| Rich Zimmerman | Base | Second | 1982 |
| Rick Dennis | Bask | Third | 1979 |
| Ron Clarkson | Base | First | 2001 |
| Rus Slawter | Base | Second | 1981 |
| Sam Karr | FB | First | 2017 |
| Shahfin Timmons | FB | Second | 2001 |
| Shaquil Bender | Bask | Third | 2020 |
| Sincere Merced | FB | Third | 2011 |
| Steve Gallo | Base | Third | 2002 |
| Steve Holiday | FB | First | 1980 |
| Steve Holiday | Base | Second | 1981 |
| Talib-Din O'Conner | FB | Third | 1994 |
| Terrell Denson | FB | Second | 2004 |
| Tim Leach | FB | Second | 1994 |
| Tim Szychulski | Base | Third | 2002 |
| Tom Riess | FB | First | 1979 |
| Tom Wright | Base | Third | 1988 |
| Tony Falice | FB | Second | 1986 |
| Tony Piscopo | FB | First | 1978 |
| Victor Mejia | Base | Second | 2017 |
| Wendell Birch | FB | Third | 1979 |
| Zachary Armwood | FB | Second | 1979 |
--