City Players on All-Scholastic FB Teams, 1932-1970
(The Bulletin's
All-Scholastic Teams were comprised of the BEST
players from the five-county
area; scholastic achievement was not a consideration. These are
honorees from Public, Catholic
and Inter-Ac schools.)
Return to TedSilary.com Home Page
| 1932 | ||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Walt "Babe" Marshall | Gratz |
| G | Stan Adamczyk | North Cath. |
| G | Harry "Reds" McNally | Frankford |
| E | Bill Lane | Overbrook |
| E | Chick Sutter | La Salle |
| QB | Bud Maguire | West Cath. |
| HB | Harry Harrison | West Phila. |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | Joe Avellino | Southern |
| G | Len Leonard | West Phila. |
| G | Jim Chanowicz | West Cath. |
| T | Phil Fowler | Penn Charter |
| T | Jim Auch Sr. | St. John's |
| E | Lucian Bell | Germantown |
| QB | Rader Huey | Montgomery |
| HB | Fran Murray | SJ Prep |
| HB | Marty Quick | Northeast |
| FB | Frank Tozar | West Cath. |
1933 |
||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Walt "Babe" Marshall | Gratz |
| G | Leroy "Mimi" McKee | Frankford |
| G | Joe DeLone | SJ Prep |
| T | Stan Chanowicz | West Cath. |
| QB | Bob Dougherty | SJ Prep |
| HB | Harry Harrison | West Phila. |
| FB | Paul Bartolomeo | Southern |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| G | Joe Missar | West Cath. |
| G | Walt Gunning | Gratz |
| T | Bud Pollock | Northeast |
| E | John Peranteau | SJ Prep |
| QB | Ed Givens | Fds. Central |
| HB | Chick Rainear | Hav. School |
| FB | Chris Pappas | Frankford |
1934 |
||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| G | Harry Stoll | SJ Prep |
| G | Walt Gunning | Gratz |
| T | Mike Rutecky | Northeast |
| T | Jim McGoldrick | West Cath. |
| E | Marty Pertnoy | Central |
| QB | Bill Denise | Gtn. Academy |
| HB | Harry Harrison | West Phila. |
| HB | Bob Taylor | Frankford |
| FB | Ed Schwop | North Cath. |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | Ted Helmetag | Gtn. Academy |
| T | Bud Palmer | North Cath. |
| E | John Gallagher | Roman |
| E | Orlyn Kimmell | Frankford |
| HB | Eddie Collins Jr. | Episcopal |
| FB | Chas. "Sonny" Brown | Gtn. Academy |
1935 |
||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Ed McFarland | Frankford |
| G | Tony Periria | Northeast |
| G | Harry Stoll | Montgomery |
| T | Charles Perkins | Hav. School |
| T | Bill Harrington | Roman |
| E | John Rumig | West Cath. |
| QB | Jack Burns | SJ Prep |
| FB | Gus Gerasimas | North Cath. |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | Bill McCoy | West Cath. |
| G | Nick DeSimone | Central |
| T | Walt Moeling | Penn Charter |
| T | Bud Carson | West Cath. |
| E | Ed Picker | Olney |
| QB | Dick Light | Hav. School |
| HB | Ed Marre | West Cath. |
| HB | Jerry Neri | Southern |
| FB | Walt Daly | Montgomery |
1936 |
||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Ed McFarland | Frankford |
| G | Harold Jastrow | Olney |
| T | Walt Moeling | Penn Charter |
| T | Clarence King | Southern |
| E | Stan Gardecki | Salesianum |
| QB | Frank Reagan | North Cath. |
| HB | John Quick | Northeast |
| HB | Lyndman Simmerman | Fds. Central |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| G | Tom Brady | Roman |
| G | Thacher Longstreth | Hav. School |
| T | Dom Montero | Salesianum |
| T | Frank McGeary | North Cath. |
| E | Joe Moss | Central |
| E | Bob Doran | SJ Prep |
| QB | Harry Seltzer | West Phila. |
| HB | Bobby Miller | Montgomery |
1937 |
||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Oscar Thatcher | Northeast |
| G | Frank Bushek | SJ Prep |
| G | Dom Montero | Salesianum |
| T | Jim Emery | Northeast |
| T | Clarence King | Southern |
| E | Frank McKernan | West Cath. |
| B | John Sadlik | North Cath. |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | Jim Donahue | North Cath. |
| G | Ed McDowell | West Phila. |
| G | Dick Debler | Germantown |
| T | Mike Mandarino | West Cath. |
| E | Al Will | Frankford |
| E | Hank Christman | St. John's |
| QB | Bill Harrington | Southern |
| FB | John Nolan | SJ Prep |
1938 |
||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Dave Williams | West Phila. |
| G | Ed Odachowski | Salesianum |
| G | John Hughes | St. John's |
| T | Al Stevenson | Central |
| E | Frank McKernan | West Cath. |
| E | Bert Kuczynski | Northeast |
| B | Jack Warner | Gtn. Academy |
| B | Tom Patchel | SJ Prep |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | Walt Kmecik | Frankford |
| G | Dick Debler | Germantown |
| E | Tom Graham | Olney |
| QB | Erle Baugher | Northeast |
1939 |
||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| G | Andy Wolfrum | Frankford |
| G | Al Skavicus | Roman |
| T | George Larkin | SJ Prep |
| T | Walt Stickel | Northeast |
| E | Mike Kraynak | Southern |
| E | John "Tex" Flannery | La Salle |
| QB | George Stanley | Episcopal |
| B | Bill Brady | SJ Prep |
| B | Erle Baugher | Northeast |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | Jim Webb | North Cath. |
| G | John Nevadunsky | Northeast |
| T | Mike Jarmoluk | Frankford |
| T | Bernie Gallagher | South Cath. |
| E | Bill Wetherill | Episcopal |
| QB | Bob Diamond | Penn Charter |
| B | Al Postus | ST More |
| B | Jerry Weisenberger | St. John's |
1940 |
||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| G | Tom Kenney | SJ Prep |
| G | Andy Wolfrum | Frankford |
| T | Walt Stickel | Northeast |
| E | Al Channell | North Cath. |
| B | Jack Kelly | West Cath. |
| B | "Indian" Joe Nejman | Frankford |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | Jim Webb | North Cath. |
| G | Bud Honeysett | Gtn. Academy |
| T | Sam Donnelly | La Salle |
| E | Joe Schofield | Roxborough |
| B | Bob Safrin | Gtn. Academy |
| B | Phil Lillie | Episcopal |
1941 |
||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Marty Keane | La Salle |
| G | Paul Lhulier | West Cath. |
| T | Matt Sholomskas | Frankford |
| E | Chas. "Sonny" Leonard | West Phila. |
| E | Bill Shellenberger | Gtn. Academy |
| B | Joe McAfee | St. John's |
| B | Jack McTamney | SJ Prep |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | Al Gornish | West Phila. |
| G | Norm Green | Germantown |
| G | Ray Pratt | Franklin |
| T | Bob Fahy | St. John's |
| T | Tom Smith | SJ Prep |
| E | John Conlan | Roman |
| B | Hugh McClelland | Episcopal |
| B | Romeo Capriotti | Frankford |
| B | John Willis | West Cath. |
| B | Hugh Jeffers | South Cath. |
1942 |
||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Frank Temple | West Cath. |
| G | Bob Lange | SJ Prep |
| G | George Burpee | Penn Charter |
| T | Bob Esterly | Northeast |
| E | Dan Brown | West Cath. |
| E | Bob McKinney | Germantown |
| B | Mickey McLaughlin | SJ Prep |
| B | Francis "Bud" Williams | West Phila. |
| B | Bill Bernardo | Germantown |
| B | Joseph "Bud" Sutton | Northeast |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | Bob Mostertz | Germantown |
| G | Sam Rubin | West Phila. |
| G | Jack Buckley | Episcopal |
| T | Pete Petrosky | North Cath. |
| T | Walt Haas | South Cath. |
| B | Joe Rogers | Roman |
| B | Jim Dugan | North Cath. |
1943 |
||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | John Witsch | Northeast |
| G | Jim Reilly | La Salle |
| T | Reeves Collins | Central |
| E | Tom Kelleher | North Cath. |
| E | Dan Brown | West Cath. |
| B | Newbold Smith | Episcopal |
| B | Vince McPeak | SJ Prep |
| B | John Tulskie | West Cath. |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | Jim Quigley | ST More |
| G | John Davis | West Phila. |
| G | Ed Lannigan | North Cath. |
| T | Pete Murphy | West Cath. |
| T | Charles Klossman | Bartram |
| B | Al Papa | Overbrook |
| B | Ed Carr | Olney |
| B | Bill Jones | Northeast |
1944 |
||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Milt Komarnicki | Southern |
| G | George McAndrews | West Cath. |
| T | John Russell | Hav. School |
| E | Mike Bogan | West Cath. |
| B | Bill Jones | Northeast |
| B | Ed Carr | Olney |
| B | Joe Byers | SJ Prep |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| G | Bob Patterson | Northeast |
| T | Ted Zygmont | Roxborough |
| T | Mike Boyle | Roman |
| E | Jim Seifert | Frankford |
| E | Joe Gorman | South Cath. |
| B | Vic Mauck | Hav. School |
| B | James Sundstrom | La Salle |
| B | Anth. "Reds" Coletta | Southern |
| B | Bob Connor | West Cath. |
1945 |
||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Ben Burdetsky | Southern |
| G | Norman Moore | Penn Charter |
| G | Jack Levin | Northeast |
| T | Mike Boyle | Roman |
| T | Ted Zygmont | Roxborough |
| E | Fritz Thornton | Hav. School |
| E | Fran Desmond | St. James |
| B | Jack Idzik | North Cath. |
| B | Fran. "Reds" Bagnell | West Cath. |
| B | Jack Del Bello | Southern |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| G | Al Kunberger | South Cath. |
| T | Stan Greenwald | Northeast |
| T | Jerry Kane | West Cath. |
| E | Frank McCartney | West Cath. |
| B | Joe Ward | St. James |
| B | Anth. "Reds" Coletta | Southern |
| B | Tony Cervino | Penn Charter |
| THIRD TEAM | ||
| G | Tom Zachweija | Roman |
| G | Bernie Lemonick | Olney |
| E | Harry West | Central |
| B | Charley Albertus | West Cath. |
1946 |
||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Carl Foust | West Cath. |
| G | Hugh Boyd | Northeast |
| G | Joe Gould | North Cath. |
| T | Frank Donohue | La Salle |
| T | Ernie Prudente | Fds. Central |
| E | Fritz Thornton | Hav. School |
| B | Charley Albertus | West Cath. |
| B | John Papit | Northeast |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| Pos. | Player | |
| G | Bob McCann | Southern |
| G | John Hauck | Frankford |
| T | Tom O'Reilly | North Cath. |
| E | Frank Carbona | Roman |
| E | Joe Ciasullo | Northeast |
| B | Mike Tucker | Roman |
| B | Anth. "Reds" Coletta | Southern |
| B | Bernie Custis | Bartram |
| 1947 | ||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Bob Gibson | West Phila. |
| G | John Michels | West Cath. |
| G | Joe Tyrrell | Roman |
| T | Lou DeVicaris | Frankford |
| E | Ralph Brosious | Central |
| E | Joe Ciasullo | Northeast |
| B | Frank Brill | Roman |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| G | John Laino | Southern |
| T | Ray Stankus | North Cath. |
| E | Charles McElwee | Frankford |
| B | Fred Gloeckner | Gtn. Friends |
| B | Bob Doyle | SJ Prep |
1948 |
||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| G | John Martin | Bartram |
| G | John Michels | West Cath. |
| T | Bob Evans | Roman |
| E | Joe Schultz | South Cath. |
| E | John Orsino | Northeast |
| B | Bill Brannau | South Cath. |
| B | Ernie Liberati | Frankford |
| B | Fran Wissman | North Cath. |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| Pos. | Player | |
| C | Marty Abramson | Central |
| G | Ed Lynn | North Cath. |
| G | Joe Stockridge | Northeast |
| T | Dave Lill | Frankford |
| T | Jack Dunn | South Cath. |
| B | Dick Bedesem | La Salle |
1949 |
||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Herman Sweeney | St. James |
| G | Ernie Miller | North Cath. |
| G | Nelson Dewey | Hav. School |
| T | Ed Cook | South Cath. |
| E | Len Oniskey | Roman |
| B | Ken Smith | Episcopal |
| B | Les Graves | Gratz |
| B | John Kitabjian | Frankford |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | Larry Cardonick | Olney |
| G | Pete Carrieri | Southern |
| G | Don Shea | St. James |
| T | Tom Franklin | Episcopal |
| E | John Lavin | South Cath. |
| E | Rudy Miles | Dobbins |
| B | John Solari | South Cath. |
| B | Stan Lis | Northeast |
| B | Francis Berk | North Cath. |
1950 |
||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Robert Burns | Germantown |
| G | Larry Cardonick | Olney |
| G | Ted Peetros | Gtn. Academy |
| E | John Lavin | South Cath. |
| B | Rod Haughey | North Cath. |
| B | Charlie Guida | Bok |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| G | John Angelini | Roman |
| G | Bob Waters | North Cath. |
| T | Bill McClung | Bok |
| E | Joe Gilfillan | Penn Charter |
| E | John Morris | SJ Prep |
| B | Harold Johnston | Episcopal |
| B | Angelo Cairo | Germantown |
| B | Tony Latronica | South Cath. |
| B | Charley Bruno | Frankford |
1951 |
||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| G | John Angelini | Roman |
| T | Charley Pastorius | West Cath. |
| E | Jay Norman | Mastbaum |
| B | John McDonnell | South Cath. |
| B | John McEachern | West Cath. |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| G | Frank DeRusso | Central |
| T | Dan Lerro | Southern |
| E | John McKernan | West Cath. |
| B | Ed Moore | Frankford |
| B | Bob Glascott | Roman |
1952 |
||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Grant Dunn | Hav. School |
| G | Remie Smith | Lincoln |
| G | Andy McFadden | West Cath. |
| T | Jim DiGrazio | South Cath. |
| E | George Atherholt | Gtn. Academy |
| B | Irvin "Bo" Roberson | Bartram |
| B | Bob Glascott | Roman |
| B | Jim Walsh | North Cath. |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| T | John O'Brien | Gtn. Academy |
| E | Ed Kerpius | North Cath. |
| B | Bob Lassen | Gtn. Academy |
| B | Dick Christy | St. James |
1953 |
||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Grant Dunn | Hav. School |
| G | Mike Romanausky | Frankford |
| G | Ted Sloan | Gtn. Academy |
| T | Ray Lyons | North Cath. |
| E | Dave Roak | Episcopal |
| B | Paul Boldin | Northeast |
| B | Dick Christy | St. James |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | Tom Defosse | St. James |
| G | Henry Nacrelli | St. James |
| G | Bill Miles | St. John's |
| T | Frank Brody | Northeast |
| T | Joe Happe | Penn Charter |
| E | Jim Fraser | Gtn. Academy |
| B | Hal Kolinsky | Lincoln |
1954 |
||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Dick Beschen | ST More |
| G | Fred Goodyear | Penn Charter |
| T | Ray Lardani | South Cath. |
| E | Joe Pullekines | St. James |
| E | Jim Fraser | Gtn. Academy |
| B | Jim Grazione | South Cath. |
| B | John Wright | Frankford |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | Walt Buckley | Episcopal |
| G | Tony Capuano | South Cath. |
| T | Don Novak | Central |
| B | Lee Elia | Olney |
| B | Tom Pasquini | Bok |
1955 |
||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Paul Holloway | Germantown |
| G | Bill Brooks | La Salle |
| T | Fred Coe | Gtn. Academy |
| E | Barney Berlinger | Penn Charter |
| B | Angelo Coia | Northeast |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | Leo Broadhurst | St. James |
| G | Jim Auch | Malvern |
| E | Mickey Heinecken | Central |
| B | Herb Adderley | Northeast |
| B | Geo. "Bubbles" Miller | Gratz |
| B | Bob Raucci | Southern |
1956 |
||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Tony Radano | Bonner |
| G | Frank Temme | Gtn. Academy |
| T | Dick Geist | Lincoln |
| E | Hugh McGough | Roman |
| B | Herb Adderley | Northeast |
| B | Marty Qualtieri | North Cath. |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | Ed Belzer | Roxborough |
| G | Clark Hodgson | La Salle |
| G | Bob Koreck | North Cath. |
| E | Mickey Heinecken | Central |
| B | Lee Jackson | Penn Charter |
| B | Ted Mordecai | West Phila. |
| B | Chick Downham | Gtn. Academy |
| B | Ron Greene | Overbrook |
1957 |
||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Ed Weihenmayer | Penn Charter |
| G | Connie DeSantis | Gtn. Academy |
| T | Jack Sherer | Lincoln |
| E | Tom Wynne | St. James |
| E | John George | Frankford |
| B | John Herrera | La Salle |
| B | Jim Pownall | Roxborough |
| B | Greg Puckett | North Cath. |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | Dave Moses | Overbrook |
| G | Tom Yannessa | La Salle |
| T | George Reistad | Roxborough |
| T | Joe Blasenstein | West Phila. |
| E | Frank Scornaienchi | Lincoln |
| B | Stan Krynski | Frankford |
1958 |
||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Bruce Hartman | Penn Charter |
| G | Bob Kowalski | SJ Prep |
| G | Joe Blasenstein | West Phila. |
| T | Jack Sherer | Lincoln |
| E | Andy Terifay | Neumann |
| E | Mark Smith | Frankford |
| B | Scott Maxwell | La Salle |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | Walt Wolfrum | Olney |
| G | Fran Heckler | La Salle |
| T | George Stratts | St. James |
| E | Frank Scornaienchi | Lincoln |
| B | Jamie Hoover | Penn Charter |
| B | Bob Theiss | Gtn. Academy |
1959 |
||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Bill Burns | West Cath. |
| G | Tony Rizzotte | Malvern |
| G | Barry Dunleavy | La Salle |
| T | Jim Lang | Bartram |
| T | Tom Wriggins | Penn Charter |
| B | Tony Dolceamore | Bonner |
| B | John Ciocari | Central |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | Roger Agin | La Salle |
| G | Joe Capewell | Edison |
| T | Dave Mitro | St. James |
| E | Rich Tatum | Olney |
| B | Bernie Dallas | Gtn. Academy |
| B | Russ Hendricks | Bonner |
1960 |
||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Roger Agin | La Salle |
| G | Bill Samuel | Frankford |
| E | Frank Gallagher | St. James |
| E | Dave Geyer | Penn Charter |
| B | Fran Dougherty | West Cath. |
| B | Russ Hendricks | Bonner |
| B | Bernie Dallas | Gtn. Academy |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| T | Al Atkinson | Bonner |
| T | Nick Cirone | West Cath. |
| E | Vince Dennery | La Salle |
| B | Connie Snyder | Frankford |
| B | Tom Crow | La Salle |
1961 |
||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Ed Stringer | Hav. School |
| G | Jim Putz | La Salle |
| T | Don Steinbacher | Frankford |
| E | Rich Van Fossen | Roxborough |
| B | George Southcott | West Cath. |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| G | Tom Bazis | West Cath. |
| T | John Levi | Bonner |
| E | Bob Wilson | Germantown |
| B | Harold "Pat" Kelly | Gratz |
| B | Bob Petrella | Southern |
| B | Joe Rafter | North Cath. |
1962 |
||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| G | Barry Ambrosius | Judge |
| T | George Katzenbach | Roxborough |
| B | Bob Mahan | West Cath. |
| B | Joe Briddell | Southern |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| G | George Gambone | Southern |
| E | Frank Grimm | Judge |
| B | Tom DeFelice | West Cath. |
| B | John Kolmer | Malvern |
| B | Jim Hoye | Edison |
| B | Tom Stretch | Judge |
1963 |
||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Homer Ashby | Central |
| G | Dave Frederick | Egan |
| T | George Katzenbach | Roxborough |
| E | Ken Scheivert | St. James |
| B | Jim Lampe | Penn Charter |
| B | Brendan Murray | SJ Prep |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| G | Ron Hill | Neumann |
| T | Bob Shimer | Penn Charter |
| T | Joe Williams | Germantown |
| E | Carl Bogatiuk | North Cath. |
| B | Tom DeFelice | West Cath. |
| B | Bob Feret | Roxborough |
| B | Frank Ryan | St. James |
1964 |
||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Jim Armstrong | Judge |
| G | Ed Plocha | La Salle |
| T | Bob Crozer | Hav. School |
| E | Fred Winston | Germantown |
| B | Gary Friedhoff | Frankford |
| B | Jim Casertano | Dougherty |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| G | Ed Fischer | Frankford |
| G | Bob DeSantis | Gtn. Academy |
| T | Dennis Ziemba | Judge |
| E | Jim Callahan | Dougherty |
| B | Greg Tisdale | Roxborough |
| B | Bob "Sparky" Faries | St. James |
1965 |
||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Bob Cox | Central |
| T | Tom Hutchinson | SJ Prep |
| E | Hank Stringer | Hav. School |
| B | Mike DiDonato | West Cath. |
| B | Irv Whalen | Egan |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| G | Roger Millhouse | Germantown |
| G | Fran Auch | Malvern |
| T | Bob Davis | West Cath. |
| E | Alan Moccia | Southern |
1966 |
||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| T | Bill Bartholemew | Egan |
| E | Chuck Zapiec | La Salle |
| E | Warren McAliley | Franklin |
| B | Bill Armstrong | Gtn. Academy |
| B | Sylv. "Pancho" Micir | Egan |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | Rich Collier | Gtn. Academy |
| G | Rich Bradley | West Cath. |
| G | Frank Muraglia | Southern |
| T | Andy Shimer | Chestnut Hill |
| E | Dennis Yarnell | St. James |
| B | Irv Whalen | Egan |
1967 |
||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| G | Gary Gray | Egan |
| E | Dennis Yarnell | St. James |
| B | Pedro Barez | Edison |
| B | Bill Armstrong | Gtn. Academy |
| B | Larry Marshall | Egan |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | Bob Fass | Penn Charter |
| E | Lou Russo | Washington |
| B | Joe Gifford | West Cath. |
| B | Richie Phillips | Northeast |
1968 |
||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Wayne Moody | Central |
| T | Mike Dennery | Dougherty |
| E | Lou Russo | Washington |
| B | Bill Foley | Judge |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | Fran Seeley | Neumann |
| G | Gary Stever | Gtn. Academy |
| E | Jim Duff | Northeast |
| B | John Gallagher | Hav. School |
| B | Richie Glenn | Frankford |
1969 |
||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| Offense | ||
| C | Ed Lamb | Neumann |
| IL | Tom Christensen | St. James |
| E | Greg Taylor | Frankford |
| E | Don Clune | O'Hara |
| B | John Cappelletti | Bonner |
| B | David Bland | Dougherty |
| Defense | ||
| L | Jim Boyle | Egan |
| LB | Mike Capriotti | Frankford |
| LB | Ed Serembus | Dougherty |
| B | Richard Jones | Olney |
| B | Jim Bigas | St. James |
1970 |
||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| Offense | ||
| G | Ray Gionta | St. James |
| T | Brian Ameche | Malvern |
| T | Andre Tennessee | Dougherty |
| B | John Haldeman | Hav. School |
| Defense | ||
| L | Joe Younge | Central |
| LB | Steve Adel | Egan |
| LB | Joe Dollymore | Bonner |
| LB | Rich Taber | North Cath. |
| B | Tom Carpenter | Frankford |
| B | Lou Siesser | Egan |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| Offense | ||
| E | Gary Pester | Roxborough |
| E | Stan Kryston | Dougherty |
| QB | Warren Mays | Frankford |
| Defense | ||
| L | Ernest Brent | Mastbaum |
| L | John Kosherzenko | Ryan |
| L | John Zimba | Judge |
| LB | Dennis King | Central |
| LB | Dave Weitzel | Ryan |
| THIRD TEAM | ||
| Offense | ||
| C | Rob Mattiola | Kenrick |
| G | John Brewster | SJ Prep |
| G | Jim DiGregorio | Frankford |
| T | Art Garwood | Hav. School |
| E | Bob Smith | Neumann |
| E | Tom Childs | Overbrook |
| B | Andy Gordon | SJ Prep |
| Defense | ||
| L | Joe Crisanti | West Cath. |
| L | Gerald Walsh | Ryan |
| LB | Warren McAllister | Central |
| LB | John Varacallo | Egan |
| B | Ray Bain | La Salle |
| B | Conrad Jackson | Central |