Neumann-Goretti High School (Philadelphia, PA)
Football History . . . Individual Scoring
(Formerly Southeast Catholic/Bishop Neumann/St. John Neumann)
(Beginning With 1948 Season; School Joined Catholic League in 1935)
Return to TedSilary.com Home Page
First List -- Top Career Scorers, Overall
Second List -- Top Career Scorers, Non-Enrollment Era (1940-98)
Third List -- Top Season Scorers, Overall
Fourth List -- Top Season Scorers, Non-Enrollment Era (1940-98)
Fifth List -- Top Game Scorers, Overall
Sixth List -- All Scorers, Year by Year
1940 Through 2021 Seasons
Neumann-Goretti is now at 10th & Moore. Previous locations:
7th & Christian as Southeast Catholic (a k a South Catholic),
26th & Moore as Bishop Neumann/St. John Neumann. SJN
merged with St. Maria Goretti, an all-girls school, for the 2004-05
school year.
If you can help with missing names and/or points, please do so.
Thanks! . . . This page will be updated as info is received.
Thanks for the help: Charlie Pitale, Bill Carberry, Jim "Bootsy" Paylor.
Ted Silary . . .tedtee307@yahoo.com.
| Top 15 Career Scorers | ||
| Overall, 1948-2021 Seasons | ||
| Year = Final Season | ||
| (Varying Number of Seasons/Games) | ||
| Name | Year | Points |
| Tysheem Johnson | 2019 | 286 |
| Len Nelson | 1983 | 236 |
| Khalil Roane | 2015 | 206 |
| Anthony Sheridan | 1993 | 166 |
| Jimmy Porreca | 2002 | 164 |
| Dick "Reds" Mattioli | 1958 | 158 |
| Billy Canady | 2003 | 152 |
| Jamal Custis | 2013 | 152 |
| Jason Gargon | 1999 | 146 |
| Sihmare Morgan | 2013 | 146 |
| Ralph DiMeo | 1982 | 144 |
| Malik Griffin | 2019 | 142 |
| Daryl Nelson | 1987 | 130 |
| Mark McPherson | 2006 | 126 |
| Joe Naselli | 1964 | 124 |
--
| Top 15 Career Scorers | ||
| Non-Enrollment Era, 1948-1998 Seasons | ||
| Year = Final Season | ||
| (Varying Number of Seasons/Games) | ||
| Name | Year | Points |
| Len Nelson | 1983 | 236 |
| Anthony Sheridan | 1993 | 166 |
| Dick "Reds" Mattioli | 1958 | 158 |
| Ralph DiMeo | 1982 | 144 |
| Daryl Nelson | 1987 | 130 |
| Joe Naselli | 1964 | 124 |
| Bill Boegly | 1954 | 116 |
| Jack McDonnell | 1951 | 109 |
| Earl Geissler | 1960 | 102 |
| Pat Drass | 1957 | 93 |
| Tony Malerba | 1968 | 92 |
| Tony Latronica | 1950 | 90 |
| Joe Moshinski | 1952 | 85 |
| Tom DiMuzio | 1964 | 84 |
| Gerry Smith | 1976 | 82 |
--
| Top 15 Season Scorers | ||
| Overall, 1948-2021 Seasons | ||
| (Varying Number of Seasons/Games) | ||
| Name | Year | Points |
| Tysheem Johnson | 2019 | 182 |
| Len Nelson | 1983 | 180 |
| Jimmy Porreca | 2002 | 162 |
| Anthony Sheridan | 1993 | 118 |
| Chris Wells | 2017 | 98 |
| Khalil Roane | 2014 | 96 |
| Billy Canady | 2003 | 94 |
| Jason Gargon | 1999 | 92 |
| Daryl Nelson | 1987 | 92 |
| Malik Griffin | 2019 | 92 |
| Tysheem Johnson | 2018 | 90 |
| Dick "Reds" Mattioli | 1958 | 86 |
| Jayden Sumpter | 2021 | 86 |
| Jack McDonnell | 1951 | 85 |
| Leddie Brown | 2017 | 84 |
| Jayden Styles | 2021 | 84 |
| Sihmare Morgan | 2013 | 80 |
--
| Top 15 Season Scorers | ||
| Non-Enrollment Era, 1948-1998 Seasons | ||
| (Varying Number of Seasons/Games) | ||
| Name | Year | Points |
| Len Nelson | 1983 | 180 |
| Anthony Sheridan | 1993 | 118 |
| Daryl Nelson | 1987 | 92 |
| Dick "Reds" Mattioli | 1958 | 86 |
| Jack McDonnell | 1951 | 85 |
| Tom DiMuzio | 1965 | 78 |
| Ralph DiMeo | 1981 | 78 |
| Joe Moshinski | 1952 | 73 |
| Ralph DiMeo | 1982 | 66 |
| Earl Geissler | 1960 | 64 |
| Gerry Smith | 1975 | 64 |
| Bill Boegly | 1954 | 60 |
| Tim Barry | 1981 | 58 |
| Bob Smith | 1970 | 56 |
| Tony DeSantis | 1954 | 54 |
| Tony Malerba | 1968 | 54 |
--
| Top Game Performances, 1948-2016 (All One List) | |||
| Name | Pts | Foe | Year |
| Anthony Sheridan | 38 | Southern | 1993 |
| Billy Canady | 38 | Dougherty | 2003 |
| Tysheem Johnson | 36 | Bonner-Prendie | 2018 |
| Jason Gargon | 32 | Dougherty | 1999 |
| Chris Scott-Peters | 30 | West Catholic | 2001 |
| Bruce Holloman | 30 | Freire Charter | 2004 |
| Mark McPherson | 30 | Southern | 2005 |
| immy Porreca | 28 | Southern | 2002 |
| Ralph DiMeo | 26 | Southern | 1982 |
| Len Nelson | 26 | St. James | 1983 |
| Daryl Nelson | 26 | Roman | 1987 |
| Jimmy Porreca | 26 | West Catholic | 2002 |
| Dick "Reds" Mattioli | 24 | St. Thomas More | 1958 |
| Bob Smith | 24 | Southern | 1970 |
| Gerry Smith | 24 | SJ Prep | 1975 |
| Jason Gargon | 24 | Conwell-Egan | 1999 |
| Pasquale Narducci | 24 | Southern | 2000 |
| Chris Scott-Peters | 24 | Conwell-Egan | 2001 |
| Tysheem Johnson | 24 | Lansdale | 2018 |
| Tysheem Johnson | 24 | Carroll | 2019 |
--
| Individual Scoring, 1948-2017 | |
| Name | Points |
| SE/South Catholic Pirates | |
| 1948 | |
| Bill Powers | 42 |
| Joe Schultz | 30 |
| Dick DeLuca | 30 |
| Bill DiGaetano | 30 |
| Jim D'Amico | 18 |
| Mike Goffredo | 18 |
| Lou Mimmo | 12 |
| Bob Verica | 6 |
| Greco | 6 |
| Safeties | 4 |
| 196 | |
| 1949 | |
| Tony Latronica | 42 |
| John Lavin | 36 |
| John Butrus | 21 |
| John Solari | 20 |
| Charles Laporte | 6 |
| Santangelo | 6 |
| Frattone | 6 |
| Coppola | 6 |
| Perri | 6 |
| Safeties | 4 |
| Ed Cook | 1 |
| Lou Solari | 1 |
| 155 | |
| 1950 | |
| Tony Latronica | 48 |
| Lou Solari | 31 |
| Joe Lavin | 28 |
| Fran Powers | 25 |
| Jack McDonnell | 24 |
| Frank Fahey | 13 |
| Stoughton | 12 |
| Charlie Muzio | 6 |
| Art DelConte | 6 |
| Safety | 2 |
| Lou Ginoble | 1 |
| Missing: 7 pts vs. MSJ (Md.) | |
| Missing: 6 pts vs. North Cath. | |
| 209 | |
| 1951 | |
| Jack McDonnell | 85 |
| George Santangelo | 30 |
| Charlie Muzio | 15 |
| Howard Cooper | 15 |
| Don DiMatteo | 12 |
| Joe Moshinski | 12 |
| Charles Kisielius | 8 |
| Lou Solari | 7 |
| Walt Werner | 6 |
| Alfred Cunningham | 6 |
| Anthony DeCecco | 6 |
| Bill Boegly | 6 |
| 208 | |
| 1952 | |
| Joe Moshinski | 73 |
| Charlie Muzio | 36 |
| Frank Squilla | 30 |
| Don Reinert | 13 |
| Nick Nardi | 13 |
| Bill Boegly | 12 |
| Joe Kelly | 12 |
| Joe DiGrazio | 6 |
| Bill Shefski | 6 |
| Ron Bracken | 6 |
| Ray Norton | 6 |
| Joe Starr | 1 |
| Jim Tobin | 1 |
| Joe Pooler | 1 |
| 216 | |
| 1953 | |
| Ray Norton | 43 |
| Bill Boegly | 38 |
| Chuck Bastian | 20 |
| Joe Nardo | 19 |
| Joe Starr | 18 |
| Jim Grazione | 1 |
| 139 | |
| 1954 | |
| Bill Boegly | 60 |
| Tony DeSantis | 54 |
| Jim Grazione | 49 |
| Ray Lardani | 31 |
| Joe Nardo | 30 |
| George Chew | 18 |
| Jim Tobin | 12 |
| Jim Joyce | 6 |
| Joe Pooler | 6 |
| 266 | |
| Bishop Neumann Pirates | |
| 1955 | |
| Jim Joyce | 48 |
| Joe Okulski | 21 |
| Joe Ferringo | 20 |
| Dick/Nick Ciavardone | 6 |
| Al Petti | 6 |
| Pat Drass | 6 |
| Joe Barnett | 6 |
| Rich Famiglietti | 1 |
| 114 | |
| 1956 | |
| Pat Drass | 45 |
| Dick "Reds" Mattioli | 30 |
| Bob Capone | 19 |
| Joe Jacovini | 7 |
| Walt Klauder | 6 |
| Jim Grispino | 6 |
| John McGovern | 6 |
| Charlie Chew | 6 |
| Curt Ciavardone | 6 |
| Rhonell Seabreeze | 6 |
| Defeated STM by forfeit | |
| 138 | |
| 1957 | |
| Dick "Reds" Mattioli | 42 |
| Pat Drass | 42 |
| Bob Capone | 24 |
| Charlie Chew | 18 |
| Andy Terifay | 18 |
| Jim Grispino | 8 |
| Joe Jacovini | 8 |
| Brennan | 7 |
| Ed Zoller | 6 |
| 173 | |
| 1958 | |
| Dick "Reds" Mattioli | 86 |
| Andy Terifay | 30 |
| Ray "Chicky" Chiumento | 18 |
| Jim Grispino | 18 |
| Tony Bariglio | 16 |
| Brennan | 6 |
| Safety | 2 |
| 176 | |
| 1959 | |
| Earl Geissler | 38 |
| Jim Kipschke | 6 |
| Ray "Chicky" Chiumento | 6 |
| Joe Laudadio | 6 |
| Tony Bariglio | 6 |
| Padio | 2 |
| Safety | 2 |
| Casciato | 2 |
| Gladis | 2 |
| John Banner | 2 |
| 72 | |
| 1960 | |
| Earl Geissler | 64 |
| Frank Borrelli | 18 |
| Ron Chiumento | 18 |
| Frank Costa | 6 |
| Joe Laudadio | 6 |
| Rich Carassai | 6 |
| Safety | 2 |
| 120 | |
| 1961 | |
| Joe Lippi | 32 |
| Joe Laudadio | 30 |
| Ron Chiumento | 24 |
| Rich Wallace | 10 |
| Greg DeFelice | 10 |
| Dan Smedley | 8 |
| Anthony Palestini | 6 |
| Rich Carassai | 3 |
| Joe Siderio | 2 |
| Missing: 2 pts vs. Roman | |
| 127 | |
| 1962 | |
| Joe Naselli | 30 |
| Joe Siderio | 26 |
| Ron Abbruzzese | 24 |
| Mark Chitwood | 14 |
| Bert Sadgwar | 8 |
| Rich Wallace | 6 |
| Greg DeFelice | 6 |
| Dan Lanno | 2 |
| Art Carita | 2 |
| Bernie Eife | 2 |
| 120 | |
| 1963 | |
| Joe Naselli | 52 |
| Wally Holman | 24 |
| Ron Ianole | 20 |
| Bill Parker | 6 |
| Rich Bova | 6 |
| Carl Holod | 6 |
| Zagone | 6 |
| Roberts | 6 |
| Ambrose | 3 |
| Safety | 2 |
| Missing: 2 pts vs. North Cath. | |
| 133 | |
| 1964 | |
| Joe Naselli | 42 |
| Frank Abruzzese | 18 |
| Rick Lombardo | 11 |
| Tom DiMuzio | 6 |
| Jim Gaynor | 6 |
| Golden | 6 |
| Giordino | 6 |
| Harry Melton | 2 |
| Missing: 6 pts vs. North Cath. | |
| 103 | |
| 1965 | |
| Tom DiMuzio | 78 |
| Harry Melton | 52 |
| Jim Gaynor | 38 |
| Bernie Guido | 22 |
| Barbieri | 6 |
| Joyce | 6 |
| John Latella | 4 |
| Missing: 2 pts vs. North Cath. | |
| 208 | |
| 1966 | |
| Don Renzi | 42 |
| Tony Malerba | 18 |
| Tom Abaldo | 14 |
| Steve Casella | 12 |
| Joe Bonavitacola | 12 |
| Golden | 8 |
| Gordsanite | 6 |
| McCrossen | 6 |
| Pat Iavarone | 6 |
| Bill Kerrin | 6 |
| Darigo | 2 |
| 132 | |
| 1967 | |
| Randy Dezii | 36 |
| Corosanite | 29 |
| Pat Iavarone | 22 |
| Tony Malerba | 20 |
| Pat Kerr | 12 |
| Ed McGinn | 12 |
| Bill Kerrin | 6 |
| Joe Gizzie | 6 |
| Joe Simone | 2 |
| Safety | 2 |
| 147 | |
| 1968 | |
| Tony Malerba | 54 |
| Steve Dezii | 16 |
| Vince Crimaldi | 12 |
| J. Mannato | 12 |
| Bob Darigo | 6 |
| Johnson | 2 |
| Jim Cattalo | 1 |
| Missing: 2 pts vs. North Cath. | |
| 105 | |
| 1969 | |
| John Itri | 32 |
| Frank Svedas | 30 |
| Joe Sirolli | 18 |
| John Costa | 12 |
| Don Capone | 12 |
| Ed Lamb | 6 |
| Jim Cattalo | 6 |
| Tom Amoriello | 6 |
| Bill Hatty | 5 |
| Safety | 2 |
| Johnston | 2 |
| Missing: 15 pts vs. North Cath. | |
| 146 | |
| 1970 | |
| Bob Smith | 56 |
| Tom Amoriello | 34 |
| Ed Moloney | 12 |
| John Itri | 12 |
| Jim Cattalo | 9 |
| Frank Svedas | 6 |
| Bill Hatty | 6 |
| 135 | |
| 1971 | |
| Mickey Adams | 40 |
| Ken Anthony | 30 |
| Gus DiFonzo | 18 |
| Tom Amoriello | 15 |
| Ron Lester | 6 |
| Smith | 2 |
| Missing: 4 pts vs. West Cath. | |
| 115 | |
| 1972 | |
| Gus DiFonzo | 30 |
| Henry Sirolli | 14 |
| Tony Mignogna | 12 |
| Reno Busillo | 10 |
| Joe Esposito | 6 |
| Jim Hetherington | 6 |
| Joe Capone | 6 |
| Bill Henry | 6 |
| Bob Mooney | 6 |
| Bill Squadrito | 6 |
| Safeties | 4 |
| Missing: 2 pts vs. Bonner | |
| 108 | |
| 1973 | |
| Reno Busillo | 20 |
| Henry Sirolli | 20 |
| Tony Mignogna | 18 |
| Fran Hetherington | 12 |
| Bill Saulino | 12 |
| Sebastian Romeo | 6 |
| Sexton | 6 |
| Bob Lacontora | 6 |
| Anthony D'Angelo | 2 |
| Joe Turchi | 2 |
| 104 | |
| 1974 | |
| Bob Lacontora | 24 |
| Tony Mignogna | 20 |
| Bill Saulino | 10 |
| Amaradio | 6 |
| Esposito | 6 |
| Joe Turchi | 6 |
| Mike DeLuca | 6 |
| Vardak | 6 |
| Sebastian Romeo | 2 |
| Morrone | 1 |
| 87 | |
| 1975 | |
| Gerry Smith | 64 |
| Bob Lacontora | 48 |
| Mike DeLuca | 34 |
| Sebastian Romeo | 12 |
| Tom Noreski | 6 |
| Mike Mallon | 6 |
| Al "Sugar Bear" Barbieri | 6 |
| Pepe | 6 |
| 182 | |
| 1976 | |
| Tom Noreski | 32 |
| Mike Mallon | 24 |
| Tom Colantuono | 18 |
| Gerry Smith | 18 |
| Steve Ruffenach | 12 |
| Mike Barretta | 12 |
| Ed Bianculli | 6 |
| Safety | 2 |
| Missing: 6 pts vs. Millville | |
| 130 | |
| 1977 | |
| Ed Bianculli | 18 |
| Frank Taylor | 18 |
| Mike Barretta | 12 |
| John Mignogna | 6 |
| Tony Guercio | 6 |
| Ernie Cimadamore | 5 |
| Safety | 2 |
| 67 | |
| SJ Neumann Pirates | |
| 1978 | |
| Bob Hayes | 30 |
| Joe DiPietro | 28 |
| Joe McGreal | 12 |
| John Mignogna | 12 |
| Ernie Cimadamore | 6 |
| Bradley | 6 |
| 94 | |
| 1979 | |
| Joe Jaep | 36 |
| Joe DiPietro | 24 |
| Rich Mecoli | 20 |
| John Leonetti | 20 |
| Rich Smith | 12 |
| Frank Vitale | 6 |
| Joe Gorman | 1 |
| 119 | |
| 1980 | |
| Ed Yocum | 23 |
| Rich Smith | 12 |
| Grubb | 12 |
| Kevin Gentile | 8 |
| John Leonetti | 6 |
| John Celona | 6 |
| Frank Carango | 6 |
| Rich Pennisi | 6 |
| 79 | |
| 1981 | |
| Ralph DiMeo | 78 |
| Tim Barry | 58 |
| Kevin Gentile | 24 |
| Larry Barretta | 24 |
| Kevin Kelly | 8 |
| John Celona | 6 |
| Len Nelson | 4 |
| Joe DiAurisio | 1 |
| 203 | |
| 1982 | |
| Ralph DiMeo | 66 |
| Len Nelson | 52 |
| Kevin Kelly | 26 |
| Larry Barretta | 26 |
| Dwayne Eady | 6 |
| John Bucci | 6 |
| Joe DiAurisio | 2 |
| Joe Fuller | 2 |
| Missing: 2 pts vs. St. Mark's | |
| Missing: 15 pts vs. St. James | |
| Missing: 2 pts vs. West Cath. | |
| Missing: 2 pts vs. SJ Prep | |
| (DiMeo: 14 pts in missing games) | |
| 193 | |
| 1983 | |
| Len Nelson | 180 |
| Brian Colkers | 28 |
| Kevin Kelly | 10 |
| Chuck Barry | 6 |
| Frank Fisher | 6 |
| Safeties | 4 |
| Sean Kelly | 3 |
| Bill Marshall | 2 |
| Missing: 2 pts vs. St. James | |
| Missing: 2 pts vs. West Cath. | |
| Missing: 2 pts vs. Roman | |
| 245 | |
| 1984 | |
| Bill Lamb | 26 |
| Lenny Tenuto | 24 |
| Billy Welch | 20 |
| Frank Fisher | 6 |
| Greg Reynolds | 6 |
| Missing: 6 pts vs. Judge | |
| Missing: 2 pts vs. Carroll (DC) | |
| Missing: 12 pts vs. Roman | |
| 102 | |
| 1985 | |
| Eddie Ross | 14 |
| Bill Lamb | 12 |
| Greg Reynolds | 8 |
| Billy Welch | 8 |
| Bob Bark | 6 |
| Missing: 6 pts vs. Judge | |
| Missing: 6 pts vs. North Cath. | |
| Missing: 12 pts vs. SJ Prep | |
| 72 | |
| 1986 | |
| Daryl Nelson | 38 |
| Greg Reynolds | 24 |
| Jim Clancy | 16 |
| Bob Bark | 14 |
| Charles Clark | 12 |
| Mike Corba | 6 |
| Eddie Ross | 3 |
| Derrick Deburow | 3 |
| 116 | |
| 1987 | |
| Daryl Nelson | 92 |
| Derrick Deburow | 38 |
| Marc Allen | 24 |
| Joe Sheridan | 18 |
| Bob Tropiano | 6 |
| Kevin Larsen | 2 |
| Missing: 2 pts vs. Judge | |
| 182 | |
| 1988 | |
| Joe Black | 36 |
| Joe Sheridan | 24 |
| Barry Sealy | 12 |
| Dante Coccia | 12 |
| Kevin Larsen | 8 |
| Geoff Gabrick | 6 |
| Paul Caserio | 6 |
| Marc Yanga | 6 |
| Scott Esposito | 6 |
| Safety | 2 |
| Mike Polidoro | 1 |
| Missing: 2 pts vs. Roman | |
| 121 | |
| 1989 | |
| Dante Coccia | 26 |
| Shawn Brown | 18 |
| Joe Boylan | 12 |
| Mike Anastasi | 6 |
| Fred Salvatore | 6 |
| Scott Esposito | 6 |
| Mike Polidoro | 4 |
| 78 | |
| 1990 | |
| Dan Gindville | 36 |
| Shawn Brown | 12 |
| Mike Polidoro | 8 |
| John Rex | 8 |
| Ron Panetta | 6 |
| Camillo Lusi | 6 |
| Gil Convento | 6 |
| Garvey | 6 |
| Dom Candito | 6 |
| Bryan Gabriel | 6 |
| 100 | |
| 1991 | |
| Ron Panetta | 48 |
| Ricky Lombardo | 28 |
| Bryan Gabriel | 12 |
| Pat Dio | 12 |
| John Rex | 8 |
| Camillo Lusi | 6 |
| Pomarico | 6 |
| Hetsi Lewandowski | 6 |
| Chris Caserico | 2 |
| Anthony Sheridan | 2 |
| Rocky Burns | 1 |
| Missing: 8 pts vs. Dougherty | |
| Missing: 8 pts vs. Judge | |
| 147 | |
| 1992 | |
| Anthony Sheridan | 46 |
| John Rex | 20 |
| Chris Gedraitis | 14 |
| Ricky Henderson | 12 |
| Carmen Accardo | 12 |
| John Toliver | 12 |
| Pat Dio | 6 |
| Bibbs | 6 |
| Tim Cairy | 6 |
| Bryan Garvey | 6 |
| Chris Girardo | 4 |
| Bill Carberry | 2 |
| 146 | |
| 1993 | |
| Anthony Sheridan | 118 |
| Pat Dio | 24 |
| Bill Carberry | 18 |
| Ray Lombardo | 12 |
| Rob Capaldo | 12 |
| Rocky Burns | 6 |
| Carmen Accardo | 6 |
| Jason Guerrera | 6 |
| John McCullough | 2 |
| Safety | 2 |
| 206 | |
| 1994 | |
| Ray Lombardo | 46 |
| Rich Wisher | 36 |
| Tony Solomon | 36 |
| Ray DeJohn | 18 |
| Leon Williams | 14 |
| Kevin McFadden | 6 |
| Craig Barrett | 6 |
| Matt McCluskey | 6 |
| Harry Dunn | 3 |
| Anastasi | 2 |
| Mike Ferraiolo | 2 |
| Jason Guerrera | 2 |
| Missing: 2 pts vs. Roman | |
| 179 | |
| 1995 | |
| Scott Griffith | 32 |
| Jason Guerrera | 26 |
| Shaheed Calhoun | 18 |
| Matt McCluskey | 12 |
| Mike Ferraiolo | 8 |
| Billy Ray | 8 |
| Tom Panchella | 7 |
| Tim Kapusniak | 6 |
| Tony Solomon | 6 |
| Lenny Morsa | 6 |
| Luqman Williams | 6 |
| Kevin Joyce | 5 |
| Safety | 2 |
| Phil Kramer | 2 |
| 144 | |
| 1996 | |
| Mike Ferraiolo | 36 |
| Kevin Joyce | 34 |
| Tony Solomon | 30 |
| Mike Shoemaker | 24 |
| Lenny Morsa | 12 |
| Dan Borda | 12 |
| Mike Zancolli | 10 |
| Ed Quinn | 8 |
| Joe Gallagher | 7 |
| Jim "Bootsy" Paylor | 6 |
| Shaheed Calhoun | 6 |
| Ray Maturo | 6 |
| Ed McNasby | 6 |
| Tim Kapusniak | 6 |
| Scott Donaghy | 2 |
| Missing: 6 pts vs. SJ Prep | |
| 211 | |
| 1997 | |
| Shaheed Calhoun | 50 |
| Luqman Williams | 32 |
| Masai Skief | 30 |
| Dan Borda | 24 |
| Jason Gargon | 24 |
| Scott Donaghy | 23 |
| Ed Quinn | 12 |
| Tim Kapusniak | 12 |
| Ed McNasby | 6 |
| Safety | 2 |
| Missing: 6 pts vs. West Cath. | |
| 221 | |
| 1998 | |
| Jason Gargon | 30 |
| Scott Donaghy | 27 |
| Dan Borda | 26 |
| Mike Shoemaker | 12 |
| Al Greenman | 6 |
| Ed McNasby | 4 |
| Safety | 2 |
| John Tiska | 2 |
| Mahmoud Kobeissi | 1 |
| 110 | |
| 1999 | |
| Pasquale Narducci | 12 |
| Jason Gargon | 92 |
| Anthony Impagliazzo | 6 |
| Christian Wright | 26 |
| Nick Laska | 6 |
| Bill Corazo | 8 |
| John Tiska | 6 |
| Missing: 7 pts vs. Wood | |
| 163 | |
| 2000 | |
| Pasquale Narducci | 66 |
| Howard Bell | 38 |
| Owen McGuire | 32 |
| Michael Moody | 32 |
| Pat McLaughlin | 20 |
| Anthony Impagliazzo | 17 |
| Ed Lego | 12 |
| Christian Wright | 12 |
| Steve Schiavo | 10 |
| Matt Cella | 7 |
| Bryan Navin | 6 |
| Devont Allen | 6 |
| Mark Meighan | 6 |
| Roy Romarico | 2 |
| Jimmy Porreca | 2 |
| 268 | |
| 2001 | |
| Chris Scott-Peters | 72 |
| Matt Cella | 36 |
| Ed Lego | 32 |
| Michael Moody | 24 |
| Randy Bell | 18 |
| Billy Canady | 12 |
| Al Meacham | 12 |
| Josh Quinlan | 8 |
| Bryan Navin | 6 |
| Mark Meighan | 6 |
| 226 | |
| 2002 | |
| Jimmy Porreca | 162 |
| Richard McMickens | 58 |
| Billy Canady | 46 |
| Jack Hatty | 20 |
| Al Meacham | 12 |
| Dan Concannon | 12 |
| Jon Brady | 12 |
| Mike "Benji" Gillespie | 8 |
| Michael Evans | 6 |
| Alvin Dill | 6 |
| Kenny Brown | 5 |
| Carmen Juliano | 2 |
| Safety | 2 |
| 351 | |
| 2003 | |
| Billy Canady | 94 |
| Frank Baldino | 38 |
| Richard McMickens | 34 |
| Jon Brady | 18 |
| Chris Conroy | 17 |
| Michael Evans | 14 |
| Antoine Stout | 12 |
| Darryl Gillard | 12 |
| Mike Matteo | 8 |
| Bruce Holloman | 6 |
| 253 | |
| Neumann-Goretti Saints | |
| 2004 | |
| Bruce Holloman | 60 |
| Dan Chavis | 24 |
| Hiram Bowman | 20 |
| Kenny Brown | 9 |
| Khaillier Harris-Stevens | 6 |
| Tom Lerro | 6 |
| Mike McLaughlin | 3 |
| Tim Kopicko | 2 |
| Safety | 2 |
| 132 | |
| 2005 | |
| Hiram Bowman | 66 |
| Mark McPherson | 54 |
| Dan Juliano | 24 |
| Anthony Davis | 18 |
| Chuck French | 18 |
| Joe Gionfriddo | 18 |
| Rich Allen | 12 |
| Rich DiGregorio | 12 |
| Ryan Howlett | 6 |
| Dion Smack | 6 |
| Darrell Dulany | 6 |
| Anthony Love | 6 |
| Safeties | 4 |
| 250 | |
| 2006 | |
| Mark McPherson | 72 |
| Anthony Sample | 70 |
| Joe Gionfriddo | 66 |
| Preandre Watson | 24 |
| George Hatton | 18 |
| Adam Malatino | 12 |
| Nick Gianos | 6 |
| Safeties | 4 |
| Mark Hatty | 2 |
| Hakeem "Skiz" Johnson | 2 |
| 276 | |
| 2007 | |
| Hakeem "Skiz" Johnson | 50 |
| Anthony Mastrando | 18 |
| Adam Malatino | 6 |
| Ira Sample | 6 |
| Dion Smack | 6 |
| Will Huff | 4 |
| Frank Coleman | 2 |
| Safety | 2 |
| 94 | |
| 2008 | |
| Anthony Mastrando | 18 |
| Anthony Janelli | 14 |
| Tom McGarrigle | 12 |
| Anthony Krywoschy | 12 |
| Brandon Wimberley | 6 |
| Benny Coppola | 6 |
| Joe Lind | 6 |
| Frank Coleman | 6 |
| Louis Coles | 6 |
| Will Huff | 6 |
| Leo Molara | 4 |
| Safety | 2 |
| 98 | |
| 2009 | |
| Sinclair Whiteman | 24 |
| Will Huff | 19 |
| Anthony Mastrando | 12 |
| Pat Balmores | 12 |
| Eric Neill | 12 |
| Jesse Kinsey | 6 |
| Antwoine Powers | 6 |
| Eric Holt | 6 |
| Mark Stinsman | 6 |
| Sharif Custis | 6 |
| Faheem Williams | 6 |
| 115 | |
| 2010 | |
| Mark Stinsman | 32 |
| Justin Rey | 26 |
| Antwoine Powers | 18 |
| Jamal Custis | 18 |
| Faheem Williams | 14 |
| Eric Neill | 12 |
| Chad McPherson | 12 |
| Eric Holt | 8 |
| Sinclair Whiteman | 8 |
| Benny Coppola | 4 |
| Shane Thomas | 3 |
| John Snyder | 2 |
| 157 | |
| 2011 | |
| Sharif Custis | 48 |
| Antwoine Powers | 42 |
| Jamal Custis | 30 |
| Christian DiFrancesco | 24 |
| Eric Holt | 12 |
| Benny Coppola | 9 |
| Danny Murray | 6 |
| Dean DeJesse | 5 |
| Safeties | 4 |
| 180 | |
| 2012 | |
| Jamal Custis | 68 |
| Sihmare Morgan | 66 |
| Tyliek Raynor | 30 |
| Sharif Custis | 24 |
| Michael Beck | 19 |
| Eric Holt | 18 |
| Khalil Roane | 6 |
| Devan Owens | 6 |
| Michael DiFrancesco | 1 |
| 238 | |
| 2013 | |
| Sihmare Morgan | 80 |
| Khalil Roane | 44 |
| Jamal Custis | 36 |
| Michael Beck | 26 |
| Joseph Richardson | 18 |
| Ray Lenhart | 12 |
| Aamir Brown | 12 |
| Aiden Brown | 6 |
| Emil Moody | 6 |
| Miles Brewer | 6 |
| Jack Taylor | 6 |
| Danny Murray | 6 |
| Safety | 2 |
| Michael DiFrancesco | 1 |
| 261 | |
| 2014 | |
| Khalil Roane | 96 |
| Aamir Brown | 66 |
| Miles Brewer | 32 |
| Michael DiFrancesco | 28 |
| Emil Moody | 20 |
| Ray Lenhart | 14 |
| Takeem Ford | 12 |
| Matt McKeown | 12 |
| Fabian Matthews | 8 |
| Amir Gordon | 6 |
| Joseph Richardson | 2 |
| 296 | |
| 2015 | |
| Khalil Roane | 60 |
| Brandon Pridgen | 28 |
| Gregory Fuller | 24 |
| Maurice Mazzccua | 20 |
| Keith Jenkins | 12 |
| Emil Moody | 10 |
| Gage Caiazzo | 6 |
| Amire Tyler | 6 |
| Zach Treadwell | 2 |
| Safety | 2 |
| 170 | |
| 2016 | |
| Maurice Mazzccua | 18 |
| Aiden Brown | 12 |
| Salvatore Emma | 6 |
| Tre'Sean Bouie | 6 |
| Safety | 2 |
| 44 | |
| 2017 | |
| Chris Wells | 98 |
| Leddie Brown | 84 |
| Jaron Macon | 34 |
| Tre'Sean Bouie | 32 |
| Quadir Monroe | 26 |
| Charles Britt | 26 |
| Kharon Lloyd | 18 |
| Tysheem Johnson | 12 |
| Rausheen Lively | 12 |
| Dymir Cave | 12 |
| Shaddiq Houston | 6 |
| Jayvonne Campfield | 6 |
| Yusuf Proctor | 4 |
| Matt Andrilla | 2 |
| Anthony Gabriel | 2 |
| Tyre Towels | 2 |
| 376 | |
| 2018 | |
| Tysheem Johnson | 92 |
| Malik Griffin | 50 |
| Tre'Sean Bouie | 18 |
| Rausheen Lively | 8 |
| Khaleef Jones | 6 |
| Isaiah Gaddy | 6 |
| Anthony Johnson | 6 |
| Glenn DeLete | 2 |
| Sincere Hall | 1 |
| 189 | |
| 2019 | |
| Tysheem Johnson | 182 |
| Malik Griffin | 92 |
| Damian Gabriel | 38 |
| Marqui Adams | 24 |
| Anthony Johnson | 18 |
| Deuce Johnson | 18 |
| Ubayd Steed | 18 |
| Rausheen Lively | 8 |
| Terry Cameau | 8 |
| Sincere Hall | 6 |
| Naseem Bailey | 6 |
| Ronald Holmes | 6 |
| Roman Brown | 6 |
| Eric Gentry | 6 |
| Khaleef Jones | 4 |
| Safety | 2 |
| 442 | |
| 2020 (one game) | |
| Jayden Sumpter | 6 |
| Solomanie Bambara | 6 |
| Ari Jones | 6 |
| Shawn Battle | 6 |
| Kevin Thomas | 2 |
| Sincere Hall | 2 |
| 2021 Spring (three games) | |
| Unavailable | |
| 2021 Fall | |
| Jayden Sumpter | 86 |
| Jayden Styles | 84 |
| Yazeed Haynes | 40 |
| Colton Calleung | 36 |
| Ahmir Batts | 36 |
| Shawn Battle | 32 |
| Rysheem Johnson | 22 |
| Kevin Thomas | 20 |
| Warren Zaid | 18 |
| Marqui Adams | 18 |
| Malachi Wyche | 16 |
| Samuel Hobbs | 12 |
| Monta Carter | 12 |
| Braheem Jefferson | 8 |
| Xavier Gaban | 6 |
| Anthony Zungolo | 6 |
| Raleigh Collins | 6 |
| Terry Cameau | 6 |
| Yasir Williams | 8 |
| George Truitt | 6 |
| Samier Bromfield | 6 |
| Jasir Jefferson | 4 |
| 488 | |
--