Coaches' All-Public FB Teams, 1937-69
Return to TedSilary.com Home Page
| Pos. | Player | School |
| 1937 | ||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Ossie Thatcher | NE |
| G | Dick Debler | Gtn |
| G | McDowell | West |
| T | Jim Emery | NE |
| T | Clarence King | Sou |
| E | Al Will | Fkd |
| E | John Hober | Gtn |
| QB | Fish Harrington | Sou |
| HB | Reds Gotwals | NE |
| HB | Jerry Reinburg | West |
| FB | Bill Kramer | Fkd |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | Kranich | Gtn |
| G | Benny Gelb | NE |
| G | Ted Schmuck | Fkd |
| T | Stevenson | Cent |
| T | John Scott | Fkd |
| E | Len Zaroff | West |
| E | Sam Rosenberg | Sou |
| QB | Bob North | Fkd |
| HB | Bob Sheppard | Sou |
| HB | Morganstein | Cent |
| FB | Earle Baugher | NE |
| 1938 | ||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Dave Williams | West |
| G | Dom Guglielmi | Gtz |
| G | Dick Debler | Gtn |
| T | Al Stevenson | Cent |
| T | John Scott | Fkd |
| E | Bert Kuczynski | NE |
| E | Tom Graham | Oln |
| QB | Erle Baugher | NE |
| HB | Walt Peterson | Fkd |
| HB | Vince Bartolomeo | Sou |
| B | Zygmund Zamlynski | Cent |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | Walt Kmecik | Fkd |
| G | Dick Edwards | Cent |
| G | Joe Feldsher | Ovb |
| T | John McDowell | West |
| T | George Schmidt | NE |
| E | Dick Fasy | Gtn |
| E | Joe Kochmanowicz | Cent |
| QB | Neil Hoekstra | West |
| HB | Lou Lopez | Cent |
| HB | Nick Dennis | NE |
| FB | Rocco Hassis | Gtz |
| 1939 | ||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Carl Biershank | Oln |
| G | John Nevadunsky | NE |
| G | Andy Wolfrum | Fkd |
| T | Mike Jarmoluk | Fkd |
| T | Walt Stickel | NE |
| E | Mike Kraynak | Sou |
| E | Bert Walls | Cent |
| QB | Erle Baugher | NE |
| B | Harry Gossling | Fkd |
| B | Gil Gekoski | West |
| B | Charles Haug | NE |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | Jules Gebauer | Fkd |
| G | George Raymond | Cent |
| G | Leo Prevetti | Sou |
| T | Fritz Earley | West |
| T | Gene Konopka | Rox |
| E | John Mason | NE |
| E | Walt Russell | Oln |
| QB | Vince Bartolomeo | Sou |
| B | Zygmunt Zamlynski | Cent |
| B | Rocco Hassis | Gtz |
| B | Indian Joe Nejman | Fkd |
| 1940 | ||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Jules Gebauer | Fkd |
| G | Andy Wolfrum | Fkd |
| G | Obie Palmer | Fkn |
| T | Walt Stickel | NE |
| T | Gene Konopka | Rox |
| E | Joe Schofield | Rox |
| E | Bert Miley | Gtn |
| QB | Lou Lopez | Fkn |
| B | Severio Siani | Sou |
| B | Indian Joe Nejman | Fkd |
| B | Bill Luongo | Gtn |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | Jim Feeley | Gtn |
| G | Carl Perretta | Ovb |
| G | Ed Kotz | Fkd |
| T | Don Clarke | West |
| T | Bob Thorsen | NE |
| E | John Hildebrand | Oln |
| E | Tom Fetters | Sou |
| QB | Romeo Capriotti | Fkd |
| B | Jack Martin | Gtn |
| B | Stan Krystopa | Rox |
| B | John Appleton | Oln |
| 1941 | ||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Al Gornish | West |
| G | Tom Guzzardo | Fkd |
| G | Norm Green | Gtn |
| T | Manning Harvey | Fkd |
| T | Bob Thorsen | NE |
| E | Chas. "Sonny" Leonard | West |
| E | Bill Glenn | NE |
| QB | Romeo Capriotti | Fkd |
| B | Steve Cherneky | Fkn |
| B | Francis "Bud" Williams | West |
| B | Jack Modress | Rox |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | Ed Spielman | Fkd |
| G | Len Green | Gtn |
| G | Ray Pratt | Fkn |
| T | Charles Smith | Rox |
| T | Matt Sholomskas | Fkd |
| E | Stu Tompkins | West |
| E | Dick Reid | Gtn |
| QB | Jack Siderio | Sou |
| B | Stan Imsenik | Rox |
| B | Al Nojunas | Fkn |
| B | Bob Luongo | Gtn |
| 1942 | ||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Bob Mostertz | Gtn |
| G | Jo Collins | Bart |
| G | Sam Rubin | West |
| T | Bob Esterly | NE |
| T | Ed Virshup | Cent |
| E | Irv Ibach | Fkd |
| E | Bob McKinney | Gtn |
| B | Francis "Bud" Williams | West |
| B | Joseph "Bud" Sutton | NE |
| B | Ed Meyer | Fkd |
| B | Bill Bernardo | Gtn |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | Bill Mackrides | West |
| G | Andy McCleary | NE |
| G | Chris Shay | Fkn |
| T | Bill Pearson | West |
| T | John Babetzki | Fkd |
| E | Elmer Forsythe | NE |
| E | Mike Santacroce | Ovb |
| B | Bob Fania | Gtn |
| B | Chris Prokas | West |
| B | Al Nojunas | Fkn |
| B | Bill Gilbert | Oln |
| 1943 | ||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Ed Veith | Cent |
| G | John Sandusky | Sou |
| G | John Davis | West |
| G | Bob Kurtz | Fkd |
| T | Lou Scioscia | Fkd |
| T | Lloyd Eisenberg | Sou |
| E | Elmer Green | Ovb |
| E | Jim Seifert | Fkd |
| B | Al Papa | Ovb |
| B | Ed Carr | Oln |
| B | Don Katz | Cent |
| B | Bill Jones | NE |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | Lou Zybinski | Rox |
| G | Jack Soloff | Oln |
| G | Lynn LeBaron | Fkd |
| T | Bob Brewton | Sou |
| T | Gil Spielberg | Oln |
| E | Len Bellis | Sou |
| E | Armand Gasbarro | Sou |
| B | Tony Nicolella | Ovb |
| B | Gavin White | Fkd |
| B | Joe Williams | Cent |
| B | Jim Selsor | Gtn |
| 1944 | ||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Milt Komarnicki | Sou |
| G | Victor Frank | Cent |
| G | Bill DiFrancesco | NE |
| T | Uriel Wallace | Fkn |
| T | Ted Zygmont | Rox |
| E | Tom Sabol | Sou |
| E | Jim Seifert | Fkd |
| B | Bill Jones | NE |
| B | Anthony "Reds" Coletta | Sou |
| B | Ed Carr | Oln |
| B | Norm Waldman | NE |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | Bill Kommer | NE |
| G | Bernie Lemonick | Oln |
| G | John Erickson | Gtn |
| T | Stan Rifkin | Sou |
| T | Lou Scioscia | Fkd |
| E | Stan Kitchner | Ovb |
| E | Bill Buehler | NE |
| B | Jim Crossmore | West |
| B | John Maiden | Rox |
| B | Dom Pendino | Sou |
| B | Ray Capriotti | Fkd |
| 1945 | ||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Ben Burdetsky | Sou |
| G | Bernie Lemonick | Oln |
| G | Jack Levin | NE |
| T | Stan Greenwald | NE |
| T | Ted Zygmont | Rox |
| E | Harry West | Cent |
| E | Jim Sherlock | Bart |
| B | Anthony "Reds" Coletta | Sou |
| B | John Papit | NE |
| B | John Maiden | Rox |
| B | Ray Capriotti | Fkd |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | John Sharpe | Bart |
| G | Bill Andreoni | Ovb |
| G | George Shallcross | Fkd |
| T | Joe Lill | Fkd |
| T | Uriel Wallace | Fkn |
| E | James Brown | Ovb |
| E | Walt Goldy | Sou |
| B | Bernie Custis | Bart |
| B | Jack Del Bello | Sou |
| B | Leon Teagle | Fkn |
| B | Joe Carloza | Sou |
| 1946 | ||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Sol Schechter | NE |
| G | Hugh Boyd | NE |
| G | John Hauck | Fkd |
| T | John Pendino | Sou |
| T | Marty Morgan | Rox |
| E | Jim Sherlock | Bart |
| E | Joe Ciasullo | NE |
| E | Jim Sherlock | Bart |
| B | John Papit | NE |
| B | Anthony "Reds" Coletta | Sou |
| B | Bernie Custis | Bart |
| B | John Phillips | NE |
| B | Ray Capriotti | Fkd |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | Joe Temple | Bart |
| G | Bill Andreoni | Ovb |
| G | Bob McCann | Sou |
| T | Ray McLane | Fkd |
| T | Anthony Zarecki | NE |
| E | Ted Scurry | Gtz |
| E | Lou August | Rox |
| E | Walt Gelman | Sou |
| B | John Maiden | Rox |
| B | John Svitak | NE |
| B | Jack Acetta | Cent |
| B | Joe Baker | West |
| 1947 | ||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Dave Harr | Gtn |
| G | John Laino | Sou |
| G | Milt Tendler | Gtn |
| T | Lou DeVicaris | Fkd |
| T | John Pendino | Sou |
| T | Frank Jafolla | Ovb |
| E | Joe Ciasullo | NE |
| E | Ralph Brosious | Cent |
| B | Sebastian "Ben" Barretta | Sou |
| B | Ed Kozlowski | West |
| B | Dave Markloff | Fkd |
| B | Bill Everson | Fkd |
| B | Bill Lewin | Gtn |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | Bob Gibson | West |
| G | Fred Olita | Bart |
| G | Joe Stockridge | NE |
| T | Dave Lill | Fkd |
| T | Marty Morgan | Rox |
| T | Charles Smith | Cent |
| E | Charles McElwee | Fkd |
| E | George Gilman | Sou |
| B | Les Graves | Gtz |
| B | Hal Feinman | Cent |
| B | Ernie Liberati | Fkd |
| B | Gus Baxter | Fkn |
| 1948 | ||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Marty Abramson | Cent |
| G | Bill Smith | Fkd |
| G | Joe Stockridge | NE |
| T | Pat Sarnese | Dobb |
| T | Dave Lill | Fkd |
| E | John Orsino | NE |
| E | Ed Bell | West |
| B | Ernie Liberati | Fkd |
| B | Fred Diodati | Sou |
| B | Les Graves | Gtz |
| B | Bill Cannady | Fkn |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | Bob Griffith | Rox |
| G | Pete Carrieri | Sou |
| G | Joe McGee | Gtn |
| T | Henry Doerfler | NE |
| T | Paul Friedman | West |
| E | Tony Vacca | Gtn |
| E | Craig Stearn | Fkd |
| E | Bill Vignola | Bart |
| B | Bill McGarry | Dobb |
| B | Henry McCollum | Gtz |
| B | George Foedisch | Fkd |
| B | Richard Rosenbleeth | West |
| B | Al Shulman | West |
| 1949 | ||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Larry Cardonick | Oln |
| G | Don Mote | Cent |
| G | Pete Carrieri | Sou |
| T | Lou Grandizio | Bart |
| T | Charles DeShields | Bok |
| E | Rudy Miles | Dobb |
| E | Bob Bachman | Cent |
| B | Les Graves | Gtz |
| B | John Kitabjian | Fkd |
| B | Nick Carchidi | Sou |
| B | Leo Manco | Cent |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | Ted Rubin | West |
| G | Joe Davison | Fkd |
| G | Nick Costalas | Bart |
| T | Ron Borne | Rox |
| T | Alfonso Rogers | Gtz |
| E | Tony Vacca | Gtn |
| E | Ed Caffee | Gtz |
| B | Stan Lis | NE |
| B | Fred Diodati | Sou |
| B | Emanuel Cambria | Mast |
| B | Clarence Williford | Dobb |
| B | Ben Johnston | Fkn |
| 1950 | ||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Robert Burns | Gtn |
| G | Larry Cardonick | Oln |
| G | Querino Busillo | Bok |
| T | John Valentino | Sou |
| T | Mark Levitan | Cent |
| T | Bill Phillips | Fkd |
| E | Ron Rowe | Fkd |
| E | Jim Lung | Oln |
| B | Angelo Cairo | Gtn |
| B | Charley Bruno | Fkd |
| B | Jimmy Jenkins | Fkn |
| B | Charlie Guida | Bok |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | Don Berger | Oln |
| G | Herb Fisher | Fkn |
| G | Barry DeSatnick | West |
| G | Norman Morrell | Dobb |
| T | Bill McClung | Bok |
| T | William Austin | West |
| E | Jake Reichert | Rox |
| E | Al Zampino | Bok |
| B | Sheldon Kolinsky | Oln |
| B | Ed Hart | Gtz |
| B | Clarence Williford | Dobb |
| B | Bill Pownall | Rox |
| 1951 | ||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Seymour Davis | NE |
| G | Ed DeBrady | Gtz |
| G | Frank DeRusso | Cent |
| T | Walt Handel | Fkd |
| T | Dan Lerro | Sou |
| E | Jay Norman | Mast |
| E | Mike Pendino | Sou |
| B | Ed Moore | Fkd |
| B | Irvin "Bo" Roberson | Bart |
| B | Charley Goodall | Cent |
| B | Bill Fox | |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | Bob Schuman | Linc |
| G | George Reed | Gtn |
| G | Leroy Ellman | Dobb |
| T | Bob Sirulnick | Ovb |
| T | Bill Kipple | Oln |
| E | Joe Kaznicki | NE |
| E | Thomas Harrison | Dobb |
| B | James Nelson | Bok |
| B | Tony Carchidi | Sou |
| B | Johnny Buggs | Ovb |
| B | Morrey Greene | Gtz |
| 1952 | ||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Ron Howley | Rox |
| G | Gene Epstein | Oln |
| G | Bob Werner | Fkd |
| T | Dan Kraynyak | Sou |
| T | Rulon Finnell | Gtz |
| E | Ed Scarborough | Dobb |
| E | Seymour Lemonick | Oln |
| B | Irvin "Bo" Roberson | Bart |
| B | Mike Slaveski | Linc |
| B | Bob Patete | Rox |
| B | Marv Grossman | Cent |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | Dick Borkowski | NE |
| G | Remie Smith | Linc |
| G | Simon Abramson | Ovb |
| T | Joe O'Connell | Mast |
| T | Fred Peck | Rox |
| E | Dan Fleming | Linc |
| E | Roger MacKrel | Gtn |
| B | Myron Greene | Ovb |
| B | Nick Franceschino | Bok |
| B | James Allen | West |
| B | Hal Kolinsky | Oln |
| 1953 | ||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Al Copeland | Sou |
| G | Bill Stark | Fkd |
| G | Len Spizzirri | Ovb |
| T | Frank Brody | NE |
| T | Mike Romanausky | Fkd |
| E | Don Resnick | West |
| E | Paul Wall | Gtz |
| B | Paul Boldin | NE |
| B | John Bowser | Cent |
| B | Jim Eglin | Bart |
| B | Bob Stevenson | Fkn |
| B | Ed Kramer | Rox |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | Tom McDougal | Gtn |
| C | Bill Beck | Bart |
| G | Bob Tartala | Bart |
| G | Charley Howard | Bok |
| T | Art Frank | Cent |
| T | Bill Rakita | Linc |
| E | Walt Chamberlain | Linc |
| E | Aaron Wilson | Cent |
| B | Walt Pijawka | Gtn |
| B | Bob Richardson | Mast |
| B | Don Webster | Dobb |
| B | Ray Abruzzese | Sou |
| 1954 | ||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Oliver Beamon | NE |
| G | Bill Haslett | NE |
| G | Bob Evans | Linc |
| T | Don Novek | Cent |
| T | Charlie Janerette | Gtn |
| E | Byron Purnell | Bok |
| E | Ron Harmer | Rox |
| B | Lee Elia | Oln |
| B | John Wright | Fkd |
| B | Tom Pasquini | Bok |
| B | Bob Warner | Rox |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | Paul Holloway | Gtn |
| G | Bill Starrett | Dobb |
| G | Ben Scott | Ovb |
| T | Howard Will | Fkd |
| T | Bob Williams | Bok |
| E | Larry May | Ovb |
| E | Steve George | Fkd |
| B | Andrew Catalano | Mast |
| B | Willie Taylor | Fkn |
| B | Harold Stroman | Gtz |
| B | Ray Abruzzese | Sou |
| 1955 | ||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Paul Holloway | Gtn |
| G | Randy Jenkins | Gtz |
| G | Bill Starrett | Dobb |
| T | Lynn Ross | Ovb |
| T | Pete Wytish | Oln |
| E | Mickey Heinecken | Cent |
| E | Carl Bancoff | Cent |
| B | Bill Kennedy | Linc |
| B | Bob Raucci | Sou |
| B | George "Bubbles" Miller | Gtz |
| B | Angelo Coia | NE |
| B | Herb Adderley | NE |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | Ron Stewart | Bart |
| G | Tony Curcio | Gtn |
| G | Cal Stoudt | Fkd |
| T | Bob Williams | Bok |
| T | Bob Arangio | Sou |
| E | Bill Preston | Rox |
| E | Joe Gallagher | Linc |
| B | Floyd Williams | NE |
| B | Jack Bottinger | Rox |
| B | Walt Calloway | Fkn |
| B | Bill Roehl | Fkd |
| B | Charles Lotson | Gtz |
| 1956 | ||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Ed Belzer | Rox |
| G | Joe Corbi | Oln |
| G | Rodger Barr | Sou |
| T | Bob Casey | Fkd |
| T | Ray Sherrod | Gtn |
| E | Mickey Heinecken | Cent |
| E | Bill Hirst | Oln |
| B | Karl Schmalz | Cent |
| B | Herb Adderley | NE |
| B | Jack Bottinger | Rox |
| B | Ron Greene | Ovb |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | Ray Green | NE |
| G | Tony Groch | NE |
| G | Reese Brown | Ovb |
| T | Bob Kearsey | Bok |
| T | Howard Roberts | NE |
| E | Lou Arcangelo | Linc |
| E | Robert Adams | Gtz |
| B | Herb Vargas | Linc |
| B | Ted Mordecai | West |
| B | Jack Newbert | Dobb |
| B | Tom Dixon | Gtn |
| 1957 | ||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Dave Moses | Ovb |
| G | Joe Blasenstein | West |
| G | Willie Armstrong | Gtz |
| T | Ed Martin | Rox |
| T | Jack Sherer | Linc |
| E | John George | Fkd |
| E | Frank Scornaienchi | Linc |
| B | Dick Constable | Linc |
| B | Jim Pownall | Rox |
| B | Stan Krynski | Fkd |
| B | Joel Browndorf | Cent |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | Warren Dolphin | Cent |
| G | George Wible | Mast |
| G | Karl Stock | Edi |
| T | Barry Tottser | Oln |
| T | Frank Conway | Cent |
| E | Ron Gatto | Edi |
| E | Eric Faddis | Linc |
| B | John Miller | Bok |
| B | Garry Gulledge | Gtz |
| B | Joe Fabrizio | Lincr |
| B | Warren Seltzer | Gtn |
| 1958 | ||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Walt Wolfrum | Oln |
| G | Joe Blasenstein | West |
| G | John Hornyak | Linc |
| T | Jack Sherer | Linc |
| T | J.W. Grodzielanek | Fkd |
| E | Joe Mecsei | Dobb |
| E | Frank Scornaienchi | Linc |
| B | Richie Richman | Ovb |
| B | Ralph Triboletti | NE |
| B | Wendell Tucker | Fkn |
| B | Ed Silverberg | Linc |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | George Mood | Edi |
| G | Frank Petrognani | Bok |
| G | Larry Aaronson | Oln |
| G | George Weigand | NE |
| G | Jim Pontari | Ovb |
| T | Bob Katcavage | Rox |
| T | Ron Barlow | Gtn |
| T | Burton Spitzer | Cent |
| E | Earl Proctor | Gtn |
| E | Warren Boardley | Edi |
| E | Mike Jordan | Ovb |
| B | Joe Vanderstine | Dobb |
| B | John Loughran | Bok |
| B | John Litzke | Fkd |
| B | Leon Jekot | Bok |
| 1959 | ||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Howard Shaw | Rox |
| G | Serge Novak | Cent |
| G | Don Mitchell | West |
| G | Joe Capewell | Edi |
| T | Jim Lang | Bart |
| T | Joe Esposito | Sou |
| T | Tony Portella | Sou |
| E | Rich Tatum | Oln |
| E | Nyles Buchner | NE |
| E | Frank Clark | Rox |
| B | Mike Corbi | Oln |
| B | Leroy Kelly | Gtz |
| B | John Ciocari | Cent |
| B | Colby Cupit | Gtn |
| B | James Ounsworth | Linc |
| B | Alvin Miller | Bok |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | Tom Taylor | Gtz |
| G | Larry Aaronson | Oln |
| G | Marvin Mitchell | NE |
| G | Ed Wabals | Mast |
| T | Earl Falice | Mast |
| T | Gene Timoschuk | Dobb |
| T | Barry Day | Linc |
| E | Willie Williams | Fkn |
| E | Willie Lee | Cent |
| E | Jim Esposito | Linc |
| B | Dave Townsend | Rox |
| B | Joe Williams | Edi |
| B | Phil Cantor | NE |
| B | Frank Petrellis | Rox |
| B | Bill Humenuk | Linc |
| 1960 | ||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Creighton Incorminias | Ovb |
| C | Steve Waters | Bart |
| G | Dwight Williams | Bok |
| G | Marvin Mitchell | NE |
| G | Bob Fergione | Bart |
| T | Earl Falice | Mast |
| T | Ed Glenn | Gtn |
| T | Rich Gervasi | Sou |
| E | Jim Esposito | Linc |
| E | Willie Williams | Fkn |
| E | Jerome Fisher | Edi |
| B | Connie Snyder | Fkd |
| B | Mark Treftz | Bart |
| B | Mike Corbi | Oln |
| B | Willie Davis | Ovb |
| B | Ron Theiss | NE |
| B | Butch Christman | Rox |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | Mike Mokriski | Fkd |
| G | Bill Samuel | Fkd |
| G | Bernard Hooker | Fkn |
| G | Ray Johnson | Edi |
| T | Tom Carr | Ovb |
| T | John O'Donnell | Dobb |
| T | Joe Brostwicz | Rox |
| E | Glenn Kuklick | Rox |
| E | George Hirst | Oln |
| E | Doug Robinson | Sou |
| B | Karl Kruse | Fkd |
| B | Ron Cohen | Gtn |
| B | Bob Turner | Dobb |
| B | Frank Roselione | Oln |
| B | Arnett Wilkerson | Gtz |
| B | Jack Schoell | Linc |
| 1961 | ||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Robert Muntz | Ovb |
| G | Ed Robinson | Cent |
| G | Perry Scott | West |
| G | Al Hill | Edi |
| T | Don Steinbacher | Fkd |
| T | Clemon Bradley | Bart |
| T | Paul Della Vecchia | Sou |
| E | Rich Van Fossen | Rox |
| E | Bob Wilson | Gtn |
| E | Charles Stewart | West |
| B | Harold "Pat" Kelly | Gtz |
| B | Dave Robertson | Gtn |
| B | Dave Jerrido | Edi |
| B | Tom Javian | NE |
| B | Lou Neebe | Oln |
| B | Bob Petrella | Sou |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | James Gibson | Gtz |
| G | Leonard Green | NE |
| G | Vince Latvines | Dobb |
| G | Bob Vernick | Ovb |
| T | Ron Mills | Mast |
| T | Emery Lucas | Dobb |
| T | Ben Pezka | Rox |
| E | Lee Corbett | Linc |
| E | Bill Grant | Fkd |
| E | George Hirst | Oln |
| B | Bill Petrellis | Rox |
| B | Carmen Esposito | Linc |
| B | Bob Turner | Dobb |
| B | Ken Moore | Bok |
| B | Lester King | Bart |
| B | Isiah Givens | Fkn |
| 1962 | ||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
C |
Homer Ashby | Cent |
| G | Jay Lance | Fkd |
| G | Paul Sandler | Oln |
| G | George Gambone | Sou |
| T | John Barber | Ovb |
| T | George Katzenbach | Rox |
| T | Wes Jones | Edi |
| E | Bernie Johnston | Sou |
| E | Ed Grove | Linc |
| E | Bob Wilson | Gtn |
| B | Gene Hoye | Edi |
| B | Joe Briddell | Sou |
| B | Bill Petrellis | Rox |
| B | Ray Schaubell | Cent |
| B | Monte Frazier | Bart |
| B | Carmen Esposito | Linc |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | Fred Smeltzer | Rox |
| G | Leonard Green | NE |
| G | Perry Scott | Bok |
| G | Don Korn | Cent |
| T | Emery Lucas | Dobb |
| T | Bob MacLean | Bart |
| T | Jim Brown | West |
| E | John Bonder | Rox |
| E | Ron Floyd | Mast |
| E | Ed Bracey | Edi |
| B | George Davenport | Sou |
| B | Willie Evans | Bok |
| B | Frank Dixon | Gtn |
| B | Gene Gravinese | Rox |
| B | Jim Tatom | Edi |
| B | Al Smail | Fkd |
| 1963 | ||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Mike Riesberg | Rox |
| C | Ken Adams | Sou |
| G | Homer Ashby | Cent |
| G | Rich Marburg | Oln |
| G | Joe Williams | Gtn |
| T | George Katzenbach | Rox |
| T | Robert Szeliga | Fkd |
| T | George Gambone | Sou |
| T | Stephen Denby | Fkn |
| E | Chris Roulhac | Gtn |
| E | Vince McCaffrey | Fkd |
| B | Joe Petrucelli | Cent |
| B | George Parfitt | Dobb |
| B | Bob Feret | Rox |
| B | Frank Dixon | Gtn |
| B | Al Brown | Bok |
| B | Nick Cione | Fkd |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | Tom Gonsiewski | Fkd |
| C | George Fravel | Bart |
| G | Jim Johnson | Cent |
| G | Vince Nardino | Linc |
| G | Charles Scott | Edi |
| T | Alvoid Powers | West |
| T | Melvin Burgess | Fkn |
| T | Richard Ward | Bart |
| T | Charles Jones | Dobb |
| E | Walt Urbaczewski | Linc |
| E | Mike Gospodarek | Dobb |
| B | Frank Petrella | Sou |
| B | Fran Ruchalski | Rox |
| B | Marc Taylor | NE |
| B | Monte Frazier | Bart |
| B | Joel Crossrow | Cent |
| B | George Nock | Fkn |
| B | Vernon Robinson | Dobb |
| 1964 | ||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Ray Fitch | Wash |
| G | Claude Scott | Edi |
| G | Ed Fisher | Fkd |
| T | Bob Bell | West |
| T | Jim Young | Bart |
| T | Phil Jerrido | Edi |
| T | Gerald Hendricks | Gtz |
| E | Jay Gill | Linc |
| E | Fred Winston | Gtn |
| E | Harvey Johnson | Mast |
| B | Gary Friedhoff | Fkd |
| B | Greg Tisdale | Rox |
| B | John Williams | Fkn |
| B | Stan Sitarsky | Cent |
| B | George Lattera | Sou |
| B | Ed Guzman | Dobb |
| B | Bill Wallace | Sou |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| C | Steve Sennott | Bok |
| G | King Harris | Gtn |
| G | John Ashby | Cent |
| T | Joe Bell | Dobb |
| T | Bill Summers | Oln |
| T | Avi Isaak | Ovb |
| T | Dave Shrier | Sou |
| E | Bob Halter | Oln |
| E | George Stalling | Ovb |
| E | Jeff Ostroff | NE |
| B | Tom Hunter | Oln |
| B | John Purtel | Edi |
| B | Richie Newman | Bart |
| B | Al Wells | NE |
| B | Joe Carvalho | Ovb |
| B | Joe Stock | Mast |
| B | Steve Kirby | Ovb |
| B | Bob Cosby | Gtn |
| 1965 | ||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| Offense | ||
| C | Calvin Bou | Dobb |
| G | Godfrey Leonard | Cent |
| G | George Butler | Bart |
| T | Bill Summers | Ovb |
| T | Gerald Ford | Fkn |
| E | Randy Tobin | Fkd |
| E | John Brenner | Linc |
| B | Bob Rubin | NE |
| B | Frank Gorman | Sou |
| B | Bill Scott | Gtn |
| B | Manor Prewitt | Fkd |
| Defense | ||
| G | Britz Randolph | Ovb |
| G | Frank Muraglia | Sou |
| T | Bob Perry | Cent |
| T | Bill Scott | Bok |
| E | Al Moccia | Sou |
| E | Jim Salley | Rox |
| LB | Bob Cox | Cent |
| LB | Roger Millhouse | Gtn |
| B | March Green | Fkn |
| B | Al Jackson | West |
| B | Curt Bernhardt | Wash |
| B | Jim Donaldson | Linc |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| Offense | ||
| C | Alan Poole | Gtz |
| G | Willmer Webb | NE |
| G | Joe Surrick | Fkd |
| T | Ed Banks | Ovb |
| T | Bob Sinnott | Rox |
| E | Tal Owen | West |
| E | Alan Johns | Oln |
| B | Howard Johnson | Bart |
| B | Rudolph McKenney | Edi |
| B | Lew Novek | Cent |
| B | Larry Lane | Dobb |
| Defense | ||
| G | Perry Pilson | Fkn |
| G | Tom Dorsey | West |
| T | Doug Macauley | NE |
| T | Boyd James | Edi |
| E | Bob Atkinson | Rox |
| E | Mark Lipson | Cent |
| LB | Ed Duffy | Mast |
| LB | Bill Reed | Edi |
| B | Richard Phillips | NE |
| B | Don Humphries | Edi |
| B | Joe Garrett | Bart |
| 1966 | ||
| HONOR ROLL | ||
| C | Ted Moody | Gtn |
| C | Rich Hollingsworth | Wash |
| C | Ed Clark | Rox |
| G | Willmer Weber | NE |
| G | Frank Muraglia | Sou |
| G | Bob Irvine | Oln |
| G | Harold Womack | Bok |
| T | Gerald Ford | Fkn |
| T | Clarence Smith | Gtn |
| T | Ken Leonczyk | Cent |
| T | Leon Briscoe | Bart |
| T | Bill McCluskey | Mast |
| E | Warren McAliley | Fkn |
| E | John McGovern | NE |
| E | Ron Werntz | Rox |
| E | Robert Johnson | Edi |
| E | Bob Kelly | Linc |
| E | Charles Booker | Sou |
| B | Milt Reid | Fkn |
| B | Jose Salamatin | Fkd |
| B | Dave Tompkins | Fkd |
| B | Joe Houghton | Fkd |
| B | Dale Lofton | Gtn |
| B | Richie Phillips | NE |
| B | Tony Carlini | Sou |
| B | Tom Fluellen | Sou |
| B | Jack Gorman | Cent |
| B | Nate Gans | Cent |
| B | Bob Mica | Wash |
| B | Len Davis | Bart |
| B | Carlton Bailey | Edi |
| B | Tom Woodard | Dobb |
| B | Larry Lane | Dobb |
| B | Ken Pagliaro | Linc |
| B | Davis Eiland | Oln |
| B | Levi Williams | West |
| B | Henry McCoullum | Gtz |
| 1967 | ||
| HONOR ROLL | ||
| L | Tom Kilgore | Bart |
| L | Cornelius Singleton | Bart |
| L | Ken Leonczyk | Cent |
| L | Frank Herschberger | Dobb |
| L | Marshall Murphy | Dobb |
| L | Chester Chisholm | Edi |
| L | George Fleetwood | Edi |
| L | Joe Geiger | Fkd |
| L | Warren McAliley | Fkn |
| L | Gil Owens | Fkn |
| L | Steve Coleman | Gtn |
| L | Ted Moody | Gtn |
| L | LeRoy Walker | Gtz |
| L | Ron Leonard | NE |
| L | Tyrone Robinson | Oln |
| L | Mike Ashby | Ovb |
| L | Harry Downey | Rox |
| L | Larry Thomas | Rox |
| L | Ron Funaro | Sou |
| L | Mike Scanzano | Sou |
| L | Bruce Gardner | Wash |
| L | Lou Russo | Wash |
| L | Willie King | West |
| L | Norm Townsend | West |
| B | Marv Frazier | Bart |
| B | Gerald Montague | Bok |
| B | Jack Gorman | Cent |
| B | Richie Weaver | Cent |
| B | Pedro Barez | Edi |
| B | Chuck Morganti | Fkd |
| B | Paul Randall | Fkn |
| B | William Hodge | Gtz |
| B | Charlie Dahms | Linc |
| B | Bill Early | Linc |
| B | Richie Phillips | NE |
| B | Paul Loughran | Rox |
| B | Frank Kern | Wash |
| 1968 | ||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| NORTHERN DIVISION | ||
| Offense | ||
| L | Henry Roundtree | Gtz |
| L | Tyrone Robinson | Oln |
| L | Jim Landay | Linc |
| L | Craig Reif | Oln |
| L | Wayne Moody | Cent |
| L | Doug Keislich | Linc |
| L | Frank Smith | Gtn |
| QB | Al Davis | Oln |
| B | Tom Sherer | NE |
| B | Bill Early | Linc |
| B | Rich Glenn | Fkd |
| B | Steve Kaplan | Cent |
| Defense | ||
| L | Bob Phillips | NE |
| L | Jim Duff | NE |
| L | Bob Schaeffer | NE |
| L | Mike Murphy | Bart |
| L | Charles Butler | Gtz |
| L | Jim Roberts | Fkd |
| LB | Dennis Weinraub | Oln |
| LB | Lou Russo | Wash |
| B | Warren Sothern | Linc |
| B | Paul Lobosco | Cent |
| B | Tom McNeil | Wash |
| SOUTHERN DIVISION | ||
| Offense | ||
| L | Ray Geisler | Mast |
| L | Fred Cicchitti | Sou |
| L | Ed Schubert | Mast |
| L | Ed Moyer | Rox |
| L | Steve Taylor | Fkn |
| L | Bob Miller | Rox |
| L | Ron Duckett | Ovb |
| QB | Ken Smith | Rox |
| B | Joe Corosonite | Sou |
| B | Ken Miller | Edi |
| B | Len Lashley | Fkn |
| Defense | ||
| L | Ron Thompkins | Ovb |
| L | Willie King | West |
| L | Reggie Nichols | Sou |
| L | Jim Devlin | Rox |
| L | Ray Burke | Sou |
| L | Wesley Jenkins | Edi |
| LB | Lloyd Jenkins | Bok |
| LB | Ed Sperduto | Dobb |
| B | Willie Holloway | Fkn |
| B | Ken Weaver | Fkn |
| B | Gene Coney | West |
| 1969 | ||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| DIVISION ONE | ||
| Offense | ||
| C | Glenn Trethaway | Fkd |
| G | Bob Schaum | Cent |
| G | William Scott | Oln |
| T | Steve Tracykiewicz | NE |
| T | Don Shaw | Rox |
| E | Doug Kieslich | Linc |
| E | Greg Taylor | Fkd |
| QB | Ken Smith | Rox |
| B | Richard Jones | Oln |
| B | George Loos | Fkd |
| B | Steve Sender | NE |
| Defense | ||
| G | John Washington | Gtz |
| G | Robert Lynch | Fkd |
| T | John Johnson | Wash |
| T | Bob Loughery | Rox |
| E | Steve Wiacek | Cent |
| E | Harry Johnson | Linc |
| LB | Mike Capriotti | Fkd |
| LB | Bobby Bernardo | NE |
| B | Rich Pierce | Linc |
| B | Ivars "Max" Bilkins | Cent |
| B | Augustus Baxter | Gtn |
| DIVISION TWO | ||
| Offense | ||
| C | Charles Johnson | Bart |
| G | Leroy Brown | Sou |
| G | Edgar Brown | West |
| T | Benjamin Jenkins | Fkn |
| T | Reggie Hollis | Bart |
| E | Ron Duckett | Ovb |
| E | Ernie White | Bart |
| E | Wallace Wilson | Dobb |
| QB | Dennis Ciocco | Bart |
| B | Gerald Scott | Sou |
| B | Calvin Jones | Edi |
| B | Joe Barnes | Fkn |
| B | George Redmon | Ovb |
| Defense | ||
| L | Leon Isaacs | Bok |
| L | Bruce Nichols | Dobb |
| L | Tyrone Backon | Dobb |
| L | George Smith | Mast |
| L | Phillip Smith | Edi |
| L | Dean Scott | Ovb |
| LB | Larry Bracy | Dobb |
| LB | Elbert Woodall | Ovb |
| LB | Keith Young | West |
| LB | Anthony Barbagiovni | Sou |
| B | Michael West | Dobb |
| B | Larry Williams | Mast |
| B | Albert Robinson | Fkn |